47 replies to this topic

[Mumby Magic]

Well the Bulls contracts that I know of are Sheriffe, Worrincy, Menzies and Reardon.

I would keep one of these but which one?

Anyone else up at the end of the season for the Bulls and what about your own clubs?

[hindle xiii]

Well the Bulls contracts that I know of are Sheriffe, Worrincy, Menzies and Reardon.

I would keep one of these but which one?

Anyone else up at the end of the season for the Bulls and what about your own clubs?

Kopczak too, who has actually improved (or stayed at the same level while all those around have fallen).

[hindle xiii]

According to RLFags:

Rikki Sheriffe
Chris Nero
Stuart Reardon
Steve Menzies
Jamie Langley
Michael Worrincy
Craig Kopczak
Steve Crossley
Andy Tate
Joe Wardle
Adam O'Brien
Danny Addy
Vinny Finigan

[hindle xiii]

There isn't a whole lot else out in there to choose from in our price range either!

[hindle xiii]

Besides Worrincy, I'd be prepared to give the rest a chance under Mick Potter, unless we acquire a few more wingers who are decent enough. If we don't I'd be prepared to give Sheriffe and Reardon a chance.

[Mumby Magic]

According to RLFags:

Rikki Sheriffe
Chris Nero
Stuart Reardon
Steve Menzies
Jamie Langley
Michael Worrincy
Craig Kopczak
Steve Crossley
Andy Tate
Joe Wardle
Adam O'Brien
Danny Addy
Vinny Finigan

I'd be a bit tough and keep the highlighted ones personally.

Thought Scruton was linked with the Rhinos again? Is he still in contract?

[Mumby Magic]

Besides Worrincy, I'd be prepared to give the rest a chance under Mick Potter, unless we acquire a few more wingers who are decent enough. If we don't I'd be prepared to give Sheriffe and Reardon a chance.

No you wouldn't. *snaps Hindle out of trance*

[matt newsholme]

According to RLFags:

Rikki Sheriffe
Chris Nero
Stuart Reardon
Steve Menzies
Jamie Langley
Michael Worrincy
Craig Kopczak
Steve Crossley
Andy Tate
Joe Wardle
Adam O'Brien
Danny Addy
Vinny Finigan

are the ones I'd keep. Think sheriffe could improve under a different coach and with a better center.

big question mark for me is menzies. undoubtedly one of our best players but taking a valuable quota spot, similar situation to morrison last year, If a top nrl center or half was available then I could see menzies going to accomodate them. otherwise retain him for a year. Nero is still a decent center and better than our other options at moment and doesnt count on quota next year so retain unless we have someone better coming in.
Koppy has shown enough this year to warrant at least another year under a new coach. I'd give all the youngsters at least another year. wardle, addy and finigan have all impressed in 1st team and whilst o'brien and tate havent debuted yet I've heard good reports for both from u'20s games. plus youngsters will be relatively cheap.
What I'd like to see us do is copy rhinos policy and give the particularly promising ones long 5 yr deals on slightly higher deals than we would normally offer.
This was policy rhinos used to tie down the core of their current team on long and relatively cheap over the length of the deal contracts.

[Mumby Magic]

are the ones I'd keep. Think sheriffe could improve under a different coach and with a better center.

big question mark for me is menzies. undoubtedly one of our best players but taking a valuable quota spot, similar situation to morrison last year, If a top nrl center or half was available then I could see menzies going to accomodate them. otherwise retain him for a year. Nero is still a decent center and better than our other options at moment and doesnt count on quota next year so retain unless we have someone better coming in.
Koppy has shown enough this year to warrant at least another year under a new coach. I'd give all the youngsters at least another year. wardle, addy and finigan have all impressed in 1st team and whilst o'brien and tate havent debuted yet I've heard good reports for both from u'20s games. plus youngsters will be relatively cheap.
What I'd like to see us do is copy rhinos policy and give the particularly promising ones long 5 yr deals on slightly higher deals than we would normally offer.
This was policy rhinos used to tie down the core of their current team on long and relatively cheap over the length of the deal contracts.

Interesting. Nero you maybe right but what annoys me by him is that he COULD be one of the best centres in SL if he could be arsed. He's almost our top try scorer and hasn't even put the effort in consistently. Disagree about Koppy. He's classed as one of our main 4 props now and he's been nowhere apart from a couple of recent games. It's the Matt Cook syndrome, how many chances will he get to prove that he is only average at best?

Wardle is your dark horse. Not going to set the world alight but won't put a foot wrong ala James Evans for one.

As far as wings go, latest rumours is Potter will bring at least one first teamer from Saints with him and I've heard it's Gardiner.

