Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Terry Mullaney

Two tier SL on the way

724 posts in this topic

As I said above Dave. Leeds rarely won much even with the sort of players gaz mentioned.

Yes but that wasn't because they weren't greats of our game its because Wigan had the money and just got better greats to join them that's all.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes but that wasn't because they weren't greats of our game its because Wigan had the money and just got better greats to join them that's all.

And that takes us back to what will happen without a salary cap. It might not be Wigan but it won't be any surprise that one club has more money to spend than the others.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And that takes us back to what will happen without a salary cap.

I never once said I was in favour of the open salary cap. I just said the players were greats and always will be. How many of today's stars will be remembered in 20 years time?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I never once said I was in favour of the open salary cap. I just said the players were greats and always will be. How many of today's stars will be remembered in 20 years time?

Sorry gaz I'm confusing threads. I'll let you know in twenty years time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If Toulouse get into SL at the expense of a champ club that will be me done with the sport.

:O

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I never once said I was in favour of the open salary cap. I just said the players were greats and always will be. How many of today's stars will be remembered in 20 years time?

I suspect in 20 years time, Wire fans who are between 10-19 now, will be in their 30's moaning that we don't see the likes of Hodgson, Briers, Morley, Westwood etc any more.

It's a strange one, because the Aussies are constantly telling us that the players they have now are the best the game has ever seen, whereas we just talk down our superstars like Tomkins, Graham, Sinfield, Roby, Burgess, Ellis, Westwood, Hock, Briscoe, Hall etc.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I suspect in 20 years time, Wire fans who are between 10-19 now, will be in their 30's moaning that we don't see the likes of Hodgson, Briers, Morley, Westwood etc any more.

Well dave I'm not between them ages you have stated but I certainly won't be mentioning those names in 20 years time. As they are not a patch on the greats of yester year for me anyway.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's a strange one, because the Aussies are constantly telling us that the players they have now are the best the game has ever seen, whereas we just talk down our superstars like Tomkins, Graham, Sinfield, Roby, Burgess, Ellis, Westwood, Hock, Briscoe, Hall etc.

I also disagree with that one too dave. Even though the Aussies are spouting about their team. Don't get me wrong they have some class players and always have had. Player for player I would say yes they have the best Aussie team ever. But team wise I would disagree I think the mal maningar era was their best era. As I don't think the Aussies of today have the standard of yester year to play against.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well dave I'm not between them ages you have stated but I certainly won't be mentioning those names in 20 years time. As they are not a patch on the greats of yester year for me anyway.

And that's sort of my point.

Morley would be a legend in any era. Westwood is as good as any of the British 2nd rowers I have seen in my 25 years watching.

I often find when I speak to fans that they always consider greats to be only from the past. I also find that sometimes the greats that are referred to lacked some skills that nowadays would see them left out of the team. Quite often players weren;t capable of passing both ways without turning their back on the defensive line for example.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I also disagree with that one too dave. Even though the Aussies are spouting about their team. Don't get me wrong they have some class players and always have had. Player for player I would say yes they have the best Aussie team ever. But team wise I would disagree I think the mal maningar era was their best era. As I don't think the Aussies of today have the standard of yester year to play against.

Nostalgia turns the likes of Paul Eastwood into legends. Same with Darryl Powell - very good players, but nowadays they would be classed as average.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nostalgia turns the likes of Paul Eastwood into legends. Same with Darryl Powell - very good players, but nowadays they would be classed as average.

I disagree again can you imagine what the likes of Hanley and Edwards etc would of done in today's game if they were full time pros it doesn't bare thinking about. They would rip the SL to shreds and turn it on its head.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I disagree again can you imagine what the likes of Hanley and Edwards etc would of done in today's game if they were full time pros it doesn't bare thinking about. They would rip the SL to shreds and turn it on its head.

I loved watching Hanley - for me he was a once in a generation player - real genuine world class.

Edwards was a great, but we've had better players since - that's not to take anything from his record.

