134 replies to this topic

[distantdog]

Wasn't there a touch from a Catalan player as they moved the ball out to the wing and therefore he was playing advantage. No advantage accrued so he took it back to the scrum. I think the Sky clowns have missed it and the ref and touchy are right

[Johnoco]

Listening on 5Live and Dave Woods and Iestyn Harris both slating this decision.

[jannerboyuk]

Sometimes I wonder why defences bother in this game when they break a neck to cover the tackle, the ball is dropped in a Warrington hand nowhere near the cats player, ref in perfect position...and he gives a knock on. Utter, utter shyte! Now that's a farce

[shun]

that was nice though. good try!!!!

[chuffer]

Wasn't there a touch from a Catalan player as they moved the ball out to the wing and therefore he was playing advantage. No advantage accrued so he took it back to the scrum. I think the Sky clowns have missed it and the ref and touchy are right

Shouldnt it have gone to vid though?

[shun]

Wasn't there a touch from a Catalan player as they moved the ball out to the wing and therefore he was playing advantage. No advantage accrued so he took it back to the scrum. I think the Sky clowns have missed it and the ref and touchy are right

maybe, i missed that, half time will tell us

[jannerboyuk]

Wasn't there a touch from a Catalan player as they moved the ball out to the wing and therefore he was playing advantage. No advantage accrued so he took it back to the scrum. I think the Sky clowns have missed it and the ref and touchy are right

thats the kind of crappy advantage they play in union, they had the advantage - a chance to score! They bombed it tough luck. If that's the rule then its a crappy rule

[Lionheart_merged]

Another dre rferee/touch judge decsion killed off the game. Spolt the spectacle for me.

[Dave T]

Interesting point about the advantage - not seen anything.

Very nice try from Myler.

[Walter Ego]

that was nice though. good try!!!!

Just ###### defense.

[shun]

16-0 warrington

[chuffer]

thats the kind of crappy advantage they play in union, they had the advantage - a chance to score! They bombed it tough luck. If that's the rule then its a crappy rule

I agree......if they play advantage and then go in touch surely thats adv over?

[shun]

thats the kind of crappy advantage they play in union, they had the advantage - a chance to score! They bombed it tough luck. If that's the rule then its a crappy rule

AGREE!!!!!

[jannerboyuk]

I'm gonna go for i) Westwood to punch Webb, ii) Elima to punch Westwood.

This isn't gonna be a classic, pitch too heavy and already a willy-waggling precedent set. Something tells me 'niggly' will be a decent summation.

i thought it was brewing up to be a classic of its type but cats are a classic if their heads drop they fold kind of team. Need some steel if they want to win trophies

[hindle xiii]

Touched it more than f"cking Michael Withers did...

[Just Browny]

Christ these two teams are ill-disciplined.

Agree, a top side like the Bulls will tear us open.

[Dave T]

So seems it was the right call!

Surely people here know about the new advantage rule?

[distantdog]

I agree, the advantage should have been over, however, that's what happened and that's why he did it. And our so called experts on Sky missed it.

Edited by distantdog, 15 February 2013 - 08:40 PM.

[Dave T]

I agree......if they play advantage and then go in touch surely thats adv over?

no - not this year

[shun]

webb is in the bin!