Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

paulmac

Mid December Grand Final

25 posts in this topic

Hey guys you can shout me down as another Aussie who dosn't get the English game if you like,but I was thinking to myself the other day about how much I hate summer over here in Aus because there is no RL. It made me think that perhaps there is an opportunity for Super League to cash in on the Aussie tv market by starting the season in April (maybe Easter weekend) and finish in mid December.

Some pros for this would be Australian superstars like Billy Slater, Greg Inglis or even your own Sam Burgess could jump on a plane soon as their NRL season finishes and have a mini stint ala Andrew Johns at Warrington. It would even be possible for mini Kangaroo tours to recommence with say four club matches aswell as tests rather than the shotgun tours we get now. We would also keep summer rugby and all the benefits that entails. My only downside is what would happen in a World Cup year. Now over to you guys to be shouted down.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And it begins. We know the NRL aren't going to move our season. I was just thinking it would be a way for players to earn a bit of extra coin. If a players team was eliminated from the finals your club could have say Feleti Mateo for September, October, November so roughly 12 games. When no foreign player can make the dream team it says a lot about the current state of imports.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And it begins. We know the NRL aren't going to move our season. I was just thinking it would be a way for players to earn a bit of extra coin. If a players team was eliminated from the finals your club could have say Feleti Mateo for September, October, November so roughly 12 games. When no foreign player can make the dream team it says a lot about the current state of imports.

or says home players have improved and are now as good as the imports if not better, which must be the case with the number of UK players now playing in the NRL

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey guys you can shout me down as another Aussie who dosn't get the English game if you like,but I was thinking to myself the other day about how much I hate summer over here in Aus because there is no RL. It made me think that perhaps there is an opportunity for Super League to cash in on the Aussie tv market by starting the season in April (maybe Easter weekend) and finish in mid December.

Some pros for this would be Australian superstars like Billy Slater, Greg Inglis or even your own Sam Burgess could jump on a plane soon as their NRL season finishes and have a mini stint ala Andrew Johns at Warrington. It would even be possible for mini Kangaroo tours to recommence with say four club matches aswell as tests rather than the shotgun tours we get now. We would also keep summer rugby and all the benefits that entails. My only downside is what would happen in a World Cup year. Now over to you guys to be shouted down.

I think there is some merit in this. You could even have a mid season break perhaps the Challenge Cup Final could bring down the curtain on the first half of the season. It would also mean when there is another major sporting occasion like the Olympics or soccer World Cup they would not be distracting the media and spectators away.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And it begins. We know the NRL aren't going to move our season. I was just thinking it would be a way for players to earn a bit of extra coin. If a players team was eliminated from the finals your club could have say Feleti Mateo for September, October, November so roughly 12 games. When no foreign player can make the dream team it says a lot about the current state of imports.

If you moved your season, then maybe some of the underpaid Suer League players could earn some extra coin rather than the NRL players NRL players that already earn significantly more

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey guys you can shout me down as another Aussie who dosn't get the English game if you like,but I was thinking to myself the other day about how much I hate summer over here in Aus because there is no RL.

With the exception of Townsville & Brisbane the aussie summer isn't so hot that players couldn't play in it. Far easier for them to move their season.

If the SL moved back to winter there would be far more disruption due to snow & frozen pitches.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

With the exception of Townsville & Brisbane the aussie summer isn't so hot that players couldn't play in it. Far easier for them to move their season.

If the SL moved back to winter there would be far more disruption due to snow & frozen pitches.

When was there ever snow and frozen pitches before mid-December?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't have a hankering for a switch back to Winter, but I'd pull our season forward not push back given the choice.

 

Start on Boxing Day with local derbies, we'd then have a season that took in all the UK bank holidays plus the play-offs and grand final would be pulled forward, meaning we'd be able to showcase our major event a month or so earlier and whilst the british weather offers no guarentees it would greatly increase the odds of it being played out on a dry track watched by folk in shirt sleaves - which is what summer rugbys all about afterall!

 

If the Aussies left there season as is, our players would have the added advantage of being able to earn some "extra coin" by guesting down under onc ethere involvement in the UK season was over and judging by the recent recruitment of British talent for the NRL they need our help, would be a win win!  ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When was there ever snow and frozen pitches before mid-December?

7/8 December 1990 major disruption especially in Wales and the Midlands. The M6 was completely closed for 2 days.

I travelled to North Wales on the Friday with some friends . We couldn't get through to the cottage we had booked and spent 2 nights in Llanwrst.

On the way back on the Sunday we were fortunate to have ice axes and crampons so were able to help other motorists.

There was even an abandoned Securicor van near Birmingham Airport.

But your right that was a bit of an exception. To prove this, the same weekend the following year 1991 we were sunbathing on the beach in Barmouth.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

7/8 December 1990 major disruption especially in Wales and the Midlands. The M6 was completely closed for 2 days.

I travelled to North Wales on the Friday with some friends . We couldn't get through to the cottage we had booked and spent 2 nights in Llanwrst.

On the way back on the Sunday we were fortunate to have ice axes and crampons so were able to help other motorists.

There was even an abandoned Securicor van near Birmingham Airport.

But your right that was a bit of an exception. To prove this, the same weekend the following year 1991 we were sunbathing on the beach in Barmouth.

