Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

SWM87

Hunslet & Mayfield Outcome

26 posts in this topic

So the result of the abandoned Hunslet and Mayfield game is Hunslet are fined £425 plus another £200 suspended for a year. Mayfield are fined £275 plus another £100 suspended for a year. That is about right however for the result to still stand is nonsense!

 

Clearly the rule book did not matter when deciding that the result will stand, and for Hunslet to be given the win is rubbish! The game had at least 25 minutes left if not more and even though Hunslet were winning, Mayfield came out the stronger and better side in the 2nd half.

 

This game should be played again, FACT!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i was at that game Warriors scored a try straight after half-time to take the score out to 28-4 they also bombed a try shortly after. that team Mayfield had out on the day would not have beaten the Warriors if they were still playing now.The NCL commitee viewed the match vidio in full and must have thought likewise, when making the decision the result stand,s.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just because they scored a try straight after half time does not mean that they were going to win, especially when there was at least 25 minutes left in the game. Plus if the game has not played over a certain time frame (68 mins) the result at the time should not stand and a rematch should take place. It’s a poor decision made.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just because they scored a try straight after half time does not mean that they were going to win, especially when there was at least 25 minutes left in the game. Plus if the game has not played over a certain time frame (68 mins) the result at the time should not stand and a rematch should take place. It’s a poor decision made.

Ha ha ha ha ha

Mayfield could only manage to score 4 points in 60 mins, what makes you think they could have scored 25 in 20 mins?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dont think the punishment is severe enough,time and time again it is the same teams that are involved in the uglyscenes.If they wan to fight then let them go elsewhwere away from a rugby pitch and stop dragging our great game through the gutter,it nearly always involves a team from the Leeds area causing the trouble,you dont often see the top sides from leigh,Wigan,Halifax,Hull causing problems,they just want to play rugby on a saturday.Mayfield used to have a bad reputation in the eighties for bullying and intimidating teams and referees,until they met their match in Elland who demorolised them time and time again..leopards never change their spots it seams....rant over !!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ha ha ha ha ha

Mayfield could only manage to score 4 points in 60 mins, what makes you think they could have scored 25 in 20 mins?

 it is a good point

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dont think the punishment is severe enough,time and time again it is the same teams that are involved in the uglyscenes.If they wan to fight then let them go elsewhwere away from a rugby pitch and stop dragging our great game through the gutter,it nearly always involves a team from the Leeds area causing the trouble,you dont often see the top sides from leigh,Wigan,Halifax,Hull causing problems,they just want to play rugby on a saturday.Mayfield used to have a bad reputation in the eighties for bullying and intimidating teams and referees,until they met their match in Elland who demorolised them time and time again..leopards never change their spots it seams....rant over !!!!

 

What a load of tripe!!!! Whatever you are smoking i strongly suggest you put a stop to it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dont think the punishment is severe enough,time and time again it is the same teams that are involved in the uglyscenes.If they wan to fight then let them go elsewhwere away from a rugby pitch and stop dragging our great game through the gutter,it nearly always involves a team from the Leeds area causing the trouble,you dont often see the top sides from leigh,Wigan,Halifax,Hull causing problems,they just want to play rugby on a saturday.Mayfield used to have a bad reputation in the eighties for bullying and intimidating teams and referees,until they met their match in Elland who demorolised them time and time again..leopards never change their spots it seams....rant over !!!!

Sort it out, I bet you agree with the banning of the shoulder charge aswell you whinging bint!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So the result of the abandoned Hunslet and Mayfield game is Hunslet are fined £425 plus another £200 suspended for a year. Mayfield are fined £275 plus another £100 suspended for a year. That is about right however for the result to still stand is nonsense!

 

Clearly the rule book did not matter when deciding that the result will stand, and for Hunslet to be given the win is rubbish! The game had at least 25 minutes left if not more and even though Hunslet were winning, Mayfield came out the stronger and better side in the 2nd half.

 

This game should be played again, FACT!!!

 

 

sorry to be pedantic but its not a fact, its an opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

you dont often see the top sides from leigh, Wigan, Halifax, Hull causing problems,

You must have had your eyes closed the last 27 years.   :nono:

Of the 6 teams expelled during that time from the NCL, 3 of them were from Halifax...  :ireful:

 

i'm aware you might have been busy up there in the hills, so we'll let you off this time 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dont think the punishment is severe enough,time and time again it is the same teams that are involved in the uglyscenes.If they wan to fight then let them go elsewhwere away from a rugby pitch and stop dragging our great game through the gutter,it nearly always involves a team from the Leeds area causing the trouble,you dont often see the top sides from leigh,Wigan,Halifax,Hull causing problems,they just want to play rugby on a saturday.Mayfield used to have a bad reputation in the eighties for bullying and intimidating teams and referees,until they met their match in Elland who demorolised them time and time again..leopards never change their spots it seams....rant over !!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Didn't brighouse get kicked out not to long ago? That's up your way isn't it?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dont think the punishment is severe enough,time and time again it is the same teams that are involved in the uglyscenes.If they wan to fight then let them go elsewhwere away from a rugby pitch and stop dragging our great game through the gutter,it nearly always involves a team from the Leeds area causing the trouble,you dont often see the top sides from leigh,Wigan,Halifax,Hull causing problems,they just want to play rugby on a saturday.Mayfield used to have a bad reputation in the eighties for bullying and intimidating teams and referees,until they met their match in Elland who demorolised them time and time again..leopards never change their spots it seams....rant over !!!!

