TBF I don't think it excites anyone - but a statement such as 'anyone who is CC standard shouldn;t be on SL books is nonsense'.
Most of the DR players will be young lads looking to make the step up.
The only way your first statement can ever make sense is by registering the whole SL squad as dual reg. and that is the only way you can justify calling my post the way you did. I also strongly disagree because of the precise opposite, in that most lads who would justifiably be classed as DR will not, have not and never will make the "step up". It is a fraction that make it, not the majority
And I reiterate that the DR of the whole squad is like walking into Ratners and asking for a gold chain. Is it gold or not? If it is treat at such and keep it's value high. If it's not then don't pretend it is. Don't devalue your premium products! The parallel with this debacle and the debate about the size of SL rings true here also.
If you really want a truely Super League then do not devalue the quality. Surely this is something that most fans of SL crave, high quality stars that people admire. So it seems an oxymoron to me to be able to crave and even demand high quality but then state that sub standard SL players should still be in SL squads and that even SL standard players should be DR's.
Edited by Ackroman, 30 January 2013 - 12:01 AM.