Jump to content

Tonka

Coach
  • Posts

    1,596
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Tonka

  1. 1 hour ago, phiggins said:

    For some reason, this reminded me of a try Hull scored against Leigh last season, that was so unnecessary and cumbersome that it was almost spectacular in it's own way. About 1:10 on here: 

     

     

    Ha - yeah exactly.  My other bug bear is tries from kicks which really amount to wanging it up in the air or along the floor, the defence fumbling it (as well they might with three 17 stone giants bearing down on them) and it ending up in the attack's hands somehow.  Perfectly legitimate but never my favourite kind of try.  Especially when it bounces around off people's heads/hands/knees/the floor and all that, and you can't even tell if they've scored til you watch the replay.

    • Like 2
  2. I’m gonna sound like a right misery guts here 🤣 but I don’t really get excited by the corner flag leaps.  They’re highly athletic and sometimes necessary to score (although often a bit unnecessary I think).  I get more excited by skilled passages of play: offloads, passes, steps, chips over, individual efforts, lines of running, tackle busts etc, than I do a leap.  Just my view, and I’m not knocking that it was a great finish.

    • Like 4
  3. I’d love to see heartland clubs in a stronger state.  But I don’t think it necessarily creates a base for expansion because 

    - from outside the M62 corridor not many will care

    - even with the “giants” awoken it’s still a small game 

    - there is massive competition from football and union and we get further and further behind

    - there’s a very limited international game 

     

    But expansion and development of existing clubs aren’t diametrically opposed, soooo.

    My own view is that the national team is the number one priority if we want positive headlines.

  4. 5 hours ago, M j M said:

    That time Huddersfield let 54 points in at Headingley vs Leeds was amongst the worst performances i've ever seen in Super League. 

    Possibly a different game to the one Schoey is talking about here though.

    Screenshot-20230628-130412-2.png

    I mean you might argue they played even worse in this one…

    1998 JJB SUPER LEAGUE - ROUND 21

    GIANTS
    16 72 Leeds
    RHINOS
  5. 13 minutes ago, Tommygilf said:

    Yeah we got away with reducing our minimum wage to £12.5k for full time professional rugby league players and have only had 1 top flight club have to resort to council loans because nobody else will give them credit yay!

    Union is a warning I agree. However the line between being financially prudent and extreme cheapskates is very thin in RL, let us not allow that to Rose Tint our spectacles.

    I don’t disagree with that sentiment, and Im definitely not a rose tinted kinda guy 

  6. 7 minutes ago, Hull Kingston Bronco said:

    That's not our success. It shows us that Rugby Union was a more attractive prospect to investors who had more money to risk, albeit it then blew up in their faces. Rugby League just operates at a lower level of financial risk and reward is all. 

    Yeah but if the upshot is that the clubs don’t go bust then that sounds like a good decision 

    • Like 1
  7. You can’t have this in the game because taken to its logical conclusion that means the referee assessing every point of contact and determining whether precisely the right amount of force as was necessary to tackle the player (or less, but not more) was used by the tacklers in aggregate, rather like self-defence laws in real life.

    Which is (1) completely against the physical nature of the sport and (2) impossible to police.

    Its just a bad decision, I’d be more curious to know whether the referee thinks he still made the right call and the referees’ body agrees (and why).

  8. For my twopence worth he seems like the kinda guy who likes to run in a straight line, so he’ll probably be amazing for the next 3 years, decent for another 3, then get slower and slower til he gets signed by Leigh aged 34.  Unless his game develops a bit.

  9. 57 minutes ago, Dave T said:

    absolutely, i get your explanation, it's not that that confuses me.

    I'm just not sure clubs posting press releases that make them look a bit dim are good jokes. Like I say, I assumed I was missing something. I wasn't sure if it was something to do with Fev and their World Record attempt. 😆

    Fair enough 

    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.