304 replies to this topic

[Gav Wilson]

Highly unlikely.

Thank you for that insightful input but we would still like to try if thats all the same to you...

[foozler]

Very interesting article about the finances of sub Premiership English soccer. Funnily enough no mention of it on the BBC sports pages!


http://www.telegraph...llion-debt.html

£68m v £1billion!

[Griff]

Gazzer Got offered a far better job at Leeds Rhinos with a good financial backer, he left The Eagles in a good position (Work was needed to be done) the RFL sh it on the Eagles by coupling them up with Huddersfield.

The RFL did not couple Sheffield with Huddersfield. Fact.

[The Parksider]

And the Grix brothers, Ben Kavanagh at Widnes.
But Parkies point still stands. The Wigan area does create more SL players than Halifax. They produce more SL players than any other area in the country including Leeds.

Thank you.

It's important to compare like with like.

I have used the definition of top players being in the 1-17 shirts.

If anyone wants to add a good kid from halifax has the No. 25 shirt at so and so tu up the Halifax ante, then I'd have to add on the many more good kids from Wigan who are fringe SL players.

But it's not a dig at Fax.

I just find it astounding clubs who are in areas where NO SL PLAYERS or maybe the odd one in the last five years are born and bred and make it as pro's are suggested as SL candidates.

Fantasy stuff.

[keighley]

It happened at Widnes - 3,500 went on to become an SL loss making 6,000

It happened at leigh - 3,000 went on to become an SL loss making 4,800

It happened in cas - 5,000 went on to become an SL loss making 7,000

it happened at HKR - 3,500 went on to become an SL loss making 7,500

it happened at Workington 3.700 stagnated in SL and stayed at a loss making 3,700

It happened at Huddersfield 2,600 went on to be an SL loss making 7,800

it happened in Wakefield 2,500 went on to become an SL loss making 6.000

It happened at Salford 2,300 went on to become a loss making 5,800

It happened at Oldham 3,900 ended up at 3,600 in Superleague

It happened at Halifax 5,600 ended up at 2,900 in Superleague.

It would have happened at keighley, Dewsbury, Hunslet, and it is yet to happen at featherstone that none of them would have/will produce 10,000 self sustaining crowds.

What is it they say "statistics, statistics and the damn truth"

And yet 6 of those teams are still in SL at this moment. That's the damn truth.

I was watching a DVD last night of a packed Thrum Hall and also the Shay with Halifax playing sime great rugby and beating the best SL had to offer at the time. I know what subsequently happened obviously but the images were very positive. A return with decent management would be a positive in my book.

[keighley]

It doesn't make them successful at all as what you miss is that these lads don't come from Halifax RLFC they come from Halifax Junior ARL.

And the ones at Wigan don't come from Wigan amateur RL ?

[keighley]

I am not going to throw you any more fish because it's plain to me that you can neither accept sound reason or logic. The facts and figures do NOT lie, but no matter what anyone tells you it appears you hate to be wrong, which to me makes it totally unreasonable to be able to hold any kind of sensible debate with someone like you.

You cannot use Keighley as a comparison either - some of your sports fans support Burnley!!

Just get it through your head - York and Rugby League do not mix, never have and never will. There is no fairytale ending to this in which all the townsfolk fall asleep and are awoken by a magic fairy who has sprinkled them wth rugby dust making them all suddenly big fans.

Personally, I think you just like to argue with people, even when you are wrong.

York and RL have mixed since 1895 or 6. That the club has never set the league in fire in the past is immaterial to what might happen in the future given the right circumstances. After their reformation as York Knights there was a wave of optimisim and enthusiasm and they were pulling in decent crowd in CC1. That this was not sustained is true but the possible potential for the game in York were demonstrated.

You just don't know that I am wrong. I am speculating that York could be a successful RL city you are denying that to be so. Neither of us knows the future.

Swinton and Hunslet were giants of the game but now are struggling A teams but if I was to take on board your theories then, because they were great in the past, this should continue into the future but obviously this is not so. So when you say York has not been a big RL City in the past and so will continue in that vein, this is clearly not a given. it might be but equally it might not.

Were the folk of Perpignan sprinkled with fairy dust or was there some other reason that they went from a struggling, dying club in the French league to a top tier SL club ?

Statistics from the past prove nothing with regards to the future. they may support a particular line of argument but they are not infallible.

