Jump to content


Rugby League World
League Express

Rugby League Yearbook 2014-15

Most Liked Content


#3027577 Australia to never play outside Australia again?

Posted by jacksy on 05 November 2014 - 12:44 PM

Australia Rugby League have today suggested that they will never play outside of Australia again. The Australian side which could possibly miss out on this years Four Nations Final, which is currently scheduled to be played in Wellington on 15th November, made the startling announcement early this morning.

National Rugby League CEO Dave Smith explained further "We feel that rugby league at this level should be played using the best referees in the best stadia. Upon reviewing every single stadium used for rugby league throughout the world it was quickly apparent that the Australian ones are head and shoulders above the ones overseas. From the greenness of the grass to the quality of the hot dogs sold in the stands, our grounds are far superior. International rugby league should be about quality and fairness and we would be letting our players down if we made them play on the insufficient turfs they have abroad... (read more)

When asked about the announcement, New Zealand Director of Operations Scott Carter told us the following, "I haven't seen the statement yet but I wholeheartedly agree with it, completely."

At this stage it is unclear how this will affect this years Four Nations Final, which could still feature Australia, but early reports suggest that if the World Champions qualify it will relocate to Sydney.


In further rugby league news, Australia will wear a commemorative shirt for their decisive Four Nations clash with underdogs Samoa. The black and white hooped shirt which remembers the historic victory over England in the 2014 Four Nations tournament, will come with a brown "swag" bag and a black eye mask.


#2982120 Empty Seats On The Telly.....

Posted by John Drake on 24 August 2014 - 10:59 AM

There are lots of things that could be done differently, but essentially, the only people who can make a real difference to the empty seats problem at Wembley are those sat at home complaining about them every year.

If you don't normally go, start planning your trip to next year's final right now, and make the difference in reducing the numbers of empty seats yourself. There's loads of time to save up, loads of time to persuade others to join you, you'll get to pick where you want to sit and how much you want to pay (you'll get some good early bird deals as well) and you'll have a great day out at one of our sport's biggest and best showpiece events. Even getting there and back doesn't have to prove that big a deal if you plan it early enough.

I'm not lecturing people from the position of having a media freebie here either. I bought and paid for my own tickets (got £32 tix for £22 on one of the RFL offers several months ago), drove myself and friends down there early yesterday morning, sharing the £40 worth of petrol it cost between 3 of us, took sandwiches to save on food costs, parked up at Hillingdon tube station which cost £2 all day, 23 minute direct tube ride to Wembley Park and there you are. Gentle stroll down Wembley Way enjoying the sights and sounds of Cup Final day and bumping into a few old friends along the way, then into the stadium to watch the curtain raiser with a bucket of tea that cost £2.

There's even now a decent shopping mall right next door to the stadium, with lots of food outlets, even a cinema, for something to do after the game without trekking into Central London.

The Cup Final is what we as Rugby League fans make it. The game itself is almost incidental to that. Some years it will be great, others it might be a bit average, but you can have a great day out at the Cup Final regardless. The players provide the main event, but the fans can lift them to greater heights as well.

So basically what I'm saying is: don't waste energy complaining about empty seats at showpiece events like Wembley, or finding reasons not to go (there will always be reasons not to go if you look hard enough to find them regardless of anything the RFL may or may not do to market it) and don't wait to see which teams get there before deciding to go. Commit yourself to the project now, make sure at the very least your own bum is filling a seat next year, then we'll all have less to complain or fret about when the official attendance is announced.

And the more non-Club Wembley seats we fill between us, the more exciting and unmissable an event our Cup Final will start to appear to those who have, but currently choose not to use, their Club Wembley seats on RL Cup Final day.


#3076333 21 Feb: WCS: Wigan Warriors v Brisbane Broncos KO 7.45pm (TV)

Posted by Exiled Wiganer on 22 February 2015 - 08:37 AM

To be honest my night was spoilt before kick off. I sat down and asked the man beside me what he'd paid for his ticket. Full price like me, so began to relax. Then I discovered that his A P R on his credit card was 4 % better than mine. I felt hollow inside.


