Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

greavesy

Sheffields unfit for purpose stadium.

44 posts in this topic

Just a thaught but if the worst happens  and we are relegated what about a official complaint against the state of Owlerton. There is no way that stadia has the minimum standards. And if the RL are seriose having grounds fit for purpose we have a case. As the highest club relegated we would replace Sheffield. After all if we do get relegated it was Sheffield who did the wingeing about Fairbanks. I am sure the Sheffield chairman and Aston would like that ( not ).

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The RFL are more than aware of the state of owlerton but with Sheffield not being a heartland club they get an exception. If it was Batley or Dewsbury we wouldn't have been allowed to play in this division this year let alone next.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If we go down purely on a points deduction I think we should launch an appeal with regards to very poor running and planning of rugby league in the divisions outside super league. am pretty certain the rl would not welcome a long drawn out event whereby close scrutiny into what goes on behind closed doors at red hall would put them in a very good light.It maybe clutching at straws but anything s worth trying at the moment.we may even get lucky and someone goes bust and we are spared it didn,t do leigh too bad when gateshead collapsed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dont you think sheffield moaned and clutched

at straws to try safe their necks from the oblivion

despicable !!

cant imagine a set of people stooping so low

errr wait a minute ;)

i still believe batley wont go down!!

;) nothing ever goes right ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If we go down purely on a points deduction I think we should launch an appeal with regards to very poor running and planning of rugby league in the divisions outside super league. am pretty certain the rl would not welcome a long drawn out event whereby close scrutiny into what goes on behind closed doors at red hall would put them in a very good light.It maybe clutching at straws but anything s worth trying at the moment.we may even get lucky and someone goes bust and we are spared it didn,t do leigh too bad when gateshead collapsed.

 

How about accepting your fate (assuming you do get relegated) and concentrate on building a team to get back out of Ch1 rather than this ridiculous suggestion of yours.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just a thaught but if the worst happens  and we are relegated what about a official complaint against the state of Owlerton.

 

The RFL said it's fine.  You'd be asking them to say, no it isn't.  Good luck with that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If we are relegated (sorry when) we must accept our fate and move on. IT IS NOT THE END OF THE WORLD and we will be back

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I believe that the RFL quietly shelved the minimum standards requirements part way through last season, based upon the fact that rigorously applying them might have sent a couple of (SL) clubs spiralling out of control. I have been informed, however, that there are a set of minimum requirements being established for the Championship next season that could prove interesting for Sheffield. No doubt they will find a way of avoiding them.

 

(On a completely seperate note why are they being allowed to play a game on CC Final weekend - I thought this wasn't allowed for all clubs except London Skolars.)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

(On a completely seperate note why are they being allowed to play a game on CC Final weekend - I thought this wasn't allowed for all clubs except London Skolars.)

 

Au contraire, Johnny.  We're playing that weekend because the RFL insist upon it.  We wanted to play on a Wednesday evening in June (I forget which one).

 

But apparently Rochdale can't play on Wednesdays.

 

Which raises a whole new tranche of questions and "what ifs"...................

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry but this does not come into the equation IMO. If we are relegated due to a points deduction it is because our management and/or coaching staff either were not aware of the regulations or decided to ignore them. What if our match on that day had been at Fev or Donny or even Dewsbury? What if we had played Sheffield away the first match of the season? Would we be raising this as an issue?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Au contraire, Johnny.  We're playing that weekend because the RFL insist upon it.  We wanted to play on a Wednesday evening in June (I forget which one).

 

But apparently Rochdale can't play on Wednesdays.

 

Which raises a whole new tranche of questions and "what ifs"...................

 

 

Well yes, rearranged games are supposed to be played within 10 days of the postponment aren't they? No doubt this was all due to Rochdale's completely unco-operative behaviour too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Talking about sheffield's stadium to oldham's stadium the whitebank is just as bad. You may just get a repvire yet. Cold after match showers at oldham.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well yes, rearranged games are supposed to be played within 10 days of the postponement aren't they? No doubt this was all due to Rochdale's completely unco-operative behaviour too.

 

No, Johnny - you're way, way out of date.  That rule disappeared shortly after summer rugby came in.  Clubs quite rightly saw no point in rearranging games for cold, wet Wednesdays in January (I recall one Sheffield-Dewsbury game being played on a Wednesday in January) when there were ample pleasant spring and summer evenings later in the season.  In any case, there was always an over-ride that clubs could use a spare weekend fixture.

 

So what exactly is your point, Johnny ?  You think Rochdale should come on Bank Holiday Monday or it should have been played last February?  You've given both views in successive posts.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Apparently rochdale can't play on Wednesdays. Sheffield can't play night games due to the floodlights at the postage stamp of a ground.

I would love Sheffield to get relegated due to the fact mark Aston is a complete plonk.

Us at Dewsbury have had some runs in with Sheffield eg playing at a college ground once they easily could of switched it to ours, but the clown Aston wanted to be a plonk again.

Our players and coaches refused to go for after match food cause of Aston which caused a big argument between the clubs.

Some bad blood between Dews and sheff all cause of Aston to.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is a really futile thread.

Sheffield were given the 'ok' by the games governing body to play their games at Owlerton. End of story.

We used an ineligible player during a game against them. This player then had a big influence on the result of that game. Sheffield were quite right to complain - as would any other club would have done.

