I actually have a bit of a rant at the telly when this form of subjective judging takes place.
Did Chetna get lucky??? Yes. Was she the best baker because of that luck??? Yes. Should that matter in terms of the competition??? Not for me.
The way I would like to see it work is that everyone gets ranked in each round.
The three ‘scores’ are then added up with the person with the lowest score winning and the person with the highest score being eliminated.
Only if scores are tied should there be a discussion. Rant over.
Lot of love in our house for Chetna.