#2845277 I knew it would happen

Posted by Gerri Monside on 30 November 2013 - 10:31 PM

It's been a dream. A long, deep, pleasant, wonderful dream. It started weeks ago - or to be fair it started on Christmas Day 2012. Santa dropped a gift to me. Two tickets to the World Cup opening ceremony in Cardiff. With accommodation thrown in. And in this dream I thought - "it wont work", "it'll be rubbish"", "the media will laugh at us", "the fans wont show", "Bristol? Bristol? Seriously?". And then I returned to my dream. And then it was October and we were on the train to Cardiff. And we bumped into Stevo & Nobby. And we had a laugh. And the opening ceremony wasn't rubbish. People came. The dancing was great. And we met some great people. And for 20 minutes we had Australia on the rack. But it wasn't to be. So we stayed back and did a Mexican wave. And watched Italy beat Wales. Then it was the long journey home. And we rushed to watch New Zealand v Samoa as Warrington rocked. And then we discovered the delights of Premier Sports and Andrew Voss. Then it was Monday and for a brief moment the dream relented as work took over. Then it was 8pm and Ireland faced Fiji in Rochdale. And the ground was full. And the people were happy. And we thought, "It might be good". Then Scotland went toe to toe. Then USA took out the Cooks. In Bristol. In front of a packed crowd. And we all thought that we were dreaming. And it got better. Huddersfield sold out. Workington sold out again. Leigh sold out. Matches were full of drama. People who had never been to a game wanted to go. And we thought "this is good". And then we had some bell-ringers of matches. And grounds packed out. And we came together. And we went to Wembley. And they needed more tickets. And for 79:38 we thought it was ours for the taking. But it wasn't. We came up so tantalisingly close it hurt. It hurt down to the core of our soul. And we cried. We cried "why. why isn't it us". But we went back into ourselves. We regrouped. And we went to the Theatre of Dreams. And we were treated to a masterclass in how to play a final. And we experienced a record crowd - at the end of a record tournament. And we look back on it all and celebrate the fact that we were there. And four five brief, magical weeks we all agreed on what we all knew already.  This is the greatest game. We are the greatest fans. 

 

And tomorrow, I'm going to wake from this dream.

And I don't want to.

It's been too good. 

 

I don't want this to end. 

 

 




#2840990 23/11/13 - World Cup Semi Final 1: England v New Zealand (Wembley)

Posted by Kenilworth Tiger on 23 November 2013 - 07:21 PM

I refuse to read this thread as I know it will be fill of the same old ###### that gets spouted every time......Sinfield is to blame, the Kiwis didn't care, Mcbana (lol) is useless etc etc etc


So all i will say is this....

Today I witnessed one of the best sporting spectacles I have ever seen in any sport, met some first time RL fans from all over the country and been involved with a team of volunteers who have given up time and money to support our game.

My overriding emotion, soon after complete and utter heartache, was sheer pride in our great game and squad of players who went toe to toe with the world champions.

No one player lost that game - as a team we never closed it out, simple as that.

I am proud England Rugby League supporter tonight


#3064092 Burgess Watch......

Posted by Dunbar on 31 January 2015 - 09:52 PM

I don't subscribe to BT Sports which is where all the televised Bath games have been broadcast so yesterday evening was the first time I have seen Sam Burgess play a game of Union

 

First and foremost, it was an awful game of rugby.  The commentators were obsessed with the fact that it was 50 or 60 minutes into the game that a scrum collapsed and that was the highlight of the match.  It was weird watching the scrums as the Union scrum halves are feeding the scrums so blatantly these days and yet the ref clamped down on it early and the English scrum half had to feed the ball straight.  On several occasions, the ball just sat in the middle of the scrum as the hooker had obviously never hooked a rugby ball in his life

 

Anyway, the joke that is the rugby union scrum is for another thread, this is about Sam Burgess

 

Without wanting to sound cocky, it was exactly as I expected.  Sam Burgess in the centre is simply not a good fit.  He has never had a passing game (occasionally he has shown an off load game but even that is nowhere near the strongest part of his game).  He will get five or six chances to run with the ball in a game of Union if he is lucky and he may dent the defensive line and put his team on the front foot but he has simply never been a flashy player who will catch the eye with these type of touches

 

