The fact that the coach identified the need to sign him might suggest he doesn't share your point of view.
I don't dislike Jack. He's an honest lad who puts the graft in, and is very strong near the opposition line. But Ben Kaye offered the team a whole different aspect. Class player.
Yes. I think it's swings and roundabouts, you wouldn't see Kaye burrowing his over the line with four defenders. But kayes distribution and brain I think is quicker. If either player had both they'd be playing regulurly in super league.