Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

once a ref always a ref

OP1.23

47 posts in this topic

Slightly off topic but also with regards to non fulfilment fixtures are BDH also up for relegation for non attendance v Rochdale Mayfield?

The NCL need to use some common sense here, no 1 does not just turn up without valid reason as seen with both the Siddal and BDH cases seen this season?

As you say Barbara will be interesting see see outcomes.

BDH never turned up at Wath Brow a couple of years ago and nothing happened !!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The NCL decided a replay was needed and informed the clubs is there anything in the rules about how much notice a club has to be given with regards holding a game.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

and Wath Brow didn't turn up at Dockers three or four years ago and nothing happened too. ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

and Wath Brow didn't turn up at Dockers three or four years ago and nothing happened too. ;)

That must have been the time when they had about a dozen or more players struck down with flu and every player had a sick note off a doctor and where told not turn up by the NCL committee

The 2 nd also could not play in the Cumberland cup the same day and got kicked out by CARLA

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Slightly off topic but also with regards to non fulfilment fixtures are BDH also up for relegation for non attendance v Rochdale Mayfield?

 

The NCL need to use some common sense here, no 1 does not just turn up without valid reason as seen with both the Siddal and BDH cases seen this season?

 

As you say Barbara will be interesting see see outcomes.

 

 

We will be relegated unfortunately, really feel for siddal her although ours was for a completely different reason! I think with regards siddal I think it will be a very disappointing decision if they do get relegated, hope they get the rub of the green

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

BDH never turned up at Wath Brow a couple of years ago and nothing happened !!!

 

The game was rearranged and was mid week! do you think we would leave ourselves needing to beat wath brow by 18 away to stay up! also knowing it was waths finest fan mark laing who was reffing we turned up on a tuesday fighting for our lives with a short side we started with 11 men who he wouldnt let warm up with 4 following in a car and arrived 10 minutes into the game! So if thats not turning up i dont know what is!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We will be relegated unfortunately, really feel for siddal her although ours was for a completely different reason! I think with regards siddal I think it will be a very disappointing decision if they do get relegated, hope they get the rub of the green

Dissapointing as you say - times are tough for all clubs. 

 

How will the league structure work as potentially at the minute we could see Siddal & BDH relegated? Who would stay / move leagues in this situation?

 

Fingers crossed the teams get sorted as soon as possible and can work towards starting next season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It is bad enough that Siddal were being forced to replay the game at West Hull but if they do now get relegated as well it will be an absolute disgrace.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The game was rearranged and was mid week! do you think we would leave ourselves needing to beat wath brow by 18 away to stay up! also knowing it was waths finest fan mark laing who was reffing we turned up on a tuesday fighting for our lives with a short side we started with 11 men who he wouldnt let warm up with 4 following in a car and arrived 10 minutes into the game! So if thats not turning up i dont know what is!

yes that's right you did come up midweek but Wath Brow did not rearrange the game BDH said they could not make the Saturday for some reason so the game was played midweek just the same as happened against Mayfield

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Surely the NCL should have backed the Referee , apparently all three parties agreed to the golden point extra time . The original result should have stood and both clubs wrapped on the knuckles for not knowing the rules .

Did the referee receive any information from the Ncl Administrator re the procedures , our referee appointments officer does inform the refs of competition rules its not rocket science .

 

So are the NCL saying the ref made a mistake , could open a massive can of worms for future disputes .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is unbelievable - Siddal play 26 rounds of the season, win a play off game, then it's taken away from them through no fault of their own - Then could be relegated. You've got to feel for them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why can't they just get a points deduction, not that I agree with it of course? Other clubs have in the past.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 We shouldn't be talking about reducing the punishment, there shouldn't be any punishment.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We shouldn't be talking about reducing the punishment, there shouldn't be any punishment.

WELL SAID a bit of common sense should go a long way in this situation

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Im going to save Marauder a job and say "this would never have happened in winter, refs were perfect then and never made mistakes".

But yes, common sense should be used and if there is any punishment at all for Siddal it is a disgrace and we all as member clubs should make a stand.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dissapointing as you say - times are tough for all clubs. 

 

How will the league structure work as potentially at the minute we could see Siddal & BDH relegated? Who would stay / move leagues in this situation?

 

Fingers crossed the teams get sorted as soon as possible and can work towards starting next season.

 

I personally think it should be the highest finishing side in the relegation zone to stay up as a side finishing 4th in the division below it could be a bit too much of an ask for to be thrust into the league above, obviously no disrespect meant to teams this would apply to

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yes that's right you did come up midweek but Wath Brow did not rearrange the game BDH said they could not make the Saturday for some reason so the game was played midweek just the same as happened against Mayfield

 

Im sure we had asked for the weekend free at the beginning of the season, as if there was anything in it dont you think we would have been relegated that season? and doubly like leigh east were due to finishing in the bottom 3! To be fair who would be able to get a stronger team to go to cumbria on a tuesday night? if you think that was the case you are seriously deluded

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Im going to save Marauder a job and say "this would never have happened in winter, refs were perfect then and never made mistakes".

But yes, common sense should be used and if there is any punishment at all for Siddal it is a disgrace and we all as member clubs should make a stand.

 

Correct, the club have been punished enough already for having to make the decision to withdraw which I fully agree with, plus this whole debacle would have gone into disrupting lock lanes season too had Siddal decided to turn up!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Im sure we had asked for the weekend free at the beginning of the season, as if there was anything in it dont you think we would have been relegated that season? and doubly like leigh east were due to finishing in the bottom 3! To be fair who would be able to get a stronger team to go to cumbria on a tuesday night? if you think that was the case you are seriously deluded

If you asked for a free weekend why was the game only called of on the Friday night and you made to play on the Tuesday night ? Surely the ncl committee would have changed the fixture list before the Friday if you HAD been given a free week off ??? So I must be deluded !!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.



Rugby League World - June 2017

League Express - Mon 17th July 2017