28 replies to this topic

[jamesb0551]

In addition to that 'nasty ' shot from Manning , would you be so kind as to post an additonal clip , obviously you have the full 80 mins available , approx 10 minutes into the 2nd half there is a shot with the forearm by a certain Rob Roberts on Paul Mennell , i would appreciate it if you could post that clip too then we can make comment on that 'nasty ' tackle .

Cheers James .

Have done

CLICK

Ive slowed that one and mannings tackles right down make your own judgments

[Mark B]

Have done

CLICK

Ive slowed that one and mannings tackles right down make your own judgments

James , its not that one , Batley are attacking downhill in the 2nd half and its on the left hand side of the field with Mennell and Rob Roberts with a very cheap shot im sure you can find it if you look close enough . Close to 10-15 minutes in the second half

Cheers James .

[jamesb0551]

James , its not that one , Batley are attacking downhill in the 2nd half and its on the left hand side of the field with Mennell and Rob Roberts with a very cheap shot im sure you can find it if you look close enough . Close to 10-15 minutes in the second half

Cheers James .

ill have look coudnt find i last time,was it penalised?

[potato ram]

Have done

CLICK

Ive slowed that one and mannings tackles right down make your own judgments

Accident or deliberate? I think Dane will be missing a couple of "real games " for his actions in a "practice" match.

[jamesb0551]

James , its not that one , Batley are attacking downhill in the 2nd half and its on the left hand side of the field with Mennell and Rob Roberts with a very cheap shot im sure you can find it if you look close enough . Close to 10-15 minutes in the second half

Cheers James .

Cant find it Mark if you get hold of a copy and give me a precise time ill put it up.

[bored]

looking at it it does look as though it was a high shot.when they take the penalty does he not lead with his elbow,ball in left arm leading with right elbow raised,and in the ensuing meelee does mr.buchanan not drop the nut in while he's on his knees.so really you could watch the whole game in slow motion and pick up loads of incidents.

[Ossy]

What is the point in continuing this? Deliberate or not, Manning went on report and the decision won't be made on here. I did have a couple of words with Keegs after the game, his mouth was a mess, but he was chatting happily with a number of fans and Dogs players upstairs in the bar, and as far as I'm concerned that's what's important.

Rugby League is a hard game played by hard men and personally that's the reason I enjoy watching it.

Oz.

[distantdog]

What is the point in continuing this? Deliberate or not, Manning went on report and the decision won't be made on here. I did have a couple of words with Keegs after the game, his mouth was a mess, but he was chatting happily with a number of fans and Dogs players upstairs in the bar, and as far as I'm concerned that's what's important.

Rugby League is a hard game played by hard men and personally that's the reason I enjoy watching it.

Oz.

Quite right too. For me as a Batley supporter it was a disappointing way to end the match but glad to hear that he is ok and that both teama were talking and socializing together.

[ANDYPK]

Video says 2nd Jan 2010 !