What does that even mean, more honest?
For me it's sculthorpe by a distance. O'loughlin is a very good player,very solid and rarely let's his team down. But he's quite "functional" when compared to sculthorpe.
I guess what I mean is that Sculthorpe was a niggler, an aggravator, always pushing the rules, trying to influence the referee, sneaky trouble casuer, a bit like Graham Bradley for us. In many ways I sometimes thought that the behaviour of some of the players in that great Saints side was nearer to soccer than RL.
SOL is a lesser player than Sculthorpe was, but I prefer his attitude. The OP question wasn't who was the best player. If it was then I don't think there would be much of a debate.
Edited by Konkrete, 09 April 2014 - 05:57 PM.
......I want curly hair toooooo.