Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

hindle xiii

29/03/13 - Salford City Reds v Huddersfield Giants - KO 3pm

Who will win?   8 members have voted

  1. 1. Who will win?

    • Salford City Reds
      3
    • Huddersfield Giants
      5
    • Draw
      0

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

54 posts in this topic

Not bloody acceptable

Salford are very much our bogey team, but that just isnt good enough.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not bloody acceptable

Salford are very much our bogey team, but that just isnt good enough.

You cannot now call Nathan Brown!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great result for Salford, hope this gives them some momentum to build upon for the rest of the season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Very pleased for Salford and their new owner - hope they can build on it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Pleased for Salford and the Dr does anyone know if Noble was in charge today or was Hunte and Longy still in charge. These shock results aren't doing me any favours in the tipping comp I'm in. I'm lucky if I can pick three winners each round.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Many posters have been wanting competitive games in Superleague and it now appears that no game in the competition can be regarded as a foregone conclusion. In how many other seasons going into a round has the team that is bottom beaten the league leaders?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great game, Salford looked much more balanced, Gaskell scored in the opening minutes for a great debut try. Sneyd was playing well.

Alan Hunte and Sean Long remain in charge, and according to the programme will do so all over Easter. There is a togetherness that was missing early on. I don't know if the sacking of Veivers has influenced this.

Gibson went off injured so to hang on for the win was outstanding.

On a side issue, a couple of Huddersfield fans refused to move for the reserved seating, and eventually were thrown/left the game.so for other visiting fans the middle block of the East Stand is reserved for home fans regardless of whether anyone is sitting there. Tickets will be checked.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is the east stand usually populated by away fans?.....if so, seems daft to reserve home seats there??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The East stand is mixed, for some games the North stand which the away end has been closed. This has led to the end 2 blocks of the East Stand being allocated to away fans. The middle block is season tickets and the end 2 near the south stand is unreserved home fans.

This new strict policy is a result of the Hull KR fans taking up seats allocated to Season ticket holders. Not their fault but the stewards failed to direct them to other seats.

The 2 guys were just idiots, the female steward tried to reason with them for a god 5 mins asking them to return to the other block but they refused, more stewards arrived and the guys were escorted away from the pitch area.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Right.......seems daft closing the away end.......bound to cause problems/confusion

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

All about money, not a big crowd expected today, will be open for teams such as Leeds and Warrington

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Right.......seems daft closing the away end.......bound to cause problems/confusion

Nothing daft about it really. It makes economic sense. Why staff a bar that is hardly going to be used? Saints close their away end for certain matches too and use the seated blocks nearest the away end for any travelling fans who do turn up.

Great win for Salford by the way. I'm glad that Sneyd had the ability to kick a drop goal. Always a handy skill to have! (PS: Gaskell can drop goals too, should the need arise)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just got home. Buzzing after that. Not a brilliant game, but tons of commitment from Salford which has been lacking. As RW says, we're beginning to look organised and our defence is unrecognisable form the early games.

In all honesty, I have to say that Huddersfield looked out of sorts today. Their pack failed to steamroller ours and I don't think Danny Brough has ever looked as anonymous. Even the outside backs (Cudjoe, McGilvary) looked a bit flat.

Still, every win is a good 'un. Let's hope we get several more. (For the Aussie watchers, Foran still looks a bit overweight and unfit. Gaskell looked good and the whole team look more together than I've seen for ages)

edited to remove reference to Mauro. Too many bearded forwards who look the same. :blush:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just got home. Buzzing after that. Not a brilliant game, but tons of commitment from Salford which has been lacking. As RW says, we're beginning to look organised and our defence is unrecognisable form the early games.

In all honesty, I have to say that Huddersfield looked out of sorts today. Their pack failed to steamroller ours and I don't think Danny Brough has ever looked as anonymous. Even the outside backs (Cudjoe, McGilvary) looked a bit flat.

Still, every win is a good 'un. Let's hope we get several more. (For the Aussie watchers, Foran still looks a bit overweight and unfit, Mauro only played shortish periods. Gaskell looked good and the whole team look more together than I've seen for ages)

Just great.

When you're sulking after a derby defeat, some smug bleeder comes along to say his team won today. :angry:

Enjoy the day mate. :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There is a togetherness that was missing early on. I don't know if the sacking of Veivers has influenced this.

Apart from Gaskell the squad today were all players Veivers had or brought to the club.As he managed to sign Andrew Dixon from St Helens apparently before the financial mess became known,there is nothing to suggest he would not have approached Gaskell when it became clear Saints didn't require him for the remainder of the season.( I wouldn't object to seeing Makinson join,either.) There were reports he tried to take him to Salford last year.

With more training time together,and more time to gel,that togetherness may just have manifested itself in the same way it did in the same fixture at the Etihad at the Magic Weekend in 2012 when Veivers coached them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just great.

