Not sure I agree with your mini league table - also you are comparing apples with pears. How can you compare a Prop to a Full Back and rate one better than the other. A prop runs forward, offloads and tackles, thats his job. A Full back....well there is so much to that position I haven't got time to write it.
So is Brad Singleton better than Jimmy Watson? The answer would have to be Watson is more skill full, agile, faster etc etc. Brad is strong in his runs.
Here is my table:
Here is the rationale.....
Watson has been good for Hunslet, safe, quick, can break the line, exciting and pushes through like no other FB I have seen at this level. At Swinton when he scored 3, it was because of the push throughs and hand offs from the forwards - Hunslet dont do enough of this thats why Watson isnt scoring 3 in every game.
Hood - is dangerous from dummy half and a good, rugby brain. Hard to catch and very strong.
Keinhorst - is a great player but plays off other people. His tries have either been lucky interceptions or he has been in support. He is strong and has a great off load.
Singleton - is just strong going forward. We need that but offers nothing else. Much better than what we have at Hunslet though.
Chisolm - is a little rusty, hasnt really had a consistent game, but never gets the ball. He is a former Fastest Man in Super League. Give him the ball in your 20 and nobody will catch him. He dropped a clanger last week but if you see no ball all game its gonna happen.
I just love it when Watson gets the ball, you dont know what will happen - has to be our most exciting player and maybe too good to stop at Hunslet long term.