Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Historical value

OA arl rip

481 posts in this topic

Not sure what you are insinuating, but you can,t complain about a shortage of players in one breath and be happy about ex ncl players kicking their heels on pay as you play contracts in another. What harm is there in letting them return to their amateur club when not selected. It's no different than the old trialist, an other system. It's now obvious that the standards of some of the individuals in championship one is similar to the best players in ncl. So it should not have a massive bearing on the league, plus everyone will be in same boat

The pro clubs would not like it, so is that not reason enough to try make it work. I know there will be the calls that you have to register and you are not covered by insurance, maybe even health and safety, but IMO they are just red herrings

What happens when the championship clubs want their player/players back & the guy who hasn't had a game for a couple of weeks because he is deemed to be the weakest link when the luxury of having championship players available & he says "I've decided to work", or "I'm taking the family to the coast"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 But you are forgetting that in his two weeks off he could get married and go on holiday so everyone is happy. Next.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not sure what you are insinuating, but you can,t complain about a shortage of players in one breath and be happy about ex ncl players kicking their heels on pay as you play contracts in another. What harm is there in letting them return to their amateur club when not selected. It's no different than the old trialist, an other system. It's now obvious that the standards of some of the individuals in championship one is similar to the best players in ncl. So it should not have a massive bearing on the league, plus everyone will be in same boat

The pro clubs would not like it, so is that not reason enough to try make it work. I know there will be the calls that you have to register and you are not covered by insurance, maybe even health and safety, but IMO they are just red herrings

 

Quite clearly the player pool is rapidly dropping to drought level following the decision by the RFL to switch the game to summer. This was a decision made by the RFL in order to implement the pyramid structure to support the professional game built from Super league downwards with totally no regard to the amateur game.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sue Taylor has to be given time to find her feet, and unfortunately for her has been thrown in at the deep end in a very uncertain time for the amateur game.

Maybe BARLA need to change tactics slightly and speak to all the amateur clubs to try and find the real root of the problems within the game and make a presentation to Sport England based on the findings of 75% of the game rather than allowing the RFL to ride rough shot over all of us with their 'big brother knows best' attitude.

At the end of the day it is the amateur clubs who are working at the coal face and they know more about the game than probably most of the RFL employees.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quite clearly the player pool is rapidly dropping to drought level following the decision by the RFL to switch the game to summer. This was a decision made by the RFL in order to implement the pyramid structure to support the professional game built from Super league downwards with totally no regard to the amateur game.

Was player participation dropping prior to the switch?

I'm pretty certain that participation levels are dropping at alarming rates in all sports including cricket, football and rugby union. Junior rugby union in Cumbria has hardly any participation at all, so is that the fault of rugby union staying in winter and asking players to train and play in the cold and wet?

Your quote Nev is exactly the point I was trying to make in an earlier email. All that ever happens on any BARLA related thread on here is to try and have a quick dig and blame everything on the summer switch. I appreciate playing in May, June and July doesn't work in some areas, but it does in others.

So, has BARLA ever consulted the clubs on the state of the game at junior /amateur level?

If they have done, when was the last time?

I'm talking about an in-depth report a well, not just a 'do you want to play in winter or summer question?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can only speak for the NWC juniors but before the switch to the " RFL SUMMER SEASON " we had year on year steady growth then this season we have seen a 12% drop in participation facts confirmed by the RFL after they reported an almost 20 % growth in our area .

 

We are getting more games cancelled then in our traditional season due not to weather conditions but to unavailability of players and coaches .

 

Facts I,m afraid  not fiction .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Taxi Egg, you are correct, those are the facts from your league and someone at BARLA should be collating all the factual information together to form the basis of a report on the demise of rugby at grass roots level and present the factual report to teh community board and sport england.

Junior rugby league in Cumbria is in a bit of state and has been for several years, but it does seem to be getting worse at the minute at 12 - 16 years of age. The Festivals for mini-mod seem to be working and there is a good healthy participation from non-traditional clubs which may bare fruit in the years to come, but in the short term there is a problem with numbers and everyone has their on ideas on what /where the game went wrong.

Maybe the local leagues should be organising forums with the 12 and 14 year old players, then hold something similar with coaches to try and get their views. the results of any such forum with juniors may be surprising, it could be something as simple as they don't like the game anymore!