Google Rochdale Mayfield v Siddal on youtube and see what you come up with.

As regards dragging our great game through the gutter, it's little weasels like yourself who come on these forums and rather than talking about rugby make snide comments about every team except their own and think that people don't pick up on it. Grow up and disappear.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just because they scored a try straight after half time does not mean that they were going to win, especially when there was at least 25 minutes left in the game. Plus if the game has not played over a certain time frame (68 mins) the result at the time should not stand and a rematch should take place. It’s a poor decision made.

Having been involved in a fair few games that have been abandoned in my playing days the time when a game doesn't have to be played again is 60 minutes unless the NCL have their own by-law.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Didn't brighouse get kicked out not to long ago? That's up your way isn't it?

Playing illegal players

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dont think the punishment is severe enough,time and time again it is the same teams that are involved in the uglyscenes.If they wan to fight then let them go elsewhwere away from a rugby pitch and stop dragging our great game through the gutter,it nearly always involves a team from the Leeds area causing the trouble,you dont often see the top sides from leigh,Wigan,Halifax,Hull causing problems,they just want to play rugby on a saturday.Mayfield used to have a bad reputation in the eighties for bullying and intimidating teams and referees,until they met their match in Elland who demorolised them time and time again..leopards never change their spots it seams....rant over !!!!

 

Making an idiot of yourself for the 2nd time this week I see!

 

Go away, learn your rugby then come back.

 

And you mention top teams from Halifax. Insinuating there is more than one. Please name them!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think you will find that Ovenden were expelled for not fulfilling fixtures,Brighouse for playing ringers.As for Mr hunslet giant,arnt Ovenden and Elland only 1 division below your fantastic club ?..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think you will find that Ovenden were expelled for not fulfilling fixtures,Brighouse for playing ringers.As for Mr hunslet giant,arnt Ovenden and Elland only 1 division below your fantastic club ?..

Let me get this right. East Hull can't hang onto players, Leigh East have in house wrangling, Hunslet Warriors think they're fantastic when they're not, Rochdale Mayfield are bullies and it's always teams from Leeds who are involved in fighting and dragging our game through the gutter. If you are a team in the Halifax area you are perfect. Yes got it - now please go away.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dont think the punishment is severe enough,time and time again it is the same teams that are involved in the uglyscenes.If they wan to fight then let them go elsewhwere away from a rugby pitch and stop dragging our great game through the gutter,it nearly always involves a team from the Leeds area causing the trouble,you dont often see the top sides from leigh,Wigan,Halifax,Hull causing problems,they just want to play rugby on a saturday.Mayfield used to have a bad reputation in the eighties for bullying and intimidating teams and referees,until they met their match in Elland who demorolised them time and time again..leopards never change their spots it seams....rant over !!!!

Please elaborate on your statement. What other teams from Leeds area have had matches abandoned

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Having been involved in a fair few games that have been abandoned in my playing days the time when a game doesn't have to be played again is 60 minutes unless the NCL have their own by-law.

Thats my point mate, the game was not played past 60 minutes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

all getting boring now,heres a fact for u all know matter what u say or think the issue been delt with and the clubs have been fined and the game stands and the WARRIORS collect the 2 points so why dont u all put that in u pipes in smoke it ;-);-);-)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I reckon every team has had a brawl go on you tube there's a good one of Rochdale Mayfield v siddal on there started by Rochdale, point is every team has done it some times it happens time to move on if there's a reverse game settle that way thro rugby

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wasn't it siddal against Fev Lions when there were a number of mass brawls. May have been Yorkshire cup I think.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think you will find that Ovenden were expelled for not fulfilling fixtures,Brighouse for playing ringers.As for Mr hunslet giant,arnt Ovenden and Elland only 1 division below your fantastic club ?..

 

Do you mean division below as in the 3rd tier of the NCL?  hardly makes them top teams does it?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I reckon every team has had a brawl go on you tube there's a good one of Rochdale Mayfield v siddal on there started by Rochdale, point is every team has done it some times it happens time to move on if there's a reverse game settle that way thro rugby

Spot on. Hope this is end of this thread now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.