I wasn't a fan of his, but Sean Long went on to get a hat-tricks of Lance Todd awards, the first in history to do so. Andy Farrell is a true great in my eyes, Morley is a legend, Cunningham has had a brilliant club career, Graham is a freak of a prop, Briers has shown many glimpses, certainly in the back end of his career, Sinfield is breaking Leeds club records for fun, Hall is a world-beater.

These players will all be remembered in years to come. I suspect much more than Paul Eastwood, Carl Gibson, Paul Dixon, Darryl Powell, Lee Jackson, Sonny Nickle, etc.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I disagree again can you imagine what the likes of Hanley and Edwards etc would of done in today's game if they were full time pros it doesn't bare thinking about.

Come on gaz, you're having a laugh aren't you? Hanley and Edwards and the rest of the eighties and nineties Wigan teams were full time pros.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I loved watching Hanley - for me he was a once in a generation player - real genuine world class.

Edwards was a great, but we've had better players since - that's not to take anything from his record.

I wasn't a fan of his, but Sean Long went on to get a hat-tricks of Lance Todd awards, the first in history to do so. Andy Farrell is a true great in my eyes, Morley is a legend, Cunningham has had a brilliant club career, Graham is a freak of a prop, Briers has shown many glimpses, certainly in the back end of his career, Sinfield is breaking Leeds club records for fun, Hall is a world-beater.

These players will all be remembered in years to come. I suspect much more than Paul Eastwood, Carl Gibson, Paul Dixon, Darryl Powell, Lee Jackson, Sonny Nickle, etc.

Nah not for me dave but each to their own I guess. Too many over rated players in today's game for me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nah not for me dave but each to their own I guess. Too many over rated players in today's game for me.

It would appear that nobody rates anybody in the game nowadays so I'd dispute your last line! :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I disagree again can you imagine what the likes of Hanley and Edwards etc would of done in today's game if they were full time pros it doesn't bare thinking about. They would rip the SL to shreds and turn it on its head.

If anything they wouldn't look as good as it is now a level playing field.

Sam Tomkins, Sam Burgess and James Graham are as good as any player England have ever produced.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If anything they wouldn't look as good as it is now a level playing field.

Sam Tomkins, Sam Burgess and James Graham are as good as any player England have ever produced.

I agree with Tomkins gav. Don't know about the other 2 though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I disagree again can you imagine what the likes of Hanley and Edwards etc would of done in today's game if they were full time pros it doesn't bare thinking about. They would rip the SL to shreds and turn it on its head.

alex murphy is the greatest player of all time and my boyhood hero, but even he would struggle with the pace of todays game, great players belong to their generation and all the time even greater players come into the frame ala darren lockyer arguably the best aussie i have seen in 50 years of watching the game.......

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

alex murphy is the greatest player of all time and my boyhood hero, but even he would struggle with the pace of todays game, great players belong to their generation and all the time even greater players come into the frame ala darren lockyer arguably the best aussie i have seen in 50 years of watching the game.......

I won't argue with any of that Viking as I agree great players in every generation. Lockyer was class too. It might be me but I just don't feel the players are of the same standard of yester years.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with Tomkins gav. Don't know about the other 2 though.

behave yourself, graham and burgess would be outstanding props in any generation, pace power and skill to burn.........sam tomkins is a freak, sublime skill with great pace, attitude and balance. he could even end up better than murphy,

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I won't argue with any of that Viking as I agree great players in every generation. Lockyer was class too. It might be me but I just don't feel the players are of the same standard of yester years.

Indeed, they are much fitter, faster, stronger and across the board more skillful thanks to full time professionalism.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

behave yourself, graham and burgess would be outstanding props in any generation, pace power and skill to burn.........

Over rated because they went down under that's all.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Over rated because they went down under that's all.

Absolutely ridiculous comment.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Indeed, they are much fitter, faster, stronger and across the board more skillful thanks to full time professionalism.

Not going to argue with that gav only the skilful bit. But what I'm saying is I would rather watch a game between the Wigan and Widnes of old than the Wigan of now and say Leeds if now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.



Rugby League World - June 2017

League Express - Mon 17th July 2017