Thurs 1st Oct SL : Castleford Tigers v Hull FC KO 19:45 SKY

[LeeF]

1 minute ago, Rupert Prince said:

Read what i said, I pointed out he was pointing to the wrong target. 

He hasn’t got a target or at least one that any reasonable person would consider legitimate. His actions are indefensible

[Padge]

1 minute ago, Dunedan said:

So if you get a penalty, it's open season?

Its called playing the advantage, a long held law of the game. If Hull hadn't scored the ref would have gone back to the incident given Hull a penalty and probably have sat a Cas player down.

[LeeF]

3 minutes ago, Agbrigg said:

Powell should retire if he cant accept refs. I think this ref tonight looks highly competent

Despite how Cas are playing

[Dunedan]

1 minute ago, LeeF said:

Advantage being played for the first offence

The second offence was foul play, so play should've been stopped. You can't just grab someone and throw him around just because you have penalty advantage.

[LeeF]

Just now, Dunedan said:

The second offence was foul play, so play should've been stopped. You can't just grab someone and throw him around just because you have penalty advantage.

Give up

[Just Browny]

Darryl certainly looks like he is ready to talk at the end of this.

[Dunedan]

Just now, Padge said:

Its called playing the advantage, a long held law of the game. If Hull hadn't scored the ref would have gone back to the incident given Hull a penalty and probably have sat a Cas player down.

Like I've just said, youcan't go after someone just because you have penalty advantage.

Take it the extreme - Team A get penalty advantage in the same situation. The injured player gets up and punches the offender. Does Team A still get the play on advantage? Of course not. The foul play thenother would should've stopped play. Hull would still have the penalty, but not play on.

[Rupert Prince]

2 minutes ago, LeeF said:

He hasn’t got a target or at least one that any reasonable person would consider legitimate. His actions are indefensible

I don't think refs are consistant and the various rule changes are not helping refs.

[Padge]

Just now, Just Browny said:

Darryl certainly looks like he is ready to talk at * the end of this.

* Missing word "She-Height"

[MZH]

Just now, Padge said:

* Missing word "She-Height"

He is embarrassing himself lately.

[spanishknight]

If Cas played rugby they will win,  giving too many pens away.

[Padge]

1 minute ago, Dunedan said:

Like I've just said, youcan't go after someone just because you have penalty advantage.

Take it the extreme - Team A get penalty advantage in the same situation. The injured player gets up and punches the offender. Does Team A still get the play on advantage? Of course not. The foul play thenother would should've stopped play. Hull would still have the penalty, but not play on.

That isn't how it works.

[Man of Kent]

I’m hoping Daryl Powell’s post-match will be along the lines of ‘We’ve got an ageing pack with some Championship quality backs. Also, Paul McShane is overrated’, but he’s already got an excuse if Cas lose.

[jacksy]

I like Powell but this is a bit embarrassing.

[Barry Badrinath]

It seems that Darryl's lack of respect and frustration with the refs is being  passed onto the players, in their lack of discipline 

[LeeF]

1 minute ago, jacksy said:

I like Powell but this is a bit embarrassing.

Very not a bit

[Just Browny]

As well as Powell's reddening cheeks, the fayre on the pitch has been decent too. Cas games tend to swing back and forth and this one has too - couldn't pick a winner at this point.

[LeeF]

3 minutes ago, MZH said:

He is embarrassing himself lately.

It’s been ongoing for a while 

[Dunedan]

1 minute ago, Padge said:

That isn't how it works.

Except it is. That's why they were looking for foul play on the VR. Refs either didn't see Cator grab O'Neill and throw him down, or decided it didn't constitute foul play. Personally, I disagree

[LeeF]

5 minutes ago, Rupert Prince said:

I don't think refs are consistant and the various rule changes are not helping refs.

I think that refs are consistent. Not as consistent as Cas who keep making basic errors or Powell who keeps whinging about being picked on

[Barry Badrinath]

I missed the powell discussion at the start, ive just rewound to listen to wells comments, wtf is clarke wearing,  if he didn't have the 'to the manor born' waist coat on, he'd only look slightly daft.

[Barry Badrinath]

Was wells doorstepped for this pre match chat? Did they not warn him they were planning to discuss this.

[Rupert Prince]

Is it now a yellow card to put a fat belly in someones backside.?

[Padge]

4 minutes ago, Dunedan said:

Except it is. That's why they were looking for foul play on the VR. Refs either didn't see Cator grab O'Neill and throw him down, or decided it didn't constitute foul play. Personally, I disagree

I suggest you do a refs course or at least study the laws of the game.

[Dunedan]

1 minute ago, Padge said:

I suggest you do a refs course or at least study the laws of the game.

Are you telling me, with a straight face, that had Cator punched O'Neill, that try would've stood?

If that was the case, what was the ref looking for when he said the the VR "Check for any foul play that means I can't award it"?

Edited October 1, 2020 by Dunedan