When you're sulking after a derby defeat, some smug bleeder comes along to say his team won today. :angry:

Enjoy the day mate. :D

I hadn't spotted that result. Ouch! Feel for you guys. Better luck on Monday. You're not playing us are you :ph34r: ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Apart from Gaskell the squad today were all players Veivers had or brought to the club.As he managed to sign Andrew Dixon from St Helens apparently before the financial mess became known,there is nothing to suggest he would not have approached Gaskell when it became clear Saints didn't require him for the remainder of the season.( I wouldn't object to seeing Makinson join,either.) There were reports he tried to take him to Salford last year.

With more training time together,and more time to gel,that togetherness may just have manifested itself in the same way it did in the same fixture at the Etihad at the Magic Weekend in 2012 when Veivers coached them.

I also feel sorry for Phil. The problem is that owners can't really do anything else. They can't suddenly recruit a fresh squad of players. If something needs to be done (and after the London game, something was needed badly), the only option for Dr Koukash was to sack the coach. PV knew the score. Every coach in SL is in the same boat, one bad game away from the sack.

I hope PV gets another crack at SL.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The East stand is mixed, for some games the North stand which the away end has been closed. This has led to the end 2 blocks of the East Stand being allocated to away fans. The middle block is season tickets and the end 2 near the south stand is unreserved home fans.

This new strict policy is a result of the Hull KR fans taking up seats allocated to Season ticket holders. Not their fault but the stewards failed to direct them to other seats.

The 2 guys were just idiots, the female steward tried to reason with them for a god 5 mins asking them to return to the other block but they refused, more stewards arrived and the guys were escorted away from the pitch area.

We mistakendly sat in the middle blocks of the east stand and were asked to move into the 2 blocks at the far end of the east stand (for away supporters) which we did. I can understand people being moved from season ticket holders seats but the middle blocks of the east stand were almost empty. This goes against the rugby league family ethic of opposing fans being able to mix which I believe was one of the attractions for Mr Koukash. I believe any Salford fan buying a ticket for the equivalent stand at the John Smiths stadium will be very welcome with the proviso that they don't sit in a Giants season ticket holder seat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Hull KR fans sat in the season ticket holders seats, Which annoyed all of us. The stadium company's solution was to challenge all fans including Salford fans. It isn't easy to monitor who should and shouldn't sit where.

I miss the atmosphere of the mixed seating but I do want my paid for seat rather than end up sitting somewhere with a worse view.

It should be easy but new stadiums never are.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Hull KR fans sat in the season ticket holders seats, Which annoyed all of us. The stadium company's solution was to challenge all fans including Salford fans. It isn't easy to monitor who should and shouldn't sit where.

I miss the atmosphere of the mixed seating but I do want my paid for seat rather than end up sitting somewhere with a worse view.

It should be easy but new stadiums never are.

Absolutely. If what the posters have said is right, then it could have been handled better. The two blocks nearest the North stand were choc-a-bloc with Huddersfield fans, so I can understand their reluctance to be sent there. There really was plenty of space available in the rest of the East stand and the fans in question could (and should!) have been redirected to other seats within that stand. Easy! Sometimes, a bit of common sense on the part of those in charge of the stewards would help defuse situations long before they get to the stage of throwing people out of the stadium.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The issues arose at half time when Huddersfield fans wanted to "change ends" Most fans including Robbo's wife moved when requested. The 2 bald headed hard men thought they could just act tough. They were given the option of moving for some time.

The simple solution would be for a ticket system that allows home fans to select the middle block as well as season ticket holders.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just got home. Buzzing after that. Not a brilliant game, but tons of commitment from Salford which has been lacking. As RW says, we're beginning to look organised and our defence is unrecognisable form the early games.

In all honesty, I have to say that Huddersfield looked out of sorts today. Their pack failed to steamroller ours and

I don't think Danny Brough has ever looked so anonymous. Even the outside backs (Cudjoe, McGilvary) looked a bit flat.

Still, every win is a good 'un. Let's hope we get several more. (For the Aussie watchers, Foran still looks a bit overweight and unfit. Gaskell looked good and the whole team look more together than I've seen for ages)

edited to remove reference to Mauro. Too many bearded forwards who look the same. :blush:

Sorry Tony but if that is true you have simply not taken that much notice! This has been (one of many admittedly :wacko: )my prime gripe with Brough and I have repeated it so often that his tendency to want or more importantly; NOT WANT to take part in games his is biggest failing. Having watched the lad for so long now this has always struck me and I feel that it is the reason that he hasn't gained rep honours, that he would have had he not got this switching off problem.

This applies not simply to individual games but also to quite long periods of a season also, on song he can be wonderful but when not he is a very poor imitation of himself.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I didn't realise Brough was playing until he stepped up to take a conversion.

Huddersfield looked better when Crabtree went off, better tactics rather than the pass it to Eorl tactic.

Robinson should have gone for the drop goal rather than a cross field kick.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.