If you don't want to debate then don,t. people like you who think they are right all the time are particularly annoying to those of us who are

[Wolford6]

Harrogate RUFC are rumoured to face being made homeless, and RU has always had a big following in the town.

Between them York and Harrogate could support a dual-franchise club.

[keighley]

Harrogate RUFC are rumoured to face being made homeless, and RU has always had a big following in the town.

Between them York and Harrogate could support a dual-franchise club.

I lived and worked in Harrogate and the demographics of the town are definitely not the demographics of RL. Just why they have abandoned RU as well is indeed a mystery.

[foozler]

Harrogate RUFC are rumoured to face being made homeless, and RU has always had a big following in the town.

Between them York and Harrogate could support a dual-franchise club.

No they're not. Whilst they have lived on a knife edge for a while, they now have plans for a very decent new facility just outside the town which looks similar to the West Park development and my understanding is that it will happen.

As for a dual franchise club, I sincerely doubt it. Whilst it is fairly fertile RU territory, you see plenty of Rhinos tops out and about and I'm sure if the Rhinos put on a youth training session on the Stray that they would get a very decent turn out indeed.

[foozler]

No they're not. Whilst they have lived on a knife edge for a while, they now have plans for a very decent new facility just outside the town which looks similar to the West Park development and my understanding is that it will happen.

As for a dual franchise club, I sincerely doubt it. Whilst it is fairly fertile RU territory, you see plenty of Rhinos tops out and about and I'm sure if the Rhinos put on a youth training session on the Stray that they would get a very decent turn out indeed.

[The Parksider]

And yet 6 of those teams are still in SL at this moment.

Yes they are. I thought it pretty much a given that above the top six or seven nobody else can sustain Superleague without the help of rich directors. Why don't you get this??

Edited by The Parksider, 30 January 2013 - 06:04 PM.

[The Parksider]

And the ones at Wigan don't come from Wigan amateur RL ?

Yes they do but enough are produced to sustain a Superleague team. Why don't you get this?

[Marauder]

There is 4 not 3 at Huddersfield first team- Stuart Fielden, Joe Wardle, Luke Robinson, Jacob Fairbank. There another couple knocking around at other clubs like O´Brien at Bradford and then theres obviously Gareth Widdop at Melbourne.

The Grix boys are from Halifax

[longboard]

The Grix boys are from Halifax

Scott Grix is a Huddersfield regular and is now one of the senior players. He's inked in to play full back this season.

[The Parksider]

I lived and worked in Harrogate and the demographics of the town are definitely not the demographics of RL.

But you don't know this do you? The past is history as you say and no indication of the future??

Surely now Rhinos have got Harrogate people on board as fans the game could spread if you put the Union club in Superleague.

York is close to Harrogate there's a direct railway line. Over a quarter of a million potential fans

How do you know if we don't try it?

Am I ringing Mr Barwick or you???

[nadera78]

Very interesting article about the finances of sub Premiership English soccer. Funnily enough no mention of it on the BBC sports pages!


http://www.telegraph...llion-debt.html

£68m v £1billion!

Cardiff City have debts of GBP83million. That's one Championship football club carrying more debt than the entire sport of Rugby League.

[JohnM]

never fear....Riley will be on their case........!

Edited by JohnM, 31 January 2013 - 10:13 AM.

[Terry Mullaney]

Am I ringing Mr Barwick or you???

Both of you wait until Fev have got in first!

[John Rhino]

York and RL have mixed since 1895 or 6. That the club has never set the league in fire in the past is immaterial to what might happen in the future given the right circumstances. After their reformation as York Knights there was a wave of optimisim and enthusiasm and they were pulling in decent crowd in CC1. That this was not sustained is true but the possible potential for the game in York were demonstrated.

You just don't know that I am wrong. I am speculating that York could be a successful RL city you are denying that to be so. Neither of us knows the future.

Swinton and Hunslet were giants of the game but now are struggling A teams but if I was to take on board your theories then, because they were great in the past, this should continue into the future but obviously this is not so. So when you say York has not been a big RL City in the past and so will continue in that vein, this is clearly not a given. it might be but equally it might not.

Were the folk of Perpignan sprinkled with fairy dust or was there some other reason that they went from a struggling, dying club in the French league to a top tier SL club ?

Statistics from the past prove nothing with regards to the future. they may support a particular line of argument but they are not infallible.

If you don't want to debate then don,t. people like you who think they are right all the time are particularly annoying to those of us who are

Just out of interest what's the population of Perpignan compared to York?