Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

shun

Referees

Referees   18 members have voted

  1. 1. Are the refs good enough for this competition? or is it just bad loosers moaning because there team didnt win?

    • Good enough
      7
    • Bad loosers
      3
    • or are they just poor
      8

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

23 posts in this topic

every week there is more talk about the reffs than the actual games, its ######!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Most of them don't have personalities. They are apparently not allowed to use common sense. They are just mobile extensions of the law book. It really annoys me that they rarely stay for something to eat and a chat after games. They should be barred from watching Super League as well! Touch judges annoy me more though. What are they there for? It gives me no pleasure to criticise referees and I know they have a difficult job, in fact, as can be seen by my recent letter in LE, I actually enjoy telling a referee when he has had a good game. Just wish they would look sometimes like they are enjoying it! Everything stems from Super League and the officials decide more games at that level than the players do!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ive not voted because my opinion of referees in general does not fall into any of those categories.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Most of them don't have personalities. They are apparently not allowed to use common sense. They are just mobile extensions of the law book. It really annoys me that they rarely stay for something to eat and a chat after games. They should be barred from watching Super League as well! Touch judges annoy me more though. What are they there for? It gives me no pleasure to criticise referees and I know they have a difficult job, in fact, as can be seen by my recent letter in LE, I actually enjoy telling a referee when he has had a good game. Just wish they would look sometimes like they are enjoying it! Everything stems from Super League and the officials decide more games at that level than the players do!

One of the first things that I was told when I first qualified was to stay after the match for a drink & something to eat as in the long run it made things easier because you got to know the players officials etc

In 13 years I probably left straight after a match on half a dozen times usually when I had a family commitment that evening

I even stayed after abandoning matches (only a couple)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One of the first things that I was told when I first qualified was to stay after the match for a drink & something to eat as in the long run it made things easier because you got to know the players officials etc

In 13 years I probably left straight after a match on half a dozen times usually when I had a family commitment that evening

I even stayed after abandoning matches (only a couple)

Always a first class performance from you Lee and retired far to early, a great testament to your ability with the whistle was when a parallel district league asked you to officiate their district cup final.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Talking of ref's. The man in the middle was absolutle disgrace at the East's V Pats game. The linesmen might aswell have not been there as he over ruled them every time. Dnt know who he was?? Was that his first ever game??? He needs to be assessed after this very poor performance, Even the Pats coaches said he was bad so its not sour grapes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Talking of ref's. The man in the middle was absolutle disgrace at the East's V Pats game. The linesmen might aswell have not been there as he over ruled them every time. Dnt know who he was?? Was that his first ever game??? He needs to be assessed after this very poor performance, Even the Pats coaches said he was bad so its not sour grapes.

got to agree. he was poor,and didn't use his touchjudges

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Most of them don't have personalities. They are apparently not allowed to use common sense. They are just mobile extensions of the law book. It really annoys me that they rarely stay for something to eat and a chat after games. They should be barred from watching Super League as well! Touch judges annoy me more though. What are they there for? It gives me no pleasure to criticise referees and I know they have a difficult job, in fact, as can be seen by my recent letter in LE, I actually enjoy telling a referee when he has had a good game. Just wish they would look sometimes like they are enjoying it! Everything stems from Super League and the officials decide more games at that level than the players do!

I think that the attitude of quite a few is discraceful.They seem to put on the attitude with the uniform.As for the touch judges great pocket money, buy plenty of pop and crisps and probably a few mates with their dosh! I know it must be difficult for refs but to have a true understanding of the game you should at leased of played it.#just my opinion

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Talking of ref's. The man in the middle was absolutle disgrace at the East's V Pats game. The linesmen might aswell have not been there as he over ruled them every time. Dnt know who he was?? Was that his first ever game??? He needs to be assessed after this very poor performance, Even the Pats coaches said he was bad so its not sour grapes.

It does worry you a bit when you've never heard of your referee before - and then they turn up in the Premier Division. What happened to working their way through the North West or Yorkshire Men's League or NW Counties/Pennine League like they used to do?