Our own club then responds by somewhat childishly making tepid and seemingly unfounded allegations of wrongdoing against Sheffield - who let's not forget were absolutely right to make their complaint against us.

It's all a bit pathetic on our part quite frankly. A lot of it is, I would assert, borne out of jealousy at the Sheffield clubs ability to sign top quality players and achieve success despite having few of the advantages we have obviously failed to tap into.

Probably best that we forget about the Sheffield club and concentrate on how best to deal with our own, self-inflicted demise.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well guys I hope you do the business apart from Sunday of course. Good luck we need both heavy woollen teams in the championship next year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

load a tosh,if we cant stay up by playing the game 100% then forget all the bullfodder,i think we might just pull it off yet so lets get behind the lads sunday to start off our next   9 points we need,we will need them all so pointless moaning about cougar park pies having no meat in them and were sat on massive timber 8x4s. :download:

  lets stay up with some on the park biff/pride. :bb:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Us at Dewsbury have had some runs in with Sheffield eg playing at a college ground once they easily could of switched it to ours, but the clown Aston wanted to be a plonk again.

Our players and coaches refused to go for after match food cause of Aston which caused a big argument between the clubs.

Some bad blood between Dews and sheff all cause of Aston to.

 

That can't be right.  Surely Dewsbury would know that Dewsbury's ground was the one ground in the country the game couldn't be played on.

 

It was only the season before that we'd been stopped by the RFL from playing a Sheffield v Dewsbury reserve grade game there because the RFL said that it would "distort" the competition (even though both clubs were waaaay down the field at the time).

 

Please check your facts before posting.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is a really futile thread.

Sheffield were given the 'ok' by the games governing body to play their games at Owlerton. End of story.

We used an ineligible player during a game against them. This player then had a big influence on the result of that game. Sheffield were quite right to complain - as would any other club would have done.

Our own club then responds by somewhat childishly making tepid and seemingly unfounded allegations of wrongdoing against Sheffield - who let's not forget were absolutely right to make their complaint against us.

It's all a bit pathetic on our part quite frankly. A lot of it is, I would assert, borne out of jealousy at the Sheffield clubs ability to sign top quality players and achieve success despite having few of the advantages we have obviously failed to tap into.

Probably best that we forget about the Sheffield club and concentrate on how best to deal with our own, self-inflicted demise.

So lets all ignore the ground minimum standards we will just concern ourselves with the mix up of the D/ R regulations. I do not think we tried to gain a unfair advantage. I do think certain clubs get favourable help from the RL. I did not enjoy the expieriance of Owlerton as i have said it is unfit to stage matches. Therefore they are bending the rules by playing there

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So lets all ignore the ground minimum standards we will just concern ourselves with the mix up of the D/ R regulations. I do not think we tried to gain a unfair advantage. I do think certain clubs get favourable help from the RL. I did not enjoy the expieriance of Owlerton as i have said it is unfit to stage matches. Therefore they are bending the rules by playing there

 

The RFL say not.

 

Let's see what they say on Thursday before we start talking about "bending rules".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As the highest club relegated we would replace Sheffield. After all if we do get relegated it was Sheffield who did the wingeing about Fairbanks. I am sure the Sheffield chairman and Aston would like that ( not ).

  I didn't wish to dignify this thread with a response but,as you have continued it,I may as well ask where the information came from which allows you to state that it was Sheffield who did the 'whinging'?

  Did they also 'whinge' about Doncaster,and err in a suggestion about Dewsbury?

  I have read tweets from a newspaper reporter with an interest in a Cumbrian club before the RFL made their announcement about the investigation,and on forums about the Workington fan who pointed out the ruling,and about clubs being reminded by email with regard to the DR regulations.

  It must only be the cost because it seems rare for individuals to make use of the libel laws in this country?

   Perhaps the transparent,accountable,fair and equitable RFL will make public how they came to be made aware of the possible error(s) on Thursday.   

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I didn't wish to dignify this thread with a response but,as you have continued it,I may as well ask where the information came from which allows you to state that it was Sheffield who did the 'whinging'?

Did they also 'whinge' about Doncaster,and err in a suggestion about Dewsbury?

I have read tweets from a newspaper reporter with an interest in a Cumbrian club before the RFL made their announcement about the investigation,and on forums about the Workington fan who pointed out the ruling,and about clubs being reminded by email with regard to the DR regulations.

It must only be the cost because it seems rare for individuals to make use of the libel laws in this country?

Perhaps the transparent,accountable,fair and equitable RFL will make public how they came to be made aware of the possible error(s) on Thursday.

not a chance on grassing on the whistlebower

clowns at the rfl struggle to make decisions in the same week.

this points deduction farse should have been dealt with last week.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

this points deduction farce should have been dealt with last week.

 

Thereby denying Batley the seven days notice required by the by-laws to prepare their case ?

 

I don't think so.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Talking about sheffield's stadium to oldham's stadium the whitebank is just as bad. You may just get a repvire yet. Cold after match showers at oldham.

Hate to disappoint you but only ONE team is coming up and that looks like York,However as a Barrow fan I hope you stay up as it means Whitehaven will be relegated :D  and they wont like that

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.



League Express - Mon 10th April 2017

Rugby League World - April 2017