I remember it well as I was stuck near Corley Sevices for hours before a lorry driver took down the central reservation barriers and I turned round and went back to London. Interestingly, the Widnes game that afternoon went ahead as I watched it on Grandstand when I got home.

I have no desire to go back to winter rugby.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And it begins. We know the NRL aren't going to move our season. I was just thinking it would be a way for players to earn a bit of extra coin. If a players team was eliminated from the finals your club could have say Feleti Mateo for September, October, November so roughly 12 games. When no foreign player can make the dream team it says a lot about the current state of imports.

 

Players don't get enough rest as it is.  The last thing they need is more opportunity to play games.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't have a hankering for a switch back to Winter, but I'd pull our season forward not push back given the choice.

 

Start on Boxing Day with local derbies, we'd then have a season that took in all the UK bank holidays plus the play-offs and grand final would be pulled forward, meaning we'd be able to showcase our major event a month or so earlier and whilst the british weather offers no guarentees it would greatly increase the odds of it being played out on a dry track watched by folk in shirt sleaves - which is what summer rugbys all about afterall!

 

If the Aussies left there season as is, our players would have the added advantage of being able to earn some "extra coin" by guesting down under onc ethere involvement in the UK season was over and judging by the recent recruitment of British talent for the NRL they need our help, would be a win win!  ;)

I like this idea.

I'm a big advocate of summer rugby for a number of reasons, but I do find it an unhappy coincidence that this wonderful summer sport has its finals series played in the wind and rain (insert British summer joke here if you're of that bent).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't have a hankering for a switch back to Winter, but I'd pull our season forward not push back given the choice.

 

Start on Boxing Day with local derbies, we'd then have a season that took in all the UK bank holidays plus the play-offs and grand final would be pulled forward, meaning we'd be able to showcase our major event a month or so earlier and whilst the british weather offers no guarentees it would greatly increase the odds of it being played out on a dry track watched by folk in shirt sleaves - which is what summer rugbys all about afterall!

 

If the Aussies left there season as is, our players would have the added advantage of being able to earn some "extra coin" by guesting down under onc ethere involvement in the UK season was over and judging by the recent recruitment of British talent for the NRL they need our help, would be a win win!  ;)

Yes, have thought this a few times. The Boxing Day and New Years Day derbies often attracted very good crowds, even now as friendlies you can get ok crowds, so I think to launch the season on Boxing Day could actually be very good.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, have thought this a few times. The Boxing Day and New Years Day derbies often attracted very good crowds, even now as friendlies you can get ok crowds, so I think to launch the season on Boxing Day could actually be very good.

 

No thanks.  We cover enough of winter anyway.  We should start in March and finish in late Sept/early Oct.  The Aussies have got it right.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No thanks.  We cover enough of winter anyway.  We should start in March and finish in late Sept/early Oct.  The Aussies have got it right.

But without midweek games that isn't possible with our structure.

 

The Aussies have a different structure which allows for a shorter season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey guys you can shout me down as another Aussie who dosn't get the English game if you like,but I was thinking to myself the other day about how much I hate summer over here in Aus because there is no RL. It made me think that perhaps there is an opportunity for Super League to cash in on the Aussie tv market by starting the season in April (maybe Easter weekend) and finish in mid December.

Some pros for this would be Australian superstars like Billy Slater, Greg Inglis or even your own Sam Burgess could jump on a plane soon as their NRL season finishes and have a mini stint ala Andrew Johns at Warrington. It would even be possible for mini Kangaroo tours to recommence with say four club matches aswell as tests rather than the shotgun tours we get now. We would also keep summer rugby and all the benefits that entails. My only downside is what would happen in a World Cup year. Now over to you guys to be shouted down.

 

It's not so much the European game you don't understand as the weather.  The last thing the RFL needs is for bad weather to disrupt arguably their biggest game of the season.  Admittedly, December's free from snow more often than not but 2010 was a bad December.  Frost would be a threat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Lets think how it would effect some players.

They would be expected to play as well as they can. Until a load of Aussies want some extra cash. They would then be dropped and have no chance of playing in the biggest game of the season the GF.

 

Sounds like a daft idea to me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

But without midweek games that isn't possible with our structure.

 

The Aussies have a different structure which allows for a shorter season.

 

We could alter our structure.  The difference is that they look at it as a business, we look at it as a game.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We could alter our structure. The difference is that they look at it as a business, we look at it as a game.

hmm. not convined. The reason we have magic weekend, plus repeat fixtures in the past was down to us treating it like a business.

Comparing the NRL to SL is pointless.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Fair comment.  But we could still alter our structure.  We play from February to October, have a couple of days off, the international players meet up with their World Cup squads, play through to November then rejoin their club squads, who've already started their pre-season training.

 

By contrast, the Aussies have a much more leisurely season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Fair comment.  But we could still alter our structure.  We play from February to October, have a couple of days off, the international players meet up with their World Cup squads, play through to November then rejoin their club squads, who've already started their pre-season training.

 

By contrast, the Aussies have a much more leisurely season.

We could, and if we so desired we could play 22 rounds in a 12 team league, but due to the financial requirements this won't happen.

We could also scrap the cup, I wouldn't be a fan of that either.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.



League Express - Mon 10th April 2017

Rugby League World - April 2017