Ant

Poor from both tbh.

Wow. That is such a made up none existent penalty.

Hence my comment on the quality of reffing

On a par with the refereeing

They were, you're right, the tides have changed

Robbo has been on record at his frustration of how many players he developed were moved on by his predecessor

They were desperate to give a try to Cas then

If only it was a yellow every day

The more they replay Cas's second try, the more it looks like it should have been scrubbed off I hope Robbo is demanding an apology next week, clearly helps

With McGuires tantrum ringing in the VRs ears

If we'd have got a single extra set restart in the 2nd half last week - we'd have won that game, and lord knows, we should have had plenty

Things that should happen, but won't And don't they have a pathway to fill out the squad?

Clune has been exceptional between his injuries, imo. Frawley did exactly what he needed to, and will settle in more as he gets more training time and game minutes. As for Tom Burgess, he is still an exceptional forward, and if you can't see that you I'm going to suggest you don't know what a prop's job is. One stat stood out to me, which was the number of captains challenges the Giants have won. Was it 3 in this match? Surely suggests refs just do not give calls our way. (And I don't know what Milne has to do to win a set restart!) Anyway. Overdue win. Well earned, against a good team.

Which slows down the ruck, defence objective achieved by hands on, knees in, and other general interference - these things, like any 50/50 call, they rarely go 50/50 and we saw that in this game. Thats without then messing around with things like the defender running behind the player playing the ball, in front of the dummy half, or just happening to sit up just as the dummy half is about to pass - these are so rarely penalised, but it's still ruck interference.

I blame Luke Keary

I'm sure he played this season, then got a knock again It's hard to keep track of who was inured pre season, in game, in training...

It's not the first time, just like everyone else in the Giants squad he's had an injury- but he did play earlier this season

Catalans were poor, no doubt and Saints clearly the better side by a mile But, and I hate to be on MacNamara's side, Catalans really did get stuffed in some 50/50 calls, especially early on.

Giants a different team than even the start of this month but Rervers are in blistering form (and get every refs call going)

I've seen those called as offside, but imo it's a try

Catalans absolutely fleeced by that decision on all points

Forward a bloody mile

Set restarts absolutely are a shower Zero consistency

50 50 would be nice...

That's the game then.