I'm a little tired of touch judges rushing in to the club after the game asking for their fee! I think I'm going to start paying ours with a cheque in future!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I prefer it when we have a referee who I have never heard of before Jaguar, because in my book, he starts with a clean slate. I keep records of every referee we have ever had at my club over the last 13 years and its good when you don't have any pre-conceived ideas about him and hopefully, he doesn't have any pre concieved ideas about us. Got to agree with you regarding touch judges though - waste of space. Got to say that the Widnes society has supplied some great referee's over the years. I follow the careers of referee's as closely as I do players. Most do a pretty decent job but I wish they were more approachable, talked to the players more and maybe smiled once in a while.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The questions in the Poll are too broad, there are good refs, poor refs and certainly some serial ref blamers.

As to the touch judges it was much better when teams had a designated TJ, referees got to know them and vice versa and there were very few problems. The local chaps were much more capable than some of the children that are sent out these days. Significantly cheaper as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

correct me if iam wrong but clubs dont pay for refs but pay for tj .as for your comment some of the children who tj i have seen some very good tj who are tjing for poor refs who think they are the best .these young officials need to learn their trade did you all critisize your players when they where learning (expecting some flack now )

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You missed the word 'some' that was in my post, you used it to say some TJs are very good, I said some are not. Does that mean we agree? When players are learning they are not learning in the top amateur league but unfortunately TJs are.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What is the excuse for the touch judges in Super league being blind to forward passes then, and generally about as much as us as a chocolate fireguard? Are they still learning their trade as well, or are they under instruction to ignore forward passes? I also saw North Wales crusaders get robbed at home to Doncaster last season by some disgraceful touch judge decisions. Those touch judges did not get a game for a month as punishment but the referee - Jamie Bloom, who had a decent game apart from taking notice of his touch judges, was also punished. He was dropped from the championship the following week and refereed Hunslet Warriors .v. Eccles. The other side of the coin is, I once went to watch Heworth .v. Leigh Miners as a neutral and was cajoled into being a touch judge. I did it as fairly as I could took and as a result, took so much abuse  from the fans that I have never considered doing it again!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

role of a tj as defined by i think james child on the new rfl twitter

tjs are sole judge on touch,touch in goal and conversions they can only advise on other decisions

with the amatuer tj not wired up like their superleague  friends the only main chance that some decisons are picked up is the timing of a ref seeing the signal given by a tj .not trying to defend tjs or refs but the so called professional officials get things wrong even with all their training and expertise, so how do some people expect amateur officials without all the technology that superleague officials have expect them to be 100% correct all the time.if games where played to the letter of the game it would be stop start and loads of penalties.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What is the excuse for the touch judges in Super league being blind to forward passes then, and generally about as much as us as a chocolate fireguard? Are they still learning their trade as well, or are they under instruction to ignore forward passes? I also saw North Wales crusaders get robbed at home to Doncaster last season by some disgraceful touch judge decisions. Those touch judges did not get a game for a month as punishment but the referee - Jamie Bloom, who had a decent game apart from taking notice of his touch judges, was also punished. He was dropped from the championship the following week and refereed Hunslet Warriors .v. Eccles. The other side of the coin is, I once went to watch Heworth .v. Leigh Miners as a neutral and was cajoled into being a touch judge. I did it as fairly as I could took and as a result, took so much abuse  from the fans that I have never considered doing it again!

and with you last statement reguarding abuse that is why we are struggling to get officials to do the jobs

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

tjs are sole judge on touch,touch in goal and conversions

No they aren't, I have seen TJs give decisions after loud advice from supporters.

The best advice I got from a referee was, "Watch my back, don't embarrass me but if you see something that I have missed then stick your flag up until I see it." Currently most of TJs haven't got the bottle to call foul play.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sadly, Once a ref - You are correct. I too, have seen many a touch judge influenced by an aggressive or vociferous touchline.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

On saturday a very young looking TJ came onto the pitch waving his flag claiming one of our players head butted a Siddal player. Everyone seemed a bit bemused (both players and supporters) as nothing seemed to have happened... after a lengthy chat with the ref our player was sent off. Video evidence of the incident showed no head butt had occurred.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Head butts are usually followed by loud spectator noises and or brawls, the ref should have explained to the young TJ that him being the only person to see the offence was highly unlikely.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.



Rugby League World - June 2017

League Express - Mon 17th July 2017