Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

keighley

The advantages of DR to Championship clubs in revue

82 posts in this topic

In previous discussions on this subject it was stated that Hunslet were a better team with higher attendances and the highest league placings for many years due to the Dual registration players from Leeds  boosting the quality of their team.

 

Swinton had the whole Warrington squad registered as their players and, in fact Lee Briers and Adrian Morley have turned out for them amongst others. This led to conjecture that Swinton would become a power in the division  and DR would greatly benefit them and the situation would be a win win for both Swinton and Warrington,

 

Rochdale had a strong player and coaching link up with Saints. Wigan adopted South Wales and Skolars were sjuppose to be a power using Broncos DR players.

 

The reality seems to be that independent Championship clubs Featherstone, Halifax and Sheffield are the class of that league and Hunslet and Swinton are occupying the relegation spots.

 

The class of CC1 are the independent Crusaders and South Wales, Skolars and Rochdale are having sub par seasons barely in touch with play off positions and the Hull KR linked Gateshead are next to bottom

 

The Championship teams linked with the major SL powers, Leeds, St Helens, Wigan and Warrington are poor. This would seem to suggest that the DR system is a one way street being of benefit only to the SL teams concerned and of little help in boosting the playing fortunes of the lower tier teams in the partnerships.

 

I wonder if these championship teams and their supporters are now still convinced that the dual registration system is a positive development.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

despite all my reservations surrounding the whole DR/feeder club debabte.....our link up with salford seems to be working well,i think thats primarily down too how we & salford have used the system....we've taken a couple or 3? salford kids on long term loans instead of salford 1st teamers rocking up for a game and sodding off...as well as still taking other players on loan from other SL teams..ie nathan mason from huddersfield...

and we're currently top of championship 1

i feel if lower league clubs adopt the policy of only signing super league kids on season long loans then it'll serve the game better and take away the negativity around the whole thing..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's quite pleasing that the two clubs that have completely taken the Micky are in the relegation spots.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's quite pleasing that the two clubs that have completely taken the Micky are in the relegation spots.

Here here!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You could argue that they were the weakest clubs anyway, so that's no great surprise.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm quite happy with the link up between York and Hull. Its going well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

the link ups can be a two way thing, we at widnes are looking at the young promising players coming through at workington whilst they are helping to develop some of our young players in return. ok we have sent the odd first team player up there but they were basically to cover for injuries etc etc. i am really excited at the prospect of the phillips brothers possibly coming to widnes, they are both extremely good prospects.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Of course, if Swinton and co were up near the top of the table, Keighley and co would also be saying it was a farce, unfair etc. Bets nicely hedged.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The existing loan system worked perfectly well and had no need to be changed. DR was devised specifically to benefit SL clubs who were being forced to reform their academy system. they then spun this to give the appearance of it being intended to be some sort of altruistic move to help the championship clubs. In reality it is a shambolic nonsense and in danger of alienating supporters of championship clubs who are facing enough difficulties hanging on to the supporters that they currently have.

 

If it is not scrapped or fundamentally altered to truly help these clubs then I expect crowds to drift even further down next season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

i am really excited at the prospect of the phillips brothers possibly coming to widnes, they are both extremely good prospects.

Can't see that happening TBH, rumour has it they're bound for West Yorkshire.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The existing loan system worked perfectly well and had no need to be changed. DR was devised specifically to benefit SL clubs who were being forced to reform their academy system. they then spun this to give the appearance of it being intended to be some sort of altruistic move to help the championship clubs. In reality it is a shambolic nonsense and in danger of alienating supporters of championship clubs who are facing enough difficulties hanging on to the supporters that they currently have.

If it is not scrapped or fundamentally altered to truly help these clubs then I expect crowds to drift even further down next season.

If the DR system only suits SL clubs why don't championship clubs use the loan system instead which is still in place. My guess is because it costs money where as the DR players are coming cheaper/free. With the DR being cheaper clubs lose the control they get with loaned players its a choice championship clubs make.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

the link ups can be a two way thing, we at widnes are looking at the young promising players coming through at workington whilst they are helping to develop some of our young players in return. ok we have sent the odd first team player up there but they were basically to cover for injuries etc etc. i am really excited at the prospect of the phillips brothers possibly coming to widnes, they are both extremely good prospects.

