Gooleboy Posted September 11 Posted September 11 Josh must be worth another year the way he has been playing recently. 6
Fevrover Posted September 11 Posted September 11 2 hours ago, marklaspalmas said: We currently have a 23 man squad. Signed for 2025: Brad Day Jimmy Beckett Connor Jones Gadwin Springer Thomas Lacans Danny Addy Greg Minikin Maddox Jeffery Gareth Gale Pending: Caleb Aekins Harry Bowes Greg Eden Jack Bussey Josh Hardcastle Ben Reynolds Wellington Albert Jack Arnold Connor Wynne Charlie Harris James Lockwood Loan to end of 2024: Ben Nakubuwai Samy Kibula Dec Patton Hopefully Reynolds, Bussey ,Wynne and Josh stay,Patton off to Widnes.
Squidward Posted September 11 Posted September 11 They would be the 4 I would be most keen to try to keep. Nakubuwai is another who's deserved a deal but whether finances will allow I'm not sure. 1
RobLambert Posted September 11 Posted September 11 1 hour ago, Squidward said: They would be the 4 I would be most keen to try to keep. Nakubuwai is another who's deserved a deal but whether finances will allow I'm not sure. There's a big name on the pending list that nobody has mentioned. I wouldn't be too upset if he leaves given that he's probably one of our biggest earners.
The Phantom Horseman Posted September 12 Posted September 12 11 hours ago, RobLambert said: There's a big name on the pending list that nobody has mentioned. I wouldn't be too upset if he leaves given that he's probably one of our biggest earners. I think that's a good way of putting it. We're always a little in the dark in that we only have half the information that's pertinent to retention decisions - ie we have all seen the players play but we are only guessing at their salaries (we also aren't privy to behind-the-scenes stuff such as are they a good team influence or disruptive etc). If we're talking about the same player, I think he's performed ok in recent weeks after a shakey start and has done a job for us, but I too would imagine he'd be on a fair salary and you'd think we could get equivalent or better production cheaper. On the other end of the scale (and again this is guesswork) but you'd think Jack Arnold wouldn't be one of our bigger earners and if so I reckon he's provided enough value in recent weeks to earn a second year with us. 1 "I won’t engage in a debate because the above is correct and if anything else is stated to the contrary it’s incorrect."
sentoffagain2 Posted September 12 Posted September 12 I was impressed with England in the first few games but his form tapered off.Arnold for me has been a very solid hard worker and i would love to see him get a 2 year contract. 2
The Phantom Horseman Posted September 12 Posted September 12 13 hours ago, Squidward said: They would be the 4 I would be most keen to try to keep. Nakubuwai is another who's deserved a deal but whether finances will allow I'm not sure. I agree that Nakubuwai has done pretty well bar a couple of quiet games, I think this is his level not SL. I wouldn't get in a mad bidding war for him but he's been solid in attack and defence in my view. 1 "I won’t engage in a debate because the above is correct and if anything else is stated to the contrary it’s incorrect."
Featherstonerovers2000 Posted September 12 Posted September 12 I’d like us to resign Aekins been very good for us last few years
sentoffagain2 Posted September 12 Posted September 12 12 minutes ago, The Phantom Horseman said: I agree that Nakubuwai has done pretty well bar a couple of quiet games, I think this is his level not SL. I wouldn't get in a mad bidding war for him but he's been solid in attack and defence in my view. Slow start and i gave him a bit of stick.But he has improved enough to be a regular starter.For the Championship he is a decent player.
RobLambert Posted September 12 Posted September 12 3 hours ago, The Phantom Horseman said: I think that's a good way of putting it. We're always a little in the dark in that we only have half the information that's pertinent to retention decisions - ie we have all seen the players play but we are only guessing at their salaries (we also aren't privy to behind-the-scenes stuff such as are they a good team influence or disruptive etc). If we're talking about the same player, I think he's performed ok in recent weeks after a shakey start and has done a job for us, but I too would imagine he'd be on a fair salary and you'd think we could get equivalent or better production cheaper. On the other end of the scale (and again this is guesswork) but you'd think Jack Arnold wouldn't be one of our bigger earners and if so I reckon he's provided enough value in recent weeks to earn a second year with us. Ah no I don't think we are talking about the same player. I don't usually like to name individuals but to avoid confusion I meant Aekins. A bit controversial maybe but, even allowing for his absences this year and that he's often being asked to play out of position, I just don't recall the last time he had a great game. Won us the opening game at Batley. Can't recall much else. He seems to be going through the motions most of the time. Recently I was just looking at highlights from our games against Leigh in the 2022 season and he looked a different player. I'm sure he was smiling more as well but I might be making that up ! Like I said though, assuming that he's one of the high earners is probably affecting my opinion. i.e its all relative - he's still a decent player - but is he worth it ? I agree about Arnold though........
