Dunbar

Not at all, just that I am in my 5th decade of watching Rugby League and I didn't know that a knee being in an unacceptable position was a foul.

Come on, not once in a generation... that's only 20 or 30 years... once in a lifetime!

Will we see other players penalised and banned for their knee's being in an unacceptable position I wonder.

It's the rules of the Internet. It's not your opinion if you give your opinion and then state it is an 'absolute fact' afterwards. Your opinions magically turn into facts.

I'm not sure he would get a run in the centre or wing unless the Knights had a pretty deep injury crisis. If Ponga has a spell on the sidelines, you would expect Pryce to be in the mix for back up #1 but I think his chance will come when (if!) Adam O'Brien finally recognises that Cogger and Hastings are too similar and Gamble is bobbins and he finally puts Pryce at 6 next to either Cogger or Hastings as a game management 7.

Manu is one of many good players in the NRL but not even close to a once in a lifetime player. In fact, I am watching the Roosters Storm game now (or working, depending on who is asking) and Manu is just one of many good players in this game.

Pryce has been named in the Knights NSW Cup side again this week so he looks OK.

If talents like Jonathan Davies , Ellery Hanley, Darren Lockyer and Joey Manu only come around once in a lifetime and I have seen them all play. I have to ask, and be honest, am I immortal... am I Highlander?

It may just be me, but I don't think Manu is anywhere close to the three you mention in this post.

I think the first of those variables is relatively easy. Most employees would change jobs for a considerable pay rise - if there is no other financial incentive involved. But the chance to live in Japan? I want to visit Japan, it is on my bucket list, but I wouldn't want to spend 2 or 3 years away from home, living and working in a foreign country can be very isolating, even if you have your close family with you. If my business wanted me to move to our Japanese office and offered me more money to do it, I would say no. All these matters are personal of course.

Winners: Storm, Warriors, Eels, Panthers, Sea Eagles, Broncos, Bulldogs, Cowboys Points: 334 Home wins: 5 Poll: Sharks vs. Cowboys

There is a lot of chat in the Aussie sports media at the moment about whether the Roosters encourage their players to leave the code rather than move to another NRL side should they want to move on or can't offer them what they want in the cap. I hope that's not true - not least because Trent Robinson has been such a wonderful ambassador for our code.

Guess you got me. I'm a big racist.

There really are far too many variables here for us to make determinations from the outside about Manu's motives. We don't, for example, know his thoughts on sushi, karaoke or indeed how bullety he likes his trains to be.

There have been some harsh things said on this site but this one takes the biscuit!