LeeF

I agree that accidents can and do happen and that you can’t legislate to eliminate accidents but in this case the duty of care is key because of how the Cas player attempts to execute the tackle. As I posted earlier hopefully the full disciplinary minutes will clarify. They are usually quite decent odd typo aside

Have you actually read what I posted? Clearly not, so best leave you to it as that discussion ain’t going anywhere either

The MRP would have probably reviewed the incident as it looks wrong as @Dave T says. Any ban can be lengthened due to injuries received. The initial grading is determined by the actual incident - didn’t Cas get it downgraded from F to E - not the outcome. As posted fairly regularly on this forum the defender has a duty of care towards the ball carrier and accident or not this incident seems to show that this was lacking in this instance so a charge and ban etc are fully justified. For hearings that go to a full Disciplinary hearing the minutes are usually published either the day after or once the club/ player have confirmed that there will be no appeal so hopefully these will published either today or later this week.

Why couldn’t it happen? Anything is possible. Someone else has done the maths. BTW have you anything to say on my response to your video of Degsy?

Not hang out to dry but a scapegoat if it goes wrong

What Myler coming out of retirement for the last game of the season for Hull to maintain their Grade A status?

If that decided the 12th/ 13th place then it would create the mother of all meltdowns and accusations of corruption ever seen on this forum with the Moderators issuing more bans than the MRP do on week 1 of a new season

Pearson has played a blinder here. Everything is now down to Myler - coach appointment; player recruitment; player development etc

So is Wellens under pressure?

And isn’t Makinson leaving at the end of this season?

No. With apologies

Wigan & Leeds would have been referenced but I’m still not taking anything away from how good a player he was.

Who are Myler’s best mates? Those will be the coach and then the first player signings

A surprise result which nobody, except one Giants fan, expected

He was used as the example of being offside at the PTB when I took my local refereeing course (not the RFL one)