The Phantom Horseman Posted September 12 Posted September 12 Just now, RobLambert said: Ah no I don't think we are talking about the same player. I don't usually like to name individuals but to avoid confusion I meant Aekins. A bit controversial maybe but, even allowing for his absences this year and that he's often being asked to play out of position, I just don't recall the last time he had a great game. Won us the opening game at Batley. Can't recall much else. He seems to be going through the motions most of the time. Recently I was just looking at highlights from our games against Leigh in the 2022 season and he looked a different player. I'm sure he was smiling more as well but I might be making that up ! Like I said though, assuming that he's one of the high earners is probably affecting my opinion. i.e its all relative - he's still a decent player - but is he worth it ? I agree about Arnold though........ It didn't occur to me you were talking about Aekins! For me he's still a really good player but he's been massively impacted over the last couple of seasons by being regularly asked to play half back, which he's done to the best of his ability but we all know it's not his natural position. He's still in the top 3 in the MOTM table on this forum despite missing quite a lot of games, but I'd say he probably needs to be playing full back behind a couple of proper half backs over a decent period (for timing/linking up purposes) to be seen at his best. I don't agree with the comment about seeming to be going through the motions. As for 2022, I think I would have looked good playing full back in that Leigh team (well, maybe not...) As you say though, he's probably one of our higher earners. Just down to whether he's judged to provide value for money at his cost (assuming he & his family want to stay in the UK). 1 "I won’t engage in a debate because the above is correct and if anything else is stated to the contrary it’s incorrect."
marklaspalmas Posted September 12 Posted September 12 31 minutes ago, RobLambert said: Ah no I don't think we are talking about the same player. I don't usually like to name individuals but to avoid confusion I meant Aekins. A bit controversial maybe but, even allowing for his absences this year and that he's often being asked to play out of position, I just don't recall the last time he had a great game. Won us the opening game at Batley. Can't recall much else. He seems to be going through the motions most of the time. Recently I was just looking at highlights from our games against Leigh in the 2022 season and he looked a different player. I'm sure he was smiling more as well but I might be making that up ! Like I said though, assuming that he's one of the high earners is probably affecting my opinion. i.e its all relative - he's still a decent player - but is he worth it ? I agree about Arnold though........ I see where your coming from but that's a harsh-ish judgement. He's not a halfback for mine. We need him at fullback, his best position. One of his family died in Australia mid season and he had to go home. That must have affected him. 2 https://www.fevarchive.co.uk/
The Phantom Horseman Posted September 12 Posted September 12 Matt Shaw is linking us with Robson Stevens, a 22yo prop who has played for Mackay Cutters in tier 2 in Australia over the last 2 years. Before that he came through the Huddersfield academy, played twice in SL for them, and also had quite a few appearances for Dewsbury. "I won’t engage in a debate because the above is correct and if anything else is stated to the contrary it’s incorrect."
Rovers fev Posted September 12 Author Posted September 12 I know the money aekins is on and if I’m honest I don’t think he’s worth it, if he’d take a 20k pay cut I’d be willing to keep him but for his wage this year we could get 2-3 decent champ players in 1
SUPERSTUD Posted September 12 Posted September 12 4 hours ago, The Phantom Horseman said: Matt Shaw is linking us with Robson Stevens, a 22yo prop who has played for Mackay Cutters in tier 2 in Australia over the last 2 years. Before that he came through the Huddersfield academy, played twice in SL for them, and also had quite a few appearances for Dewsbury. He must have come on leaps and bounds during the two year period. It’s possible and I genuinely mean that. Ex Birstall Victoria junior player. Nice lad.