He was eye catching in League due to his work ethic and his impact over 80 minutes when considering the cumulative effect of his surging runs, his defensive workload and his punishing contact.  He will not get the chance in Union to display these traits unless he plays in the forwards and even then it is a different type of attrition where the workload is so typically done of the ball (not a bad thing, just different)

 

Funnily enough, Sam Burgess may be best suited to the English national team if he gets a chance as they play a style of game that suits big centres who can push through the gain line

 

Sam Burgess has made his choice and he will always be a talented rugby player as he has all the physical attributes and the professionalism to go with it but I suspect he may have thrown away his rugby legacy.  The reason I say this is that I do not think that Union is a game that Burgess can excel at.  He is undoubtedly best suited in the back row of the scrum but this is not an area than Union needs to buy in talent so I suspect he will stay in the centres where his lack of ball skills and footwork will see him exposed by players who are not in his class as a rugby player but more suited to that position

 

The most overriding thing that comes out of this is why do some of the best rugby brains on the planet look at Sam Burgess and think 'Rugby Union centre' when all of his best attributes are wasted in that position

 

He may turn out to be a reasonable success in Union and he may be capped many times by England and win medals and awards but one thing I am confident of is that he will never be as good a Union player as he was a League player because the game does not suit his style (this is not a critique of Union more an acceptance that they are different sports that suit different attributes)




#2967249 Catalans Rumour

Posted by Auntie Linzi Morris on 28 July 2014 - 08:12 PM

I have maintained all along that the RFL wanted the Broncos and the Catalans out of Super League. That in my opinion was why they brought in the 2 team relegation in the hope the Broncos and the Catalans finished in the bottom 2. They got half their wish. The RFL would love Super League to become a M62 corridor competition.

Is it little wonder that we get less print inches in the national papers than we did 15 years with such insular thinking.

 

There's an awful lot of nonsense written on rugby league internet forums and I've lost count of how many times I've shaken my head in disbelief when reading comments over the last few years.

 

But this, by some considerable margin, is in my opinion the daftest piece of ignorant and ill-informed nonsense without any foundation or basis whatsoever that I've had the misfortune to chance upon.




#2856295 London Broncos and future expansion

Posted by willy on 24 December 2013 - 06:16 PM

What holds RL back is its outdated view of itself and its backwards view of the sort of person that would enjoy it

 

The RLWC showed there is an appetite for it outside the flat cap northern enclaves of working classishness!

 

But as ever no one wants to support a losing team, or one that struggles, or one that comes in for so much stick from others within it

 

Geographically we have a large spread across the UK at semi pro level. That needs feeding

 

Its no accident that there are Romanian/polish/Nigerian etc kids killing it in the London academy - absolutely no baggage, don't care about where they play, nothing to do with the good ol british preoccupation with the class system, they just want to play a fast exciting sport

 

So please stop eulogising/patronising etc the London area like it is even remotely the same as anywhere in the north, it isn't.

 

We want success in London? Let London drive it. The problem with that of course is a Londoners priorities making a successful team in a London environment will be a lot different to that in the hinterlands of the Midlands and the North and sadly requires a lot of money and media presence, which don't actually go hand in hand but to a Northern audience seem to

 

The Money because its twice as expensive, the media because large sports concerns across London (soccer etc) blanket the media every single hour of every single day.

 

In my experience Londoners LIKE RUGBY LEAGUE

 

They respond to it, they appreciate it, they even admire it but it has no social or environmental context in their day to day lives

 

Media and Money all else follows

 

Grass roots development? Community ownership?

 

Outdated and outmoded in a city like London where the big sports clubs have overdrafts that dwarf the whole income of RL in one team alone. There is no such thing as 'local' development there.Name one London team of any sport in the spotlight that has 90% London born players?

 

RL should play to its strengths, it is egalitarian in nature, always has been, a mongrel with a rebel spirit. On the frontline of expansion even more so than PNG or Samoa or the USA or Canada, London should be a flagship outpost and should always have had dispensation to sign above the salary cap with extra income from the RFL

 

Same as half the teams in the USA football leagues when the franchises move geographical locations and the top Aussie RL side in the NRL outside of the East coast or the Super 14 RU teams etc etc

 

A level playing field is level only if the context is the same for each club, it isn't ever that simple, never was, and you reap what you sew.