 

This is exactly my point. it's a positive situation for Widnes, the SL club, but what do Workington get out of it?.

 

For instance, Keighley, when playing Castleford players were bottom of the league. No Castleford player has graced our ranks since March and now the team is on a winning streak and slowly climbing to safety. What therefore was the advantage to Keighley from this link up?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Of course, if Swinton and co were up near the top of the table, Keighley and co would also be saying it was a farce, unfair etc. Bets nicely hedged.

 

Oh yes, I would resent any Swinton success based on that and I think that Swinton and co hoped that this was what would happen, but it appears the exact opposite has occurred. Hence I am posing the question " What are the benefits in these arrangements for the Championship clubs. Seems to be a one way street to me

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Can't see that happening TBH, rumour has it they're bound for West Yorkshire.

hopefully not both callum and brett have big futures in the game and i hope that it is with widnes........

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is exactly my point. it's a positive situation for Widnes, the SL club, but what do Workington get out of it?.

 

For instance, Keighley, when playing Castleford players were bottom of the league. No Castleford player has graced our ranks since March and now the team is on a winning streak and slowly climbing to safety. What therefore was the advantage to Keighley from this link up?

Workington got to call on (mostly) young good players when we were lacking through injury and suspension, something we have struggled with over the past 3 seasons when we have consistently ran out of players. This meant we could continue to compete with other clubs, meaning a more competitive league rather than getting shallackings when we were down to dragging in ex players and local kids. What good would those beating have done those young players?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

hopefully not both callum and brett have big futures in the game and i hope that it is with widnes........

Frankly, I also hope its Widnes as it would set a very good precedent for DR, and would show theres a two way door to it. Both the Phillips boys have what it takes to step up to SL in my opinion, though I`m not as sure they can be at the top teams. No offence to Widnes obviously, but I think they would get more game time there to begin with.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Workington got to call on (mostly) young good players when we were lacking through injury and suspension, something we have struggled with over the past 3 seasons when we have consistently ran out of players. This meant we could continue to compete with other clubs, meaning a more competitive league rather than getting shallackings when we were down to dragging in ex players and local kids. What good would those beating have done those young players?

Plus our agreement with Widnes is a genuine 2-way deal which sees young lads like Jack Gaskell, who aren't quite ready for Championship level, getting to play in Widnes' U19 team while being retained as Town players.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Plus our agreement with Widnes is a genuine 2-way deal which sees young lads like Jack Gaskell, who aren't quite ready for Championship level, getting to play in Widnes' U19 team while being retained as Town players.

I heard on the weekend there are others lined up to go the other way at some point, I presumed it was that young lad who left to go to uni.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i agree, DR should be a two way link up, there are many talented young lads out there with limited access to super league clubs, the development of the game as a whole will benefit from the system if we can unearth another hardaker or hill. brett and callum are certainly up there with the best in the championship at the moment, and they can both make the grade...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh yes, I would resent any Swinton success based on that and I think that Swinton and co hoped that this was what would happen, but it appears the exact opposite has occurred. Hence I am posing the question " What are the benefits in these arrangements for the Championship clubs. Seems to be a one way street to me

It is.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

I heard on the weekend there are others lined up to go the other way at some point, I presumed it was that young lad who left to go to uni.

Yes I think it is young Keiran McAvoy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Skolars were sjuppose to be a power using Broncos DR players.

 

Skolars are having sub par seasons barely in touch with play off positions

Skolars are in a play off position in 5th with 2 games in hand. They have never before qualified for the play offs.

Broncos' other DR club Hemel are in 3rd

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Skolars are in a play off position in 5th with 2 games in hand. They have never before qualified for the play offs.

Broncos' other DR club Hemel are in 3rd

If Skolars and Hemel are to exist as farm clubs to the Bronco's then thats fine, but quite frankly when they get to finals and such it dont really mean as much as it should does it?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.



League Express - Mon 24th July 2017

Rugby League World - August 2017