One thing is for certain, if nobody bothers to ask, then the powers that be will never know!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'll be interested to see if anyone from BARLA tries to contact people in the Midlands, and other non-traditional areas, as part of their fact-finding mission.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'll be interested to see if anyone from BARLA tries to contact people in the Midlands, and other non-traditional areas, as part of their fact-finding mission.

One step at a time, there's nothing concrete that a fact finding mission is imminent in the "traditional" areas yet

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One step at a time, there's nothing concrete that a fact finding mission is imminent in the "traditional" areas yet

Actually I'm not convinced that anyone will do an unbiased one that doesn't aim for the conclusion for which they are looking.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tim 2 you should know this and for your information Spidey and Rah Rah ,the RFL the governing body are conducting a full study across all the leagues to determine the impact or otherwise of games cancelled and as to their reasons ,this can not be biased in any way .

 

Time will tell if the figures are made public.

 

But I for one would hope we the leagues will be given the results before they are passed to the community board for approval . ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'll be interested to see if anyone from BARLA tries to contact people in the Midlands, and other non-traditional areas, as part of their fact-finding mission.

Tim the RFL never contacted one of our players, committee or coaching staff about going to summer when they did their poll's and at that time we where part of the RLC with something like 70 plus players registered.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Was player participation dropping prior to the switch?

I'm pretty certain that participation levels are dropping at alarming rates in all sports including cricket, football and rugby union. Junior rugby union in Cumbria has hardly any participation at all, so is that the fault of rugby union staying in winter and asking players to train and play in the cold and wet?

Your quote Nev is exactly the point I was trying to make in an earlier email. All that ever happens on any BARLA related thread on here is to try and have a quick dig and blame everything on the summer switch. I appreciate playing in May, June and July doesn't work in some areas, but it does in others.

So, has BARLA ever consulted the clubs on the state of the game at junior /amateur level?

If they have done, when was the last time?

I'm talking about an in-depth report a well, not just a 'do you want to play in winter or summer question?

 

The decline in all areas of sport over the last few years has been well documented and recognised. However, when the RFL blindly make a promise to deliver more participation, in their debate for the summer swing, then I believe that they should be held accountable for the acceleration of the appalling decline in numbers, that the summer switch is responsible for.

 

And how was all this done, on the back of a very highly loaded telephone consultation from which the RFL surprisingly found, "a clear desire to play summer rugby." Well I would hope that the RFL have saved some phone numbers to consult all the "polees" once again and ask, where the hell are they on a Saturday afternoon.

 

All well and good if the summer switch had done the trick, then hats off to the RFL and Sport England (tax payers') money well spent. I'm sure that the full review of the game when completed will have some highly massaged figures to prop up the RFL's decision to bulldoze the game into summer.  Other than that, I would say that it's only a matter of time before the RFL - especially with the youth game - and are forced to admit that it's just not working.

 

I think that the open age game up in your neck of the woods mainly answers some of your questions DTTRR, it seems that BARLA simply asked the Cumbrians what they needed for their new league and then delivered. No consultation needed and horror of horrors my friend, their season has successfully leapt the boundaries of the traditional season and now starts with a March kick off.

 

It seems that the wiley Cumbrians found it fit to poll their clubs and acted on their democratic wishes and moved to where the clubs and more importantly the players, had indicated that they wanted to be. 

 

And for the record DTTRR, I can remember our club taking part in a BARLA consultation on behalf of my roughly at the same time as the RFL had their phone in. After consultation with the 30 or so players we have, our club, along with the other 80% of the clubs that took part opted to remain and still are, playing in a traditional season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tim 2 you should know this and for your information Spidey and Rah Rah ,the RFL the governing body are conducting a full study across all the leagues to determine the impact or otherwise of games cancelled and as to their reasons ,this can not be biased in any way .

 

Time will tell if the figures are made public.

 

But I for one would hope we the leagues will be given the results before they are passed to the community board for approval . ;)

 

Our Open Age have played 100% of their fixtures, and the U16s have had one game conceded by a Leeds based team (at our place). So, if you look at the pure figueres for completion, it would be high. However, if you asked us how many games were played at full strength, it wouldn't be anywhere near 100%.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What happens when the championship clubs want their player/players back & the guy who hasn't had a game for a couple of weeks because he is deemed to be the weakest link when the luxury of having championship players available & he says "I've decided to work", or "I'm taking the family to the coast"

Hang on a minute, you said there weren, t enough players make your mind up. If there is then you just don, t pick the championship player. He might realise the grass isn, t greener then.