RobLambert Posted September 12 Posted September 12 2 hours ago, Rovers fev said: I know the money aekins is on and if I’m honest I don’t think he’s worth it, if he’d take a 20k pay cut I’d be willing to keep him but for his wage this year we could get 2-3 decent champ players in Thats my thinking. Just on the above comments I may have been a bit harsh regarding his contribution over the last year or so. Its a shame he's had to play so much at half back so we've not seen the best of him. But I cant see an end to the cycle of us having just 2 decent halves on the books - one of which seems to be constantly injured - leaving Aekins (arguably) as our No.1 replacement. I'd rather see the likes of Addy, Eden, Bowes, Bussey etc to step in. Its like signing Messi and putting him in goal.
Featherstonerovers2000 Posted September 14 Posted September 14 By sounds both Aekins and springer signed 2 year deals
Wakefield Ram Posted September 15 Posted September 15 On 11/09/2024 at 16:51, Fevrover said: Hopefully Reynolds, Bussey ,Wynne and Josh stay,Patton off to Widnes. You've got Calum Turner and Bailey O'Connor from Dewsbury by all accounts. Turner isn't a Championship standard half back, lacks the necessary pace but O'Connor is a real talent. 1
elppaxr2i Posted September 16 Posted September 16 Pretty sure Reynolds signed an 18 month deal when he re-signed so he would be in for 2025?
POR Posted September 16 Posted September 16 It's interesting to hear peoples thoughts on players for 2025 but the biggest monkey in the room is coach for 2025 1
Michael Bates Posted September 16 Posted September 16 1 hour ago, elppaxr2i said: Pretty sure Reynolds signed an 18 month deal when he re-signed so he would be in for 2025? The news article on our website says until the end of the 2024 season.
Monkeymagic22 Posted September 16 Posted September 16 55 minutes ago, POR said: It's interesting to hear peoples thoughts on players for 2025 but the biggest monkey in the room is coach for 2025 I agree, struggling to see how there will be improvement under the current coaching staff. Alas, it seems like Ford is here to stay.
POR Posted September 16 Posted September 16 (edited) 57 minutes ago, Michael Bates said: The news article on our website says until the end of the 2024 season. I saw that when he came back from the Robins with Reynolds returns to the Rovers dated 06/07/24 Featherstone Rovers are delighted to announce the signing of Ben Reynolds until the end of the 2024 season. but it was announced on website dated 19/10/23 Local lad Ben Reynolds has joined Featherstone Rovers from Leigh Leopards on a two year deal. The talismanic halfback becomes the first new signing for 2024 so what's happening is anyone's guess Edited September 16 by POR
J Phil Loxton Posted September 16 Posted September 16 28 minutes ago, Monkeymagic22 said: I agree, struggling to see how there will be improvement under the current coaching staff. Alas, it seems like Ford is here to stay. I would think and sincerely hope that Paddy Handley who sounds to be the ultimate professional in the ideas that he has,would put the club before a best friend. With the ideas that he has put in place regarding the ground etc he wouldn't want the dark days of the old division 2 returning when I stood with 700+ fans at Post Office Road. I can't believe a coach would be given the boot with two matches left. If anything it's next season now that is important from a coaching aspect. Looking on the positive side it is now up to the players and coaching staff to decide if they are up for the almighty challenge of achieving the slight chance of us making the six. If we don't then the coach should be answerable to this failure. We have been beaten now on numerous occasions at home by teams that rarely take two points from Post Office Road and while no team has got the right to beat everyone it seems that alarm bells have been ringing for a while only to be glossed over by beating top four teams.
Michael Bates Posted September 16 Posted September 16 16 minutes ago, POR said: I saw that when he came back from the Robins with Reynolds returns to the Rovers dated 06/07/24 Featherstone Rovers are delighted to announce the signing of Ben Reynolds until the end of the 2024 season. but it was announced on website dated 19/10/23 Local lad Ben Reynolds has joined Featherstone Rovers from Leigh Leopards on a two year deal. The talismanic halfback becomes the first new signing for 2024 so what's happening is anyone's guess Sounds about right for this club...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now