Jump to content

Ray Cashmere

Coach
  • Posts

    253
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

Ray Cashmere last won the day on November 10 2021

Ray Cashmere had the most liked content!

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

Ray Cashmere's Achievements

423

Reputation

  1. At World Cup event tonight, Dave Woods suggested the broadcasting team will be announced next week and that there will be more RLWC games on BBC1 and 2 than FIFA World Cup Games (I think the number he gave was 31 but it sounded like this will be part of a press release/promotional drive).
  2. This is interesting. Given IMG produce Channel 4's league coverage, I'd hazard a guess that the "light-bulb moment" might have something to do with fan feedback and comparisons with Sky. Centralised production is probably suited to a sport like ours where we are positioned to complement the big names of football and cricket. Sky buy SL rights to fill out their service and retain subscriptions; if they can do so without the overheads associated with production then that must be a commercially attractive option for them.
  3. I’ve made my point elsewhere but this is the appropriate thread: the play offs reward the best teams over the course of the season. That is a statistical fact. And for those calling it ‘contrived’. That is, ironically, exactly what a regular season format in rugby league would look like. Rugby league would be out on its own in having zero incentive for teams to finish in any position that isn’t first/not last. The Premier League has CL and EL spots to compete for, the rest of the footballing pyramid has play offs. Just be very aware of what you are asking for: no competitive incentive to go and watch your team if they aren’t competing for top spot. How does that help to grow attendances and engage new audiences? Salford and Leeds won just over half their games this season. This narrative that all they had to do was win a couple of games in August to make the play offs is counter-factual.
  4. And under a regular league format this season- with only Wigan and Saints in realistic contention to finish top with half a dozen games left- what happens? It works in football because you still have Europe to play for. Unless you’re in serious contention for that top spot *every* league game then becomes meaningless: Leeds’ season over by May, Catalans’ by July. In fairness though, Wire’s season would still be over by March… Also, it is worth pointing out that the play offs do statistically reward the best teams: Unless we no longer want any unpredictability or narrative in our game…
  5. If teams want to take their foot off the gas just before the play offs then they’ll end up being knocked out. Salford have made the semis and Leeds the final because they’ve effectively been playing play off rugby for 2 months. The sooner people see the play offs make *more* games matter, due to the importance of momentum, the better. In a regular format, Leeds finish this season mid table and nothing to play for for months leading to sub-10k home crowds. Instead, they’ve had a sellout final home game and 3,000+ away days. In a sport so desperate for narratives, Leeds and Salford’s stories (so far) have provided them.
  6. It's no reflection on his career as a whole; he's been one of the outstanding English players of this century. Time catches up with everyone though and
  7. Based upon performances this season he shouldn't be anywhere near. Lost a yard of pace, failing to engage the line and even nervous under the high ball. It's a shame because he was outstanding last season. Hopefully he has just been conserving himself knowing the world cup is in view as there is no way that Wane does not pick him. So long as tonight was enough to put the nail in McIlorum's world cup coffin I'll be content.
  8. Young has plenty to work on (high ball and defensive reads particularly) but we don't have an athlete like him, plus his versatility to play centre is crucial given how small the tournament squads are required to be. His kick returns are also as good as anyones, something which will be especially important against Samoa. Makinson is an obvious guaranteed starter Handley would be in but I'm fairly certain he's now ruled out with injury. Tom Davies hasn't hit anything like last year's form. Liam Marshall has been excellent, but I'm concerned he's another 'very good SL, not test level' player. Burgess has been excellent and is more physically suited to test level than Marshall. Murphy looks a superstar but it's probably a year too soon. All in all, Young making at least the squad makes a lot of sense. Not because he's the finished article or because he plays in the NRL. However, he's coming off a good season and has genuinely world class attributes compared with a group of wingers who, bar Makinson, are not bona fide world class.
  9. Don't think it's as simple as that in this instance. As many have pointed out, the mid-tier categories (£45-£65 a ticket generally) have appeared quite broad on the stadium plans creating a disparity between a 'good' Category C seat and a 'bad' Category C seat, for instance. Those who bought early (like me) were able to get the best seats in our respective category. I'd have been a bit miffed paying the same amount for some of the other areas included in my category. Expanding Categories E and D to cover some of these poorer seats seems like a natural correction of the pricing strategy rather than an attempt to give as many tickets as possible away.
  10. Can't really fault the effort of the FC players today. Sao and Satae especially caused us big problems. Whilst we dominated the game it was a poor performance in the context of the last few weeks. Croft and Sneyd did their best to throw it away but they've more than earnt an off night. Luckily Brierley stepped up and was excellent.
  11. There will obviously be discussion around the Myler incident but it shouldn't distract from what was an absorbing game, brilliant atmosphere (on TV anyway) and good presentation by Sky. Watching tonight felt like the product that the sport aspires to be consistently. FWIW, I thought Huddersfield had enough territory and numerical superiority to win the game without any excuses and Leeds deserved it in the end for how game they were when Huddersfield were dominant.
  12. Exactly. I've not met many fellow fans who would have our number 8 Akauola in the 17. Vuniyayawa, Dupree and Luckley are 3 of our 4 best props. Livett undoubtedly starts and Wright (on the little we've seen this year due to injury) would also make the 17. Granted, we are lucky to have all our main backs (bar Sarginson whose loss hasn't really been felt with the form of Deon Cross) fit and this is where our strength has been but that does not mean we are full strength. I do think it's a strong enough side to get over the line on Saturday but we will need bodies back quickly with our post-Toulouse run of fixtures.
  13. Some great talent but I think Newman, Dodd and Welsby are the 3 that are special already whilst Young and KPP have the raw attributes to become special but are some distance off fulfilling their potential yet. I'd also add Morgan Smithies, Morgan Gannon, Lewis Murphy & Ethan Havard to the wider list.
  14. That is true but you also had Bousquet and Kasiano back whilst we were without King & Dupree (2 of our best 3 props) and 2 of our best 3 back rowers in Livett & Wright. I think most Salford fans feared the worse when both 17s were announced given your strength in depth but you completely lost the energy battle imo.
×
×
  • Create New...