Well let's be realistic here, questioning and/or bagging an individual players ability on a public forum doesn't help does it?
Commenting on them as players and how they perform is fine. I merely comment on what happens on the field, im sure they are lovely people and you like others are confusing the difference between commenting on the player and the person.
You are definitely one of the do gooders that Vile Rodders speaks of, possibly even ranked as high as number 2 on here in terms of opposing anything that isnt what you want to hear, rather than just accepting opinions of others and encouraging debate, which is what this type of forum is for.
And for the record, that isnt a comment about you as a person, as i dont know you, its a comment about you as a member of this forum.