Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

The current Man City situation raises the question as to how compliant clubs in rugby league are with our salary cap rules. With dispensations for guarantors, marquee signings etc how effective is the compliance monitoring and what sanctions are in place to deal with offenders.


Posted

The SL cap is pretty watertight as far as these things go. There definitely won't be a Melbourne style situation over here.

Posted

We would be naïve to think that some clubs are not schooling the system. We only have to look how he IMG criteria was worked over and that was just what we saw in the public domain.

  • Thanks 1
Posted (edited)

City's cheating is on a different scale, the sums of money they 'invented' would fund the whole of Super League for 40 years. It wasn't marginal and open to interpretation as possibly some cap issues might be. SL is too small a village for things to stay secret in relation to players pay and possible perks.

What it does do though, is ruin people's confidence in football (mine was ruined well before this exposure) and provides an opportunity for other sports to gain some traction, especially when you add on all the on-field cheating and feigning involved in soccer. RL just managed to avoid placing the WC in the spotlight at just the right time, well done there (albeit we might get some Scottish football fans through Premier)

Edited by Tom F
Posted
1 hour ago, The Blues Ox said:

We would be naïve to think that some clubs are not schooling the system. We only have to look how he IMG criteria was worked over and that was just what we saw in the public domain.

Indeed. 

Would not be shocked to see some players wives etc employed at the other companies of owners for example.

  • Thanks 1
Posted (edited)
4 minutes ago, Tommygilf said:

Indeed. 

Would not be shocked to see some players wives etc employed at the other companies of owners for example.

Imagine the scandal when Mrs Ipape is spotted touting decking around Leigh Market, would put Etihad's billions in the shade.

🙂

Edited by Tom F
  • Like 1
  • Haha 5
Posted

Spouse employment arrangements are one of the first things that gets looked at.

If clubs are rorting the cap they are doing stuff much more complex than that.

  • Like 2
Posted
42 minutes ago, Tom F said:

Imagine the scandal when Mrs Ipape is spotted touting decking around Leigh Market, would put Etihad's billions in the shade.

🙂

Indeed. It would be more sophisticated than that of course, and I have little confidence in the RFL compliance department if it exists!

  • Thanks 1
Posted (edited)

We've had a salary cap long enough for a lot of the ruses that people think are going on to be ironed out. Certainly the days of Mrs Renouf allegedly being the best paid shop worker in the North West, or a player being "employed" by a club sponsor or a company that a player has a financial interest in happening to win a suspiciously lucrative contract from a club are gone as loopholes and that sort of thing is well covered in the SC guidelines. 

If you're so interested, what is and isn't included is covered from page 281 in this 112194 Tab Indicator Pages.indd

Edited by whatmichaelsays
  • Like 2
Posted
On 07/10/2026 at 12:50, The 4 of Us said:

Different all together. Premier league is to protect solvency and isn’t a salary cap. Superleague’s is to ensure solvency but also to spread the talent so that one team doesn’t just buy a team. 
 

Exactly. The Premier League rules are to prevent insolvency and by design help the bigger teams not to have to deal with big investors basically long term working on scaling up a club…. We, in rugby league don’t have any interest on preventing something like that (yes the insolvency, but that’s about it). 
Annoyingly for all the cheating of Man City it is purely about the Premier League rules nothing about money laundering that they or any other rich owners are doing 

Posted
5 hours ago, Tommygilf said:

Oldham alleging that some clubs are making figures up for the grading scores.

Bingo . And here is the point, as money (hopefully) comes into the game monitoring has to become paramount to ensure integrity and stave off legal wrangling. This is not just about stating what is wanted but more about how we ensure it happens.  Simple performance on the pitch negates the need for this but having decided to take a different route let’s at least have processes in place to ensure we can demonstrate fair play.

Posted
15 hours ago, Tommygilf said:

Oldham alleging that some clubs are making figures up for the grading scores.

But we already knew this. It didnt take a rocket scientist to see that some clubs were manipulating attendance figures and social media figures. Although it seemed obvious we had to trust that the RFL had measures in place to clamp down on this, it now turns out that they don't which to be honest is no big surprise.

Posted
23 minutes ago, The Blues Ox said:

But we already knew this. It didnt take a rocket scientist to see that some clubs were manipulating attendance figures and social media figures. Although it seemed obvious we had to trust that the RFL had measures in place to clamp down on this, it now turns out that they don't which to be honest is no big surprise.

Is it legal to provide fake attendance numbers to the local council?

Posted
41 minutes ago, Click said:

Is it legal to provide fake attendance numbers to the local council?

If I was going to prosecute this then 

false representation.

Section 2 2006 Fraud act...

 

Do well to get out of that.

Posted
2 hours ago, Click said:

Is it legal to provide fake attendance numbers to the local council?

That is the big question and it's very likely that the attendance figure that is reported for RFL purposes will differ to what the actual numbers given to the council or the figures given to HMRC are.

Posted
1 minute ago, The Blues Ox said:

That is the big question and it's very likely that the attendance figure that is reported for RFL purposes will differ to what the actual numbers given to the council or the figures given to HMRC are.

I thought the clubs had to declare the same attendance to the RFL & the council? 

What they put out in a press release on social media could be different though. 

Why would clubs lie about attendances to the RFL but tell the truth to the council? That is something the RFL could discover as a lie very easily.

Posted
5 minutes ago, The Blues Ox said:

I think you give them too much credit.

They don't even need to do it themselves, journalists could make FOI requests to councils and the RFL get the data from those releases. 

Posted
On 07/10/2026 at 12:50, The 4 of Us said:

Different all together. Premier league is to protect solvency and isn’t a salary cap. Superleague’s is to ensure solvency but also to spread the talent so that one team doesn’t just buy a team. 
 

PL rules protect solvency as a by-product of maintaining the status quo of the Champions League teams & preventing other teams with wealthy bankers (Newcastle the richest by far) investing to join that club.  Mystery why Premier League clubs voted for it but probably a gun to the head works wonders.

In RL, IMG scores have pretty much the same effect in making it difficult for Championship teams to gatecrash the party. But you can see why SL teams would be happy with the range of metrics used.

The real lesson to be learned from the Man City situation is never allow ownership of a club by individual(s) with provable links to State owned bodies.

Posted
5 hours ago, Deadcowboys1 said:

PL rules protect solvency as a by-product of maintaining the status quo of the Champions League teams & preventing other teams with wealthy bankers (Newcastle the richest by far) investing to join that club.  Mystery why Premier League clubs voted for it but probably a gun to the head works wonders.

In RL, IMG scores have pretty much the same effect in making it difficult for Championship teams to gatecrash the party. But you can see why SL teams would be happy with the range of metrics used.

The real lesson to be learned from the Man City situation is never allow ownership of a club by individual(s) with provable links to State owned bodies.

Rugby league especially in this this country needs men/ states with that money 

 

beggars can’t be choosers 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.


×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.