[hindle xiii]

Interesting. Nero you maybe right but what annoys me by him is that he COULD be one of the best centres in SL if he could be arsed. He's almost our top try scorer and hasn't even put the effort in consistently. Disagree about Koppy. He's classed as one of our main 4 props now and he's been nowhere apart from a couple of recent games. It's the Matt Cook syndrome, how many chances will he get to prove that he is only average at best?

Wardle is your dark horse. Not going to set the world alight but won't put a foot wrong ala James Evans for one.

As far as wings go, latest rumours is Potter will bring at least one first teamer from Saints with him and I've heard it's Gardiner.

Nero is very much an attacking centre, and must be the reason why our left wingers (Reardon and Halley) haven't been crash-hot while outside him. He invariably takes the tackle, while making metres yes, but won't look to pass except only on the odd occasion. Senior he isn't.

And Gardner? Pretty much every Saints fan on here wants to see the back of him, probably the same as our wingmen, however without a Gidley and especially with a Nero (if Gardner would be switched from right wing) he is poop. I'd stick with Reardon.

[The Best The Beautiful The Only]

Sack Worrincy, sign Elima.

[snapski]

i think bratfud should give worrincy a new 5 year contract, as a thank you to the rest of rugby league

[Lee]

Wont be a rush to sign any of that lot up with the exception of maybe a couple of the young uns

[jackknife]

any one know who is out of contract for cas at the end of this season? do u know kenny?

[Exiled Wiganer]

Assuming this isn't a Bradford thread, I think the way things are looking at Wigan, we have...
OUTS - Feca, Phelps, Pryce, Piggy, Deacon and Bailey (4 overseas)
INS - Finch, Hoffman, Lima and Hock (3 overseas)
I suspect we will play Charnley and Marsh a lot more, but may need some additional half back cover. I would like us to sign Ratchford, a good Wigan lad with some talent. Apparently we will have a quota space left over, but I am hoping we don't fill it. I am assuming we re-sign Fielden on a smaller contract. He certainly sounded happy enough with Wigan last night.

[terrywebbisgod]

Leeds don't have any as far as I know, and did last night show it.

[The Boy Saint]

As far as wings go, latest rumours is Potter will bring at least one first teamer from Saints with him and I've heard it's Gardiner.

Please please please let that be true!

From what ive heard the following are out of contract at Saints:

Flannery - GET RID
Meli - GET RID
Chris Dean - GET RID
Nick Fozzard - Keep
Paul Wellens - Keep
Leon Pryce - Keep
Maurie Fa'asavalu - Signed for Quins RU
Keiron Cunningham - retired (Coach)
Matt Gidley - Retired
Matty Smith - Signed for Salford

[nath155]

wouldnt mind pryce if hes out of contract

least were finally getting rid of rubbish like demetriou and cooke at the end of the season

think well keep hold of leanno he looks like a monster
glesson gone
blanch gone

but jamie maloney from the new zealand warriors could be a good addition at scrum half
scott wheeldon from hull kr could also be another good singing a good young prop and then get rid of moore and im happy

Edited by nath155, 01 August 2010 - 02:24 AM.

[matt newsholme]

Interesting. Nero you maybe right but what annoys me by him is that he COULD be one of the best centres in SL if he could be arsed. He's almost our top try scorer and hasn't even put the effort in consistently. Disagree about Koppy. He's classed as one of our main 4 props now and he's been nowhere apart from a couple of recent games. It's the Matt Cook syndrome, how many chances will he get to prove that he is only average at best?

Wardle is your dark horse. Not going to set the world alight but won't put a foot wrong ala James Evans for one.

As far as wings go, latest rumours is Potter will bring at least one first teamer from Saints with him and I've heard it's Gardiner.

koppy is probably never going to be a top class prop. he is however a decent solid one with some improvement left in him which hopefully a new coach can bring out. And he has benefits of being homegrown and relatively cheap which tips balance in his favor imo. Ideally we'd have 4 lynch/scrutons in team but financially we cant afford that.

interesting about gardner. surely meli would be a more likely target for us as he's OOC and seems a more typical bulls style winger. cant see us paying a transfer fee for gardner.

[Mumby Magic]

koppy is probably never going to be a top class prop. he is however a decent solid one with some improvement left in him which hopefully a new coach can bring out. And he has benefits of being homegrown and relatively cheap which tips balance in his favor imo. Ideally we'd have 4 lynch/scrutons in team but financially we cant afford that.

interesting about gardner. surely meli would be a more likely target for us as he's OOC and seems a more typical bulls style winger. cant see us paying a transfer fee for gardner.

I'd have either Meli or Gardiner to be honest. Yes Saints fans dn't like either but they are consistently top of the table and can be picky!! I didn't like Langley too much when we were in our pomp but his workrate this year has hlped us immensely. One thing we have lacked this year is a winger to come in and work. Sheriffe tries but my farts have more chance of breaking a tackle.

And to answer someone earlier in the thread it's about any club.