49 replies to this topic

[Tommy The C5t]

Scenario One:

It's the final game of the inaugural Magic Weekend and you have been given control of the derby between two evenly matched sides and you feel confident that you can handle the high intensity that comes with such a prestigious fixture.

Team L are trailing team B by 36 points 38 in the final 60 seconds, with team L in possession attacking just inside team B's half.

Suddenly the team L player losses control of the ball as the tackle is about to be completed 40m out from team B's try line, but the ball travels back as the tackle is made and a player from team B recovers the now loose ball.

The player from team B who now has the ball was back the 10m at the previous play the ball.

You look at the near side touch judge who waves the flag indicating play on but suddenly the video referee offers you his opinion via the communication earpiece and he says that the team B player was offside as when the team L player lost possession during the tackle attempt, the ball was directed and helped forward by one of the team B players making the tackle implying that the team B player with the ball was offside.

What do you do? You are the referee so it's over to you................

[terrywebbisgod]

I'd give a penalty to team L.They would kick for goal,hit the post and the full back would streak through to score the match winning try.Job done.Next one please.

[Tommy The C5t]

I'd give a penalty to team L.They would kick for goal,hit the post and the full back would streak through to score the match winning try.Job done.Next one please.

You are wrong, care to try again.

[terrywebbisgod]

You are wrong, care to try again.

Can't be,Refs never are.

[Tommy The C5t]

Can't be,Refs never are.

Come on you along with myself know the rules. Concentrate on this paragraph

You look at the near side touch judge who waves the flag indicating play on but suddenly the video referee offers you his opinion via the communication earpiece and he says that the team B player was offside as when the team L player lost possession during the tackle attempt, the ball was directed and helped forward by one of the team B players making the tackle implying that the team B player with the ball was offside.

[terrywebbisgod]

Come on you along with myself know the rules. Concentrate on this paragraph

You look at the near side touch judge who waves the flag indicating play on but suddenly the video referee offers you his opinion via the communication earpiece and he says that the team B player was offside as when the team L player lost possession during the tackle attempt, the ball was directed and helped forward by one of the team B players making the tackle implying that the team B player with the ball was offside.

Back 10 for dissent.Next time your in the bin,old son.

[Old Frightful]

Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!

FFS....Let it go.

[Tommy The C5t]

Back 10 for dissent.Next time your in the bin,old son.

None of the team L/team B players give you dissent.

[terrywebbisgod]

None of the team L/team B players give you dissent.

You did, and I'm the ref.10 minutes.

[southstand loiner]

i pull the bloody earpeice out and referee the game myself just like all refs should do.

any reason you use team B and team L instead of A and B ?.

[Dave T]

ffs

[Tommy The C5t]

Scenario Two:

You have been demoted by your head of referees for poor performance in a previous game that caused both coaches to speak out at your handling of the game. You now have been appointed to referee a Challenge Cup 2nd fixture involving two conference sides, team F and team S.

Team S are attacking 20m out from team F's tryline when on the last tackle team S put boot to ball.

The ball is fielded by team F's fullback who takes the ball and tackle just 1m from the team F tryline.

The fullback in his hastiness to get his team moving plays the ball at an angle of 20 degrees to the right of the original tackle and in his hastiness hasn't checked to make sure that an acting half back was present when the attempt to the play ball began.

Resulting in the front marker for Team S diving behind the tackled player playing the ball and reaching the ball over the try line in a clean act.

What do you do? You are the referee so it's over to you................

[terrywebbisgod]

Scenario Two:

You have been demoted by your head of referees for poor performance in a previous game that caused both coaches to speak out at your handling of the game. You now have been appointed to referee a Challenge Cup 2nd fixture involving two conference sides, team F and team S.

Team S are attacking 20m out from team F's tryline when on the last tackle team S put boot to ball.

The ball is fielded by team F's fullback who takes the ball and tackle just 1m from the team F tryline.

The fullback in his hastiness to get his team moving plays the ball at an angle of 20 degrees to the right of the original tackle and in his hastiness hasn't checked to make sure that an acting half back was present when the attempt to the play ball began.

Resulting in the front marker for Team S diving behind the tackled player playing the ball and reaching the ball over the try line in a clean act.

What do you do? You are the referee so it's over to you................

Enough.Yawn.

[Tommy The C5t]

i pull the bloody earpeice out and referee the game myself just like all refs should do.

any reason you use team B and team L instead of A and B ?.

Just what came into my head. Just like scenario two has team F and team S.

[terrywebbisgod]

Just what came into my head. Just like scenario two has team F and team S.

I see you're not getting any bites over at Southstander.com.

[Tommy The C5t]

I see you're not getting any bites over at Southstander.com.

I'm not after any bites.

The Observer has a very good "you are the ref/umpire" section in the sports pullout and I thought I would translate that on here.

[southstand loiner]

Just what came into my head. Just like scenario two has team F and team S.

right so explain again what happened in the saints v fev cuptie ?

[1976PMJwires]

It's not acceptable to call anyone's decisions

[Tommy The C5t]

right so explain again what happened in the saints v fev cuptie ?

I don't know as I wasn't at the game and since when have St Helens and Featherstone been conference sides?

[terrywebbisgod]

I'm not after any bites.

The Observer has a very good "you are the ref/umpire" section in the sports pullout and I thought I would translate that on here.

Right, that's it,of you go,early bath