That seems a strange way of thinking about things.
Petero im not saying im right or you wrong im just saying in my opinion chase n sinfield are our best half combo, IMO chase is the best off the cuff half we have n sinfield is the most organized an with a kicking game.
In the past 5years we must of had more than 10 different half combos were as the aussies have had lockyer n JT n they have slowly introduced Cronk. New Zealand have had benji n foran n also young johnson so as much as I dislike mcnamara been coach I actually like his thinking behind gettin a team n letting it full gel n im willing to give him the chance to try it.
If it work great if it dunt unlucky bring on the next coach with his theory.
If Chase and Sinfield had developed a really good understanding and had demonstrated on multiple occassions that they were an effective partnership, then yes, I could see the logic in sticking with them. Does anyone think that this is the case? Because if not then it would seem to make far more sense to select the players who are in the best form currently.