Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

buford t justice

3 point deduction.

63 posts in this topic

listen its not about you going down or us staying up its about the rules, and you must admit however you look at it Donny have had 2 points taken away from them that were gained in a match where everyone was ok to play.

What an absolute dullard you are.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What an absolute dullard you are.

thanks for the well thought out reasoned response, look at those running your club.At least i knew the rules 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

thanks for the well thought out reasoned response, look at those running your club.At least i knew the rules

The fact that you are an astonishingly boring dullard who has spent every day on this forum over the last few weeks endlessly quoting the rule book has nothing to do with the people who made the error in question. I'm not sure why you chose to link the two? The fact that you've now reappeared to bicker over the severity of the punishment handed down also makes you an absolute pedant - at best.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Both clubs committed the same offence, both clubs got the same punishment quite simple really

.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

think you have been lucky here you lost the 3 points that you got from the game where fairbanks played

Donny have lost the 1 point from the game @ cougars plus another 2 points as well

I struggle to see how the RFL deem this as fair

and yes the outcome of the game does have a bearing on this as the out come of the game effects league position

I wouldn't say Batley are lucky they have lost 3 points and are in danger of relegation If the rules say you loose 3 points for fielding a player that's not allowed that is what they have got like Doncaster nothing to do with if they won the match or not If anything Batley and Donny are unlucky because had it been in S\L they would of probably been deducted the points next year

Hope you can win all your remaining games Batley your a good club with honest RL fans and as a Fev fan love coming up to the mount to play against you

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The fact that you are an astonishingly boring dullard who has spent every day on this forum over the last few weeks endlessly quoting the rule book has nothing to do with the people who made the error in question. I'm not sure why you chose to link the two? The fact that you've now reappeared to bicker over the severity of the punishment handed down also makes you an absolute pedant - at best.

if you read again i am not complaining about the severity or asking for it increased, if you loose 3 then donny should only loose 1 simple really 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

if you read again i am not complaining about the severity or asking for it increased, if you loose 3 then donny should only loose 1 simple really

So if Donny had lost they should of not been punished for breaking the rules

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

if you read again i am not complaining about the severity or asking for it increased, if you loose 3 then donny should only loose 1 simple really

Both clubs committed the same offence so the same punishment should be handed out. As has been done.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So if Donny had lost they should of not been punished for breaking the rules

I think that's what he's saying. Stupidity of the highest order. Anyway, we shouldn't encourage him. It'll only result in more lengthy, boring posts attempting to explain his baffling position.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

it really is simple you are now no worse off then you would have been if you had got beat or the game hadnt been played, in fact with points difference you are still slightly better off than both the above.Where as Donny a worse off despite getting beat .

It should have been all points gained from both Batley and Donny games removed , then punishment decided

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

it really is simple you are now no worse off then you would have been if you had got beat or the game hadnt been played, in fact with points difference you are still slightly better off than both the above.Where as Donny a worse off despite getting beat .

It should have been all points gained from both Batley and Donny games removed , then punishment decided

Here's the email address you need to contact if you feel the need to complain; ralphtherimmer@rfl.co.uk

No-one here cares what you think.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

it really is simple you are now no worse off then you would have been if you had got beat or the game hadnt been played, in fact with points difference you are still slightly better off than both the above.Where as Donny a worse off despite getting beat .

It should have been all points gained from both Batley and Donny games removed , then punishment decided

So you think Batley should have six point reduction . and Doncaster four ?  Three for wrongdoing and match points gained in respective games ?

 

The law they broke was  playing an 'illegal' D/R player  .  the match result was nothing to do with this action as both players had played for clubs before just not played 

the minimum games  RL rules say they needed to  ...

IMHO

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

listen its not about you going down or us staying up its about the rules, and you must admit  however you look at it Donny have had 2 points taken away from them that were gained in a match where everyone was ok to play.

 

So, a few years ago when Wigan breached the salary cap rules, were they deducted the whole season's points because of the advantage they gained in all games?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It really is a shame this has happened to you, massively unfair on the fans and team that an admin error has screwed you over. But at the same time I feel relief because it makes it more probable my team will stay up, and I'm afraid this season that's all that matters. Should the worst happen and you do get relegated then hopefully for your case its not too destructive and it can be used as a rebuilding season. Good luck for the future.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's not over yet,let's not admit defeat,got 3 games to go let's get behind the lads for one last push,there are some clowns in here haven4ever you know nothing about how the rfl works and we should have been punished more severely due to winning and donny losing,but donny gain more still in 4th place which will be worth more money when season finishes if stay there if we stay up and finish 9th we would get less money and no play offs

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

if you had not replaced the majority of your GF team with mediocre replacements and gambled on the DR lottery your club would not be in the predicament they are right now. I sincerely hope that you can get out of this huge hole you are in because we love the away day at Batley, but it is going to be very very difficult.

You took exactly the same route as Hunslet and York did last season even after seeing what happened to them. 

At least you have 3 games to get yourselves out of this mess which is not impossible as both dews bury and doncaster appear to have injury crisis's as well and I would fancy you at home to swinton. Get behind your team this week !!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's not over yet,let's not admit defeat,got 3 games to go let's get behind the lads for one last push,there are some clowns in here haven4ever you know nothing about how the rfl works and we should have been punished more severely due to winning and donny losing,but donny gain more still in 4th place which will be worth more money when season finishes if stay there if we stay up and finish 9th we would get less money and no play offs

No, points from both games removed result from the offending team are invalid

then punish both sides the same

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

if you read again i am not complaining about the severity or asking for it increased, if you loose 3 then donny should only loose 1 simple really 

Can i bum you!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No, points from both games removed result from the offending team is valid

then both puished the same

zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz now bore off and concentrate on your own teams last 3 games

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Fat lady is not singing yet.

 

I remember when Cougars lost points and it was not the fans fault many from Batley were sympathetic and I now feel your pain for the Clubs oversight.

 

In reality, the Batley of recent years would not have been in the bottom of the table. I think your season has got you in this pickle. 

 

In any case, if the worst comes to the worst, I am dam sure you will bounce back fast. 

 

Where is the Internet Troll they call Piggy's mate who insults and gloats over everybody's bad luck. Bet he is quiet today. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Fat lady is not singing yet.

I remember when Cougars lost points and it was not the fans fault many from Batley were sympathetic and I now feel your pain for the Clubs oversight.

In reality, the Batley of recent years would not have been in the bottom of the table. I think your season has got you in this pickle.

In any case, if the worst comes to the worst, I am dam sure you will bounce back fast.

Where is the Internet Troll they call Piggy's mate who insults and gloats over everybody's bad luck. Bet he is quiet today.

Shes already got the microphone in her hand.

If we had another half back id have more optimism, but we dont and with no Paterson will have Faal or Martin back at centre, both of whom arent even national conference standard.

Game over for us.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Course you will kev whilst giving us more hope that just dwindles away.

I used to swear by your robust and sensible approach to keeping my club in order

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What an absolute dullard you are.

most fans say things like that to haven4ever on all the forums he goes on.atleast he is consistent lol.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

most fans say things like that to haven4ever on all the forums he goes on.atleast he is consistent lol.

wondered when you would show up, still waiting for my regular sunday night PM from last week,,,,sorry thats right you got beat.

look i will explain this in terms even you understand

all batley have lost is the 3 points they obtained illegally by playing some one who was not allowed to play,no other punishment

Donny have lost the 1 point they obtained illegally plus another 2 on top of that.

however you try to dress that up it is wrong

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.



Rugby League World - April 2017

League Express - Mon 10th April 2017