 

London was not allowed to invest properly when it could, now it cant it never will unless the cap can be altered to assist and hopefully another money bags hits the scene to allow this to happen. Otherwise we are lucky to have a London team with no ground of its own, no money and no way to access a level playing field in the first place.




#3043942 Raiders sign 4 on loans

Posted by The Vet on 12 December 2014 - 12:11 AM

In Bullock and Bate are now 2 proven front rowers who if weren't Leigh players would walk into most part time championship team,we all saw what Joe can do and now he's a full timer with a full season of championship rugby behind him he should be great for us,while Bate has played a fair share of 1st grade games in the last couple of years,we eventually get a rough house prop and people are complaining! The other 2 players are obviously good kids as they have been rewarded F/T contracts and are obviously seen as too good for age group rugby,it's ok saying the club aren't learning from mistakes but what mistakes are being made? Every club is looking for quality experienced players but these cost money which we ain't got, it's easy to say its a risk signing inexperience but that's rubbish,every signing any club makes is a risk whether the player is 19 or 29,I would sign 3 hungry young players instead of 1 experienced 'journeyman' everyday,Paul Rowls has a lot of respect for Cresta so he won't be loaning poor players,the way Cresta is doing it is 100% right for me,obviously fans want a winning team but for me the team & club needs to develope over a few years before we are ready to go into the championship


#3018943 "Rugby league's international failure is spectacular"

Posted by Dunbar on 24 October 2014 - 08:13 AM

The problem with Rugby League is that on the day before the major international tournament of the year begins the journalists and fans all start a chorus of international league is dead or dying.  I cannot think of another sport with so much inherent negativity or pessimism

 

People cite the lack of GB and England competitiveness as a reason why League is failing internationally.  While I admit that the single biggest boost to the international game would be a win for England in a major tournament the lack of success should not limit the spectacle of the international fixtures

 

Let me provide an example.  Ireland have never beaten the New Zealand All Blacks at Rugby Union.  That’s right, never beaten them.  And yet when this fixture is scheduled, do we hear great cries of Union journalists and fans saying the game is a waste of time or the Union world cup a meaningless tournament.  Of course we don’t, we hear that International Union is the pinnacle of the sport and a gladiatorial contest etc etc

 

Tomorrow sees the start of a month of great international Rugby League and I can’t wait for 7.00am tomorrow morning

 

There are clearly things to improve and I agree with many of the points in the article but I really do wish RL fans would say something positive about the sport every now and again




#3013679 Red card - Good publicity ?

Posted by Griff9of13 on 14 October 2014 - 10:09 AM

In answer to the question in the OP, it may be more in how the incident is dealt with as much as the incident itself.

 

For me these are the positives we can take from it so far:

The referee acted swiftly and decisively on the spot to dismiss Flower. There was no histrionics from players of either side to try and influence his decision making.
The remaining players from both sides immediately and without question accepted his decision.

Flower walked without even glancing at ref.

The game resumed and was played in reasonably good spirits with no further recriminations from players or spectators.

At the end of the game the Wigan and Saints players mixed and congratulated one another in the usual good spirits. Saints, deservedly, celebrated their win and Wigan quietly left them to get on with it. (this, and those above are nothing less than I'd expect from our game in any circumstances, but maybe should be contrasted with other sports)

Wigan and Flower issue a comprehensive apology as soon as is practically possible. This apology contains no excuses or attempt to mitigate any disciplinary action that will follow.

The RFL announce the charges to be brought and when the disciplinary hearing will be held. Demonstrating that the game of rugby league has a transparent disciplinary process.

Lance Hohaia makes a statement to say there are no hard feelings. Saints say publicly they have no desire to press criminal charges.

The whole fuss being made about this clearly shows that this sort of thing is far from common in the sport of rugby league.




#2944323 Kevin Sinfield awarded MBE in Queen's Birthday Honours List (Merged threads)

Posted by RSN on 14 June 2014 - 12:39 AM

Let's take ability out of the equation for a second.

He is the example of how every sportsman should live their life. He's had so much success but showed so little arrogance. He tries his hardest every week, sets an example for the younger kids and has a massive professionalism about how he acts. .

