Is it time to get rid of video referees in Rugby League?

Martyn Sadler
By Martyn Sadler March 10, 2014 12:00

Is it time to get rid of video referees in Rugby League?

Is it just me, or is anyone else getting mightily sick of the amount of time we are devoting to video referee decisions in Super League?

Jamie Peacock is stopped in his tracks playing for Leeds against Huddersfield on Friday night.

Jamie Peacock is stopped in his tracks playing for Leeds against Huddersfield on Friday night.

Whether you’re watching the game live at the stadium or on TV, the video referee has become an incredible drag on the game. I was a great advocate of it when it was first introduced, but when virtually every decision goes to the video referee, as it seemed to do on Friday night when I watched Huddersfield take on Leeds, it tests the patience of everyone.

I realised just how much it irks me when I watched the NRL’s Auckland Nines tournament three weeks ago. At that tournament there was no video referee, and it was a liberating experience not to have one.
The whole event was improved by the video referee’s absence, and the games flowed much more naturally.

I’m not saying that the video referee doesn’t get most of its decisions correct. It’s just that I no longer think it’s worth it, and the occasional error from a referee in awarding a try would be a small price to pay for getting rid of it.

Is it time to get rid of video referees?

Is it time to get rid of video referees?

The new strategy of the video referee announcing the decision to the crowd didn’t necessarily work too well on Friday either. Most of the decisions involved disallowing Huddersfield tries, and it was hard to hear the explanations over the chorus of booing that came from the Giants’ fans.

And on the same theme, on Sunday morning I watched Sam Tomkins’ debut in the NRL, for the New Zealand Warriors at Parramatta, and in that game the video referee was called into action nine times. That is way too much and something needs to be done about it.

Want more Rugby League news and features? Subscribe to the online version of League Express newspaper and Rugby League World magazine. You can also connect with Total Rugby League on the social media platform of your choice.


Join the lively Rugby League debates on our Fans Forum


Rugby League Yearbook 2014/15League ExpressSuper League's Top 50Rugby League World
Print / KindlePrint / DigitalDigital ExclusivePrint / Digital

Martyn Sadler
By Martyn Sadler March 10, 2014 12:00

Great Rugby League Reads!

rlle_230315_125rlw_apr15_125
device-icons-all

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter

Which team do you support?

Vote in our poll

After Widnes coach Denis Betts said he would like to do away with Sunday Super League games, what day would you stop playing games on?