But it would be up to each club how they handle it.me personally would only pick a championship player if it did not upset anyo

ne its called man management

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hang on a minute, you said there weren, t enough players make your mind up. If there is then you just don, t pick the championship player. He might realise the grass isn, t greener then.

But it would be up to each club how they handle it.me personally would only pick a championship player if it did not upset anyo

ne its called man management

So the luxury of professionals will only go to struggling clubs (doubt it one little bit) then when the pro's are recalled the clubs who are not struggling will start to.

 

Each club to handle it how they choose, your making me laugh, human nature will take control and a free for all will break out destroying any sense of honesty,

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Our Open Age have played 100% of their fixtures, and the U16s have had one game conceded by a Leeds based team (at our place). So, if you look at the pure figueres for completion, it would be high. However, if you asked us how many games were played at full strength, it wouldn't be anywhere near 100%.

How many teams compete in your OA competition ?

And are you saying that every game as been played as scheduled ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The point most people are missing is ,does every team in the competition have access to "pro players" ? If not the league is not operating on a level playing field so bringing into question the integrity of the competition .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Which bit of so called pro players returning to their amateur club did eveyone choose to ignore. They will end up there one

day anyway.

The same people saying there are not enough players are the same people objecting to the solution because one team might have an advantage over another.

I think dttrr has hit the nail on the head as have others. The main problems ncl clubs have is that they take weakened teams to away games, but they still turn up. This tends to even out over the season to create really competitive leagues with unpredictable results. Exactly what sport is meant to be about .

League 3 excluded apart from top 4 as it is in its infancy

Barla don, t seem to want to address the problems as it will mean changing their rules and accepting that maybe some people just don, t want to play rugby

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The returning of pros back to the amateur game is not the issue that as always happened , its the idea of dual registration that is the issue people are debating Old Fiddle .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 its the idea of dual registration that is the issue people are debating Old Fiddle .

There's only you debating it  :bye:

 

i told you 18 pages ago, it won't be introduced in the NCL.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There's only you debating it  :bye:

 

i told you 18 pages ago, it won't be introduced in the NCL.

 

It seems that people at a higher level are debating it I'm afraid Raider and those people will implement it

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Which bit of so called pro players returning to their amateur club did eveyone choose to ignore. They will end up there one

day anyway.

The same people saying there are not enough players are the same people objecting to the solution because one team might have an advantage over another.

I think dttrr has hit the nail on the head as have others. The main problems ncl clubs have is that they take weakened teams to away games, but they still turn up. This tends to even out over the season to create really competitive leagues with unpredictable results. Exactly what sport is meant to be about .

League 3 excluded apart from top 4 as it is in its infancy

Barla don, t seem to want to address the problems as it will mean changing their rules and accepting that maybe some people just don, t want to play rugby

 

It's quite simple Fiddler, the players are signed on professional contracts (contracted players) and the rules of the amateur games don't allow them in the amateur game. Cake and eating it not allowed.

 

Ex players (non contracted players) returning to the amateur game - the rules do allow that. Smell the coffee while you're tasting the cake

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How many teams compete in your OA competition ?

And are you saying that every game as been played as scheduled ?

 

Exactly - as with any survey it depends on what you ask. 10 teams, out of 54 games so far 3 have been conceded, all by 'A' teams.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Which bit of so called pro players returning to their amateur club did eveyone choose to ignore. They will end up there one

day anyway.

The same people saying there are not enough players are the same people objecting to the solution because one team might have an advantage over another.

I think dttrr has hit the nail on the head as have others. The main problems ncl clubs have is that they take weakened teams to away games, but they still turn up. This tends to even out over the season to create really competitive leagues with unpredictable results. Exactly what sport is meant to be about .

League 3 excluded apart from top 4 as it is in its infancy

Barla don, t seem to want to address the problems as it will mean changing their rules and accepting that maybe some people just don, t want to play rugby

 

So that is in the best interests of the sport is it at OA level is it?

 

Beggars belief that you could think it is a positive on the grounds you state!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.



League Express - Mon 10th April 2017

Rugby League World - April 2017