Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

juliancaine

RIP SWINTON LIONS

183 posts in this topic

Yes It is an apology mark, Im sorry I misunderstood the arrangement, I unreservedly apologise, Brian.

Im currently cheering for Wigan!

Cheers Brian

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We have just had a letter from the rlc stating that we have SIGNEDthe young d/rs on contract they are NO LONGER REGISTERED OR CONTRACTED TO WARRINGTON.Yet we still have so called fans coming on here complaning about warrington a team. Last year threequaters of the team were signed from Leigh. I didn't here any moaning about watching Leigh A. To those still moaning who went to the match last sunday it was obvious to anyone with half a brain the players had squad numbers and there names on there jerseys,you can't do that with d/r players. We played 3 d/rs on sunday and the rules say we can play 5 in the seventeen. Those young players are now Swinton players stop moaning and get out there and support them if as you say you are true Swinton fans

hear hear!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Surely this official explanation closes the discussions on these 6 lads joining us and hopefully end adverse comments about our clubs behaviour in this matter - whether you agree with the DR system is a wider subject.

Why am I so naive??? my problem is I love Rugby League and I love Swinton Lions - I just want to get to York and support Rugby League

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So all 6 young players felt that Swinton was their best option and didn't even try to go elsewhere.......pmsl

Are you all really that stupid.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So all 6 young players felt that Swinton was their best option and didn't even try to go elsewhere.......pmsl

Are you all really that stupid.

you really do have a lot to say for yourself.....best kept on Leigh forum.

Every forum you go on you just muck stir.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So all 6 young players felt that Swinton was their best option and didn't even try to go elsewhere.......pmsl

Are you all really that stupid.

so is it your moral compass thats causing the problem as we have not broken any rules.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As a long-time fan, I'm getting tired of all this negativity.

I support Swinton Lions, regardless of where the players come from. We never had 17 home grown Swinton lads at any time in my memory.

We need to move on. If this is the new face of RL, so be it. What other option do we have? Move back to RU? That would count Spelly out! :rolleyes:

Personally I don't like fake scrums and all the forward passes and play the ball issues. That's doesn't stop me from making my bi-annual pilgrimage to see them play. Again, and my point, it is what it is, so let's get on with it. The rules are the rules and we have been blessed by the RL, appear to have inherited a lot of talent along the way and just maybe out-smarted a good few of our competitors.

We should be ecstatic!

Get out and support the Lions! I'll see you all this summer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So all 6 young players felt that Swinton was their best option and didn't even try to go elsewhere.......pmsl

Are you all really that stupid.

I am not stupid - I have been watching Rugby League for nearly 60 years - ups and downs for all teams - why shouldn't these players sign for us - what is our problem - can you explain??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am not stupid - I have been watching Rugby League for nearly 60 years - ups and downs for all teams - why shouldn't these players sign for us - what is our problem - can you explain??

I'm not having a go and I'm sorry for interrupting your debate with demon but ok these players are now swinton players I will except that but your club cannot be paying their wages because you would be exceeding the salary cap if that's the case. Also I doubt these players would terminate their contracts of say 40k plus a season each to go part time and to swinton. No offense but they could get better wages else where as you guys have stated before you are on your last legs. So to get the wages for these players would be impossible for you guys at the minute. ( like I said I'm not having a go just looking at the situation from your clubs point)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How much money do you think a player earns?!?! Trust me apart from the top earners its nowhere near 40k especially for 19-21 year old reserves!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How much money do you think a player earns?!?! Trust me apart from the top earners its nowhere near 40k especially for 19-21 year old reserves!

I was referring to the 3 year contracts they were on at wire surely that would be around the 40k mark? But like I said surely they would of looked for other options before signing for you guys? Most players look for the most money and I doubt these were any different. I just doubt whether your club is paying their wages that's all. Also I agree I could be wrong and if I am I will hold my hands up. But I'm just going off what you guys have said by saying your club is skint. If this is the case how have you signed 6 players in a week. on I'm assuming good wages? That's why I think wire are paying their wages.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It wasn't a 3 year contract it was a one year contract with two option years. Plus by joining Swinton they get to train at wire and impress Smith at close quarters. Lets face it they are not good enough for fax or Leigh so why not join Swinton?

or is it a fact that we are an unfashionable club so we shouldn't be allowed to sign players with potential, just average journeymen?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It wasn't a 3 year contract it was a one year contract with two option years. Plus by joining Swinton they get to train at wire and impress Smith at close quarters. Lets face it they are not good enough for fax or Leigh so why not join Swinton?

or is it a fact that we are an unfashionable club so we shouldn't be allowed to sign players with potential, just average journeymen?

