Jump to content

dealwithit

Coach
  • Posts

    590
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by dealwithit

  1. 1 hour ago, Dave T said:

    Hang on, aren't we talking about SL clubs London Broncos beibg kicked out? And Leigh being at risk despite their excellent 2023?

    And Toulouse are on the list to be elevated. 

    So tbh, I struggle to keep up. If this system is to protect the current teams, it ain't doing a brilliant job, and aren't the likes of London always treated like favourites, until they aren't? 

    I'm not convinced they have it right, which probably isn't a surprise for v1, but I don't doubt what they are trying to achieve. 

    Yeah good point. But the weighting on League position, tv ratings and crowds is substantial and any B grade club in championship will do it tough cracking the bottom SL clubs from ‘25 onwards — even if they produce players, are based in strategically important areas or have huge potential. If you’re not in SL you’re not on tv and you’re not attracting bigger crowds. Hard to compete. 

    • Like 1
  2. Couple quick observations:

    1. Regional academies should be run by the RFL

    2. Broncos will pick up IMG points for increased crowds, viewing numbers and revenue from their 2024 season. Probably not enough to stay up. 


    3. Most supported P&L with minimum standards ie. junior pathways, decent stadium, etc. Few thought the IMG gradings would be what they are: a way to nail in the existing SL clubs. 
     

    4. 2024 marks another missed opportunity in the narrative of RL. 

  3. London need additions. But they won’t lose the likes of Parata just because he needs to be a FT player. He has a successful project management company. The broncos have said they’ll accommodate players as best they can. Living in London, it would be no surprise for some of their squad to earn far more from non-SL income. 

  4. 2 minutes ago, Rovers13 said:

    If London are in top 16 clubs let alone close to c@s I will eat my shorts tbh lol. 

    Owner investment, catchment, academy, Stadium, etc. will probably score higher than some current SL clubs. Digital, no idea. Solvency, no idea. Performance in 2024 will have quite an impact. 

  5. 6 hours ago, Toby Chopra said:

    That's what people originally assumed, but it was clarified it is being done on overall grading score. A's plus the top scoring B's will make up Superleague, regardless of where they finish. That's why some of the Championship clubs voted against. 

    Well that contradicts comms from IMG. Do you have an article or press release you could share?

  6. 5 hours ago, The Phantom Horseman said:

    What do you mean "if they aren't relegated in 2024"? Their place in SL in 2025, like everyone else, will depend on whether they have one of the top 12 IMG scores. 

    No that’s not how it’s working. They’re not ranking every single club in order. They’re giving A, B and C grades. If you’re grade A you’ll be in SL. If you’re grade B and you finish bottom of SL you could be relegated if the championship winner is graded B too. 

    • Like 1
  7. On 12/10/2023 at 18:46, Toby Chopra said:

    The detailed scoring criteria have been published and most of them are things that are either in the public domain or we can make a very accurate stab at. We can work it out with 90% accuracy, and unless London do a Leigh in SL and Wakey crash and burn in the Championship it's almost impossible for them to stay up.

    https://www.rugby-league.com/uploads/docs/Grading Handbook (Final Version).pdf

    I’ve had a read and done some calculations. The part missing (or I’m blind) is the thresholds for Category A, B and C. Is this know? 
     

    scratch that. This article says 7.5 for B and 15 for A

    https://www.skysports.com/amp/rugby-league/news/12204/12860710/rugby-league-grading-criteria-radical-new-proposals-voted-in-by-majority-of-clubs

     

    That means London will probably be category B. If they aren’t relegated in 2024, hard to see them being punted for a category A team. There will be other B teams in SL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.