I don't rate him as a international standard player, but for professionalism as a top level English sportsman and how to set an example would I give an MBE? Most definitely.


#2844717 Dare to dream

Posted by grimesy on 29 November 2013 - 11:23 PM

“...BUT will enthusiasm for the game last beyond the tournament?”

So asked Katherine Downes in a BBC sports feature on the eve of the Rugby League World Cup Final. Of course my selected quote was preceded by a positive introduction on the fact that the final was a sell out. It went on to interview players from both New Zealand and Australia as well as an amateur player from Goucester All Golds. Katherine was introduced by Katie Gornall who asked had the World Cup caught the imagination of the wider public.

Following this clip I routinely did my daily scan of my preferred RL forum site. There was one comment that expressed a favourable view in the media coverage section. Fair enough. But I began to reflect on this tournament. Not about the games, players, tries, crowds etc etc – you will find them elsewhere (though you may have to dig a little). On the opening day of the tournament I went down to the Sports Club in my local village to watch England frustratingly, though not without promise, lose to the greatest rugby team in the world. They are not a brand name – rugby league doesn’t do that. Maybe it should. Well it sort of does. My comment about the greatest rugby side in the world comes naturally and without any hesitation. At the time of writing they are not even the reigning world cup holders. My current favourite band in the word is The Bitter Springs yet no has heard of them. They don’t sell records (they’ve been around a long time). They are not a brand. Yet they have considerable talent. And passion and integrity and honesty. Yes – honesty. Rugby league is an honest game. I grew up watching Wigan beat everyone and anyone – except Australia. I was at Central Park in 1994, 1990, 1986 – we couldn’t quite beat the ‘Unbeatables’ or even, I recall, in 1982, my dad coming back from the match whilst I was at my Auntie Mary’s on a cold dark Tuesday night saying the referee Fred Lindop had robbed us by denying a try by Wigan’s Glynn Shaw and then going on perversely to award Wigan a penalty. My dad said that was a pivotal moment in the future as the Kangaroos went on to literally be “invincible”. Still to this day I fear the green and gold jersey (I sense no fear when I see a black one, with or without any white). Funny as there is a family photo in my dining room on the wall and my wife is wearing it. She is from Sydney. We are all going to the final tomorrow. She says she’s wearing it. I’m wearing my All Golds top. It just seems right. Even after the semi final.

 

There was only one regret after that first game. Not the dropped balls or the decision about Charnley’s foot in touch or not. I hadn’t gone to watch it with my dad. He has Lewy Body dementia now and is in a nursing home. The last three live matches we saw were Wigan winning the Grand Final for the first time in 12 years, losing to St George in the World Club challenge and beating Leeds at Wembley. He was very poorly by then. A day or so later I did some work on the laptop and put 5 live extra on and listened to NZ v Samoa. Something did happen then. I don’t know what. Dave Woods doesn’t usually get me too excited. Maybe it was the Wire crowd. But something happened. And then I discovered I could actually watch the World Cup on Premier Sports online. So I subscribed. And was transfixed. It was breathtaking. It was exciting. It was brutal. It was honest. I wasn’t surprised. It was rugby league. And we all welcomed the Australian commentator Andre Voss into our hearts as he articulated the spectacle before him in a way we have been aching for – for, well, ever. He bellowed that Danny Brough is a “SUPERSTAR”. I cried laughing at "He's left 3 of his ribs on the pitch......somebody cook them up for me with some BBQ sauce....". But he cared. He did. He joked about the pub grub but he went in those pubs and talked to folk.

 

It was just great. The game was alive. I watched the first half of the England v Fiji game with my dad. I should have stayed for the second half. I formed my own opinions about the half back pairings and the rest of it. I read all the comments on the forum. I didn’t join in though. I took my two little kids to England v France. They loved it. Their mother has the temerity to suggest they are half Australian – thus it is my job to brainwash them. At one point I turned to the bloke sitting to the right of my little girl and had a rant about the half backs and the omission of a certain player. He nodded and agreed. I had another rant about something or other. He leaned over and said “I’ve never been to a rugby league game before”. It was brilliant. I said I hoped he enjoyed it and that he would come again.