I didn't mean it like that you are entitled to sign anyone just as any other club is. I just thought the signings were very quick that's all. They could of gone to dews, keighley etc as well. It just seems very odd that all 6 went to swinton even you have to think that's odd it's very rare 2 players from one club go to the same club within a week never mind 6. To be honest if swinton are paying their wages that's great and I'm all for giving young talent a go. I don't mind the DR system to give up and coming youngsters a kick start its when the likes of woods, Moore and luluai etc get game time Im totally against that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with only young uns being used. but on the flip side of the coin we are the nearest team to where they live. petrol isn't cheap and who wants to be driving lancs to yorkshire 4 times a week whilst earning a few 100 quid.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with only young uns being used. but on the flip side of the coin we are the nearest team to where they live. petrol isn't cheap and who wants to be driving lancs to yorkshire 4 times a week whilst earning a few 100 quid.

Fair point Barnie and to be honest you never know and might never know. I just hope they are your players though for the sake of your club. Because if wire are paying their wages they have an hold over you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not having a go and I'm sorry for interrupting your debate with demon but ok these players are now swinton players I will except that but your club cannot be paying their wages because you would be exceeding the salary cap if that's the case. Also I doubt these players would terminate their contracts of say 40k plus a season each to go part time and to swinton. No offense but they could get better wages else where as you guys have stated before you are on your last legs. So to get the wages for these players would be impossible for you guys at the minute. ( like I said I'm not having a go just looking at the situation from your clubs point)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I didn't mean it like that you are entitled to sign anyone just as any other club is. I just thought the signings were very quick that's all. They could of gone to dews, keighley etc as well. It just seems very odd that all 6 went to swinton even you have to think that's odd it's very rare 2 players from one club go to the same club within a week never mind 6. To be honest if swinton are paying their wages that's great and I'm all for giving young talent a go. I don't mind the DR system to give up and coming youngsters a kick start its when the likes of woods, Moore and luluai etc get game time Im totally against that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Erm no one is doubting we have a link with Wire,so why would they conceivably choose another club.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For god's sake can everyone give the Swinton club and speccies a break ... I don't suppose for one minute that any of them find the current situation ideal but that's what they've got and all they can do is try to make the best of it ..who knows how many other clubs will find themselves in a similar situation . The important thing is that the speccies stick by the club as if they spit the dummy out and stop going ... then at best it's unlikely that the situation will change for the better and at worst will be the death knell of the club . As a supporter of Oldham I've seen us on the brink of folding on too many occasions and don't want us or anyone else to go through this again so hope the Swinton speccies keep the faith and supporters of other clubs stop taking the moral high ground and remember that we are all in this together so let's start acting like we are .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For god's sake can everyone give the Swinton club and speccies a break ... I don't suppose for one minute that any of them find the current situation ideal but that's what they've got and all they can do is try to make the best of it ..who knows how many other clubs will find themselves in a similar situation . The important thing is that the speccies stick by the club as if they spit the dummy out and stop going ... then at best it's unlikely that the situation will change for the better and at worst will be the death knell of the club . As a supporter of Oldham I've seen us on the brink of folding on too many occasions and don't want us or anyone else to go through this again so hope the Swinton speccies keep the faith and supporters of other clubs stop taking the moral high ground and remember that we are all in this together so let's start acting like we are .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not having a go and I'm sorry for interrupting your debate with demon but ok these players are now swinton players I will except that but your club cannot be paying their wages because you would be exceeding the salary cap if that's the case. Also I doubt these players would terminate their contracts of say 40k plus a season each to go part time and to swinton. No offense but they could get better wages else where as you guys have stated before you are on your last legs. So to get the wages for these players would be impossible for you guys at the minute. ( like I said I'm not having a go just looking at the situation from your clubs point)

40k a season for a 20yo up and coming junior? Are you having a Turkish?

And as for us not paying their wages, who's paying at Salford, Bradford, Widnes? Can't be the club because they're buster! They get a sugar daddy but that's ok? He goes, they fall!

Sort your head out mate!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just to clear this up....one of the wire lads was on 4k that's four thousand. Thats off his dad. Stop making stuff up.

By the way I know an ex wigan gb international. He was on 75k as a top player

Thats out of his mouth.

Stop making stuff up!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not having a go and I'm sorry for interrupting your debate with demon but ok these players are now swinton players I will except that but your club cannot be paying their wages because you would be exceeding the salary cap if that's the case. Also I doubt these players would terminate their contracts of say 40k plus a season each to go part time and to swinton. No offense but they could get better wages else where as you guys have stated before you are on your last legs. So to get the wages for these players would be impossible for you guys at the minute. ( like I said I'm not having a go just looking at the situation from your clubs point)

I dont think any of us hsve stated we are on our last legs

And finally. ..these lads could have gone elsewhere and got more...where like leigh who signed our second top try scorer....or Sheffield who signed our third top try scorer or Halifax who signed our brightest young prospect or even Featherstone who've had it alll their own way for years.

I think I clearly see the objection now!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.



Rugby League World - April 2017

League Express - Mon 10th April 2017