Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

fillipo del toro

Negative Post Time, So If Your Easily Offended Turn Away Now

23 posts in this topic

Change the clueless numpties who are running the club first or matt will not have a chance

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The board aren't gonna change anytime soon they were voted in and will have to be voted out. I imagine the coach may well have to walk as he clearly can't get a response from the players. If that means the end of the Saints relationship then so be it, we'll survive without a posh gym and AstroTurf.

For me regardless of the coach, the future of Rochdale Hornets MUST involve the young Rochdale lads coming out of the Super league systems, along side a proper experienced pack of 100%ers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The board aren't gonna change anytime soon they were voted in and will have to be voted out. I imagine the coach may well have to walk as he clearly can't get a response from the players. If that means the end of the Saints relationship then so be it, we'll survive without a posh gym and AstroTurf.

For me regardless of the coach, the future of Rochdale Hornets MUST involve the young Rochdale lads coming out of the Super league systems, along side a proper experienced pack of 100%ers.

The way 1 or 2 have been treated recently i can't see that happening !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The board aren't gonna change anytime soon they were voted in and will have to be voted out. I imagine the coach may well have to walk as he clearly can't get a response from the players. If that means the end of the Saints relationship then so be it, we'll survive without a posh gym and AstroTurf.

For me regardless of the coach, the future of Rochdale Hornets MUST involve the young Rochdale lads coming out of the Super league systems, along side a proper experienced pack of 100%ers.

Great post Tiger, but my post was pretty clear. can we have a name? I assure you members will talk to you again if you pin your colours to the mast. The club needs to listen. Is it an attendance of 250 before they do?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Matt Calland

Difference being as I see it, he has a successful history of managing men, all Talbot's experience is with youth.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Matt Calland.

I hope that he would motivate the players more than Ian Talbot seems to. I didn't see the last two games because I was on holiday. I expected Crusaders to beat us but to not even get a bonus point from either of the two matches is poor.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Matt Calland

Difference being as I see it, he has a successful history of managing men, all Talbot's experience is with youth.

Cheers Tiger, 2 grand finals & a win with Fax. With a pretty sound playing career as well. Most of all he's ROCHDALE Hornets.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So...has anyone thought that if MC got the job right now, whether there would be a team to pick from for the remaining games...with injuries etc it's already bare bones time, plus the inevitable player exodus at semi-pro level when a coach who brought them in is turfed out...

 

not saying it will happen, we've just seen it sooooo many times before.

 

Judge the coaching team and players when the season is over - still in our hands is it not?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So...has anyone thought that if MC got the job right now, whether there would be a team to pick from for the remaining games...with injuries etc it's already bare bones time, plus the inevitable player exodus at semi-pro level when a coach who brought them in is turfed out...

 

not saying it will happen, we've just seen it sooooo many times before.

 

Judge the coaching team and players when the season is over - still in our hands is it not?

 

So what are you saying - be held to ransom by the players?

 

Its not normal that players would leave just because of a change in coach and to be honest if the current crop are that fickle then is it worth even having them?

 

This is one of the worst hornets sides ever and changes need to be made to avoid a further decline

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The way I understand it before the St Helens link up was finalised the decision had been made to give the job to Matt Calland - then Saints got involved and IanTalbot was given the job.

 

Matt would have been the correct choice for all the reasons mentioned on here including: Grand Final Winner (division above), lives in Rochdale, Links locally to amature game and Hopwood Hall and a genuine passion for Hornets a club that he played at for a large part of his career - instead we appointed a guy who with all due respect has no record in the open age coaching game and asked Matt to work under him - that dosent stack up 

 

Who made that decision? and is whoever made that decision going to hold their hands up and admit that it hasnt worked by showing some bottle and correcting their mistake?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So what are you saying - be held to ransom by the players?

 

Its not normal that players would leave just because of a change in coach and to be honest if the current crop are that fickle then is it worth even having them?

 

This is one of the worst hornets sides ever and changes need to be made to avoid a further decline

 

Every club is held to ransom by the players at semi-pro level...unless you are rich enough to take that out of the equation by paying them a significant amount.

 

How many of the players are there because they brought in this season is what i'm saying - with 5 home games left and players returning from injury it would be a big gamble to start again right now, but the guys at the top need to either put up or shut up and let us all get behind the team whoever the coach is.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are the borrowed players not contracted to Saints? I know a few are definately but not sure about others. In fact how many players do Hornets employ even just on a game by game basis, is there any kind of contract? Appologies for all the questions.

 

I imagine we wouldnt be able to change coach without Saints spitting the dummy and pulling out totally,   wasnt his appointment a pre-requisite of the whole partnership? They almost hired him on our behalf would they have to remove on our behalf?

 

And surely they would want to provide another coach?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The deal with Saints seems to have been a 2 edged sword. The use of facilities you could only have dreamed of having, but at a cost. What would you have done?

Hind-sight is always 20 - 20 vision. Fore-sight is at least 35% luck.

Still, if you're all that unhappy with the people running things your board elections are not far off....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We had a similar situation when Steve Eyre was appointed. His experience was of dealing with some of the best talent in the game but it was a million miles away from what League One football was all about. It's one thing coaching kids with a natural ability but its a different matter completely working with men who with the best will in the world might not be blessed with all the talent. Players complained about being treated like kids and the tactics involved went repeatedly over their heads,

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This was discussed at the members meeting last week. Ian Talbot is the coach until the end of the season.He has the full backing of the players. Hemel were a really good side yesterday. The hospitality we had was first class.The fans were singing the Hornets new song.Disappointed at losing, win a few lose a few, thats the way it goes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If oxford win at Gateshead this weekend we will move down to sixth place.

If we manage to savage the season and get into the play off's it's a good thing that the away hospitality is good because we will be playing away for certain. I just hope that it is not at whitebank.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This was discussed at the members meeting last week. Ian Talbot is the coach until the end of the season.He has the full backing of the players. Hemel were a really good side yesterday. The hospitality we had was first class.The fans were singing the Hornets new song.Disappointed at losing, win a few lose a few, thats the way it goes.

 

Excellent post mickhornet.  Its good to hear from the people that actually attended the game and yes you are right Hemel were a very good side and they will certainly be there abouts at the end of the season.

 

As for replacing the present coach I defy any coach either in our division or the super league to overcome the handicap of fielding a team short of ten regular first teamers.  Lets see what miracle Matt could perform with such an handicap?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.



Rugby League World - April 2017

League Express - Mon 10th April 2017