 

I watched the semi final with my dad. All of it. I got him a beer and had to stir some thickener into it as per orders from the nurse. He didn’t know what was going on. I made the usual mistake of course. I got too excited. I should know better. We were at Elland Road three or four times. The one that stands out was 2004. I was convinced it was our time. Lockyer destroyed us.  I still haven’t got over it. To be honest I haven’t got over Devereux’s missed tackle from ’92 at Wembley. But I still love it. Every month I have to change my password at work. November has been ‘daretodream’. I still will. After the semi final I just kissed my dad and told him I loved him. I couldn’t speak for two days after that. A week later at least I can say I watched it with my dad. That feels good. Better than good. Just like this game.

 

“Will enthusiasm for the game last beyond the tournament? Has it caught the imagination of the wider public?” I’m not going to try and answer these questions. I think they are irrelevant. To be frank they are hypocritical questions from the BBC. It is about more than ‘enthusiasm’ and ‘imagination’ and ‘the wider public’ – whatever that means. To me it’s about heart and courage and belief and spirit and honesty. And that’s just the rest of us, not even the players. Oh and a real sense of community. In the attic is a bottle of whiskey my dad and I bought in Western Australia in 2001 – only to be opened the day GB wins the ashes (well ok I’d go for the WC or a 4 nations). I do believe my day will come. The World Cup has confirmed to me what the game is – gold. All gold. 24 carat. Dare to dream.




#3082935 RIP Ray

Posted by heartofGold on 04 March 2015 - 09:41 PM

I'm trying to tread carefully here but, as I assume TRL will have some contact details for Ray, is there any way any message could be sent to his family? I imagine a phone call would be very difficult but if anybody has other ideas then perhaps a tactful post on here might be apt.

 

I seem to remember "Heart of Gold" started posting after "Goldcard" passed away and she said how much she appreciated reading the tributes on here and how it helped her during a difficult time.

 

Here's hoping.

I remember those first few days very well.  My daughter and I read all the kind tributes for Bill (Goldcard) and it really did give us something to focus on whilst we came to terms with the overwhelming fact that he had left us so suddenly.  Your posts at that time made us laugh and cry but most of all they gave us comfort.  It's true this forum is a community and even a family to some of us and the members and moderators should be very proud of it.  I still log on every day and enjoy reading the wide variety of threads whether they be funny, serious, political, moaning, praising, sad, informative, light hearted etc they all make my day a little better.  TRL meant so much to Bill and since joining I can certainly see why.  I hope Ray's family can gain as much as I did from your respectful feelings on his sad passing. 




#3073821 Bbc and Greg Inglis

Posted by Konkrete on 17 February 2015 - 06:00 PM

Inglis playing Onion in the UK would be a travesty.  I can't think of a more depressing sight than seeing one of the greatest players ever waiting and waiting for the ball to arrive from under the subtle and nuanced fat blokes. Then when the field is open and at his mercy seeing it punted to and fro between full backs like a shuttlecock, as the crowd rah in awe at the skills of the relentless 'box kicks'.

 

Pah!




#3061317 So I found this wallet

Posted by Phil on 26 January 2015 - 03:22 PM

When I was 18 I found a wallet, it had over 3 grand in it.

I handed it in to the local nick who contacted the owner. I was unemployed at the time, he gave me a job and although he has now sadly passed away I'm still friends with his family.


#3059072 Difference between heartland and non heartland fans?

Posted by gogledd on 22 January 2015 - 12:27 PM

i have been a widnes fan all of my life but i admit that i go to watch crusaders when widnes aren't playing as i have adopted them as my second team, their fans are among the most passionate i have ever met in 50 years of watching the game and around 200 turned up at a pre season friendly away at thatto heath and sang all the way through the game in what was virtually a field in sthelens..........

Nice post VW.  Crusaders fans have made a point of enjoying the day out; we'll get behind our team, there will be some friendly rivalry, but at the end we love to meet up with the other fans after the game. We have an unwritten code to welcome away supporters to the Racecourse and the Turf and to promote a family friendly atmosphere so all fans can enjoy their day.

