72 replies to this topic

[PREPOSTEROUS]

Depends, your late score and no score both came through the spot Jerry would have been defending


Wakey lacked composure and accuracy in the pass

The giants thought it would be an easy game and failed to respect possession or the opposition

Game was there to be won by Wakey and they failed. EoS

2 points to the giants who need to improve a lot for the next couple of games

I can agree with that. At one stage there was 20 minutes to go and Trinity were playing as though there were 20 seconds left

Definitely two points lost.

[Steve May]

Huddersfield must be finally starting to become a "big club" if the refs are beginning to intervene to win them tight matches.

[Steve May]

Watched super league fulltime and luke robinson's pass for Jermaine McGillvary's second try is at least three metres forward

Eight metres forward seemed to be the Wakey consensus on RLFans last night.

[Wollo Wollo Wayoo]

Depends, your late score and no score both came through the spot Jerry would have been defending

Hell of a defender then! Last score was right on the touchline, disallowed was at the side of the right hand post.

This, and your post regarding Mc's injury suggest you weren't actually at the game?

[Wollo Wollo Wayoo]

Huddersfield must be finally starting to become a "big club" if the refs are beginning to intervene to win them tight matches.

Since the inception of Super League there's been a hell of a lot of "intervention" in many on and off field areas.

[hindle xiii]

http://www.youtube.c...p8oheT6XCtjPf2A

[bobbruce]

Watched super league fulltime and luke robinson's pass for Jermaine McGillvary's second try is at least three metres forward, LR passes the ball before the line and JM catches it 2.5 to 3 metres after it!!! and Tim smiths pass to Lee Smith which was dissallowed looks flat at worst!!! very dissapointed....

Just watched it on SL full time but you can't tell whether or not it's a forward pass from that angle. Does go from the line to in front but it doesn't really tell you anything.

[OMEGA]

Just watched it on SL full time but you can't tell whether or not it's a forward pass from that angle. Does go from the line to in front but it doesn't really tell you anything.

It tells you that LR throws the pass just before the ten metre line and JM catches it 2.5 to 3metres after it, Robinson isn't really travelling forward that much so no momentum argument can be made.

Forward pass, end of!

I won't argue that the Smith to Smith pass was'nt forward I'd just like to see even handed refereeing especially on decisions that so acutely affect the result

Edited by OMEGA, 25 February 2013 - 05:03 PM.

[Ant]

The offload to mathers for Wakey's first try looked forward from those hightlights

And every tackle wakey made in those highlights could arguably have been penalised for holding down

Ref was equallty poor for both teams it looks and Wakey lacked composure to take down the league leaders

[bobbruce]

It tells you that LR throws the pass just before the ten metre line and JM catches it 2.5 to 3metres after it, Robinson isn't really travelling forward that much so no momentum argument can be made.

He isn't really travelling forward you must be watching a different clip to me.

[Ant]

Difference between jerry's try and the Wakey no try = Robinson was moving forward, the wakey passer was moving sideways, if hed been going forward it might have been given and Wakey win - then again he might not have found the pass

[superten]

went to match yesterday on away side poor view for £22 not worth the money. Although match was good it was spoilt by several wakey fans in hudds end . We all like a bit of banter but I think several fans crossed the line intimidating and foul language as well as threating several hudds fans. They even tore down some poor lads hudds flag and when he went to complain they just threaten him and the boys dad quite shameful .Plenty of hudds fans were saying they wont be going to wakey next year which is a shame for both teams.

[longboard]

It tells you that LR throws the pass just before the ten metre line and JM catches it 2.5 to 3metres after it, Robinson isn't really travelling forward that much so no momentum argument can be made.

Forward pass, end of!

I won't argue that the Smith to Smith pass was'nt forward I'd just like to see even handed refereeing especially on decisions that so acutely affect the result

Some times you have to take the brough with the smooth.