 

A bus load of us went to support Eccles RLFC, as their chairman has travelled miles to watch and support Crusaders and it was a chance for our fans to support an amateur side.

 

There are about a dozen of us who support Catalans Dragons when they play in the UK; that started when Crusaders RL folded and we weren't sure we would have an RL team in North Wales. Now we have lots of French friends and get warmly welcomed at SL grounds because we make the effort to support Catalan.

 

We also travel to Challenge cup, Magic Weekend and the Grand Finals (SL and Championships) and will be going to the Big Bash this year.. hopefully Crusaders will make the League One cup to add to the day.

 

I'd agree that there is a broad range of fans.. those who HATE their opposition and those who will go to any game to support RL. I've only experienced it turning nasty of a handful of occasions and personally I don't particularly want to repeat those experiences; but certainly the enjoyable experiences far outway the negative.




#3044770 Australian schoolboys?

Posted by bar red on 13 December 2014 - 10:59 PM

Cannot believe there are people on here knocking individual players. These are kids who have just beaten the Aussies and should all be congratulated.




#3044593 BBC Sport - Burgess love in

Posted by Exiled Wiganer on 13 December 2014 - 04:15 PM

Here are my thoughts on this sorry story:
- to use our World Cup to set up a move away gives an insight into the sort of person Sam is;
- his refusal to speak to the press and say anything positive about our game reflects similarly poorly on him;
- the whole idea seems madness to me from his and union's perspective. What skills does he have which are transferable? Seemingly not tackling, certainly not his ability to run multiple times at speed and with power, as he will get perhaps 5 runs every match (my mum is fit enough for that), probably not his offload game, which wasn't that great in RL and I doubt is much use in union;
- he will have been super fit and strong while at Souths because he was being superbly conditioned and playing a fantastically demanding sport. That will go, and his body shape will change in the same way as Joel T has come back softer and lacking drive and power. He will lose everything he had by virtue of his environment and the game he played in short order;
- so, given that his only transferable "skills" are possibly an ability to run hard and pass (though again not his forte in league) and some intangible drive and determination, what does he need? Having played a lot of union in the back row and in the centres, unless you have spent thousands of hours knowing what to do in the back row you'll be made to look like a monkey. There are so many people and so many decisions on where to put yourself, where not to put yourself and how, that you simply don't have time to think or you'll be in the wrong place. Surely there are dozens of back row players who would eat him for breakfast at even semi pro level. God help him against a top back row player;
- in the centres he will do far less work than in a quarter of an NRL game, but what he does therefore has to make a difference. While he might make 3 clean breaks in a good game at NRL level, he will perhaps be making 25 carries for those. It'll take him 6 games to see that much ball. So, he had better make every one count. The qualities you need to be an instant success are some combination of huge size, great footwork or electric speed. Sam has none of those - he is big enough but you can't be huge in league because you have so much running around to do;
- so, it makes no sense at all, and I am astonished nobody has pointed this out that I have seen. It isn't a reflection on his skills as a leaguie, as in many respects he was the ultimate modern league forward. It is a reflection on the vast differences between the roles. Union is a combination of highly specialised people undertaking narrowly circumscribed jobs, whereas our game requires a high level of mastery of a much more generic set of skills; and
- finally, it reminds me of the stupidity of signing Panface (now recruiter in chief, to his shame). Again, no transferable skills and few natural attributes that would allow him to master the new ones. It's madness for everyone concerned.


#3031128 15/11/14 - 4N Final - New Zealand v Australia KO 7.45am (GMT)

Posted by nathanwood7 on 11 November 2014 - 10:28 AM

I see Bentham has been selected for the final and going off the stated criteria (the best referee gets the biggest match) he is therefore considered as the best referee once again. An amazing few weeks for Bentham who has gone from being considered the best referee in week 1 (Aus v Nz), to worst referee in week 2 (a warm up match between the police forces), back to best referee in week 3 (Nz v Eng), and now still best referee in the final week (NZ v Aus). In fact the only week that he was considered the worst referee was when Australia faced a do or die match against England. In this week, the Australian referee was the best referee.

 

Bentham must have really turned things around with his performance in that Police forces warm-up game to have suddenly become the best referee again by the following week. Well done Phil.