Mushy

Coach
  • Content count

    298
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

193 Excellent

Recent Profile Visitors

2,489 profile views
  1. Australia to Play Tonga in Qatar?

    That’d be brilliant but I suspect most of the dosh will go elsewhere.
  2. Australia to Play Tonga in Qatar?

    Comedy gold this from the Aussies. Wouldn’t have been so bad taking the dosh if they weren’t so two faced. No one will be in the stadium, it won’t get close to helping develop the game like the same match In australasia, but they’ll make some money so it’s ok. Now if the RLIF were getting the money to actually develop the game I might be able to see the point but after they’ve spent their billion dollar TV money Australia probably do need a bit more cash. Could have been worse, they could have played in Saudi or Dubai, although they have seriously considered the last one in a rather shameful dose of amnesia after our guy in the UAE was jailed.
  3. New Wolfpack Signing??

    TWP after Lussick from Manly? A tad more expensive than Springer though.
  4. Huddersfield's tin can/cowbell

    Gateshead Thunder had some steel drums and stuff at their home games in 1999 and they were loads of fun. I’d stick with them if the majority of the Giants fans are supportive. The Thunder also had their ‘windy man’ that inflated after a score plus a very entertaining play list. Plus their fans developed a few chants of their own as anyone who was at Tynecastle that year could testify.
  5. Gareth O’Brien off to Toronto

    Should play fullback for TWP. Been excellent for Salford there and as good as QLT is at running the ball he’s not a standout at this level at #1.
  6. Worth exploring further I think. In terms of producing players and having teams where the game is supported then Cumbria ticks the boxes. Might never be a top club without shed loads of money but could be in the mix and add more diversity to the top flight. The stadium would be an issue, although if the new ground on the west coast is finally built that would be a good home, and it wouldn’t be a bad idea to play at the other championship grounds too. Whether Marwan is the right man or quite how the business plan will ever totally stack up I don’t know. A good spring/summer/autumn destination for away fans which would help boost the local economy (not many visitors venture much west of Windermere currently) so maybe there’s be buy-in and support from other stakeholders in the region though.
  7. You’ve got to separate his performances from character and attitude. We saw evidence of the former, and can only speculate on the latter. He seemed to lose any impact when he slimmed down, and impact was his whole game. He could have worked his socks off and either just not had it any more or maybe the training he was doing was counterproductive. Oz players often comment on the different physiques of players after a year or two in the SL, maybe he’s another example of one it just didn’t suit. Good luck to him in Newcastle, I hope it works out for him and his family.
  8. Thank you for the detailed critique on my post. Seems you disagree with pretty much everything I’ve written, which is of course fine, although you can do that without patronisingly telling someone they are letting themselves down, though! Pretty sure I wasn’t ranting either, and my comment about a club from another sport wanting to invest in our sport would have been valid even if a soccer club were looking to do the same.
  9. Agreed. He was awful last year. What was interesting was that apparently he slimmed down this year - or Wigan slimmed him down - in the mistaken belief that this would make him more effective. Take a look at the NRL packs and they are massively powerful but not necessarily lean as you still need the weight to make a dent in the defensive line. It was again an observation of the NRL teams and you saw it during the World Cup - the antipodean based players make more ground on impact than ours, which largely comes down to appropriate conditioning. FPN was incredible at times in the NRL, Wigan picked him up when he was on a decline, he played a few half decent matches before losing any remaining NRL power and becoming a very ordinary overpaid player.
  10. Pretty sure it the Newcastle rugby clubs share the same owner rather than the union club owning the league club. Subtle but important difference. Also, having been an investor in Gateshead previously myself, the relationship between the codes in that area is quite different to many other parts of the UK with little animosity and a greater acceptance of League for what it is. It’s a digression I know, but if the Thunder had received the same funding as the other Super League clubs it was not too much of an extrapolation to see the initial investment having been enough to stave off the merger and make them break even within three years, and hence they might have been a major club in the game by now. They were owned and run by Leaguies rather than someone who wanted to use a venue or expand a brand importantly. Worthwhile understanding this when some think we’ve tried expansion and it’s failed. We’ve barely tried at all, and in almost all cases the game hasn’t put its money where it’s mouth is and committed to making ventures a success, reluctantly sharing meagre levels of TV revenue with new clubs at all levels who have rarely had the resources to see it through on their own. I’m really not sure about where Coventry sits in all this - the Bears will be Leaguies wanting their club to be a long term success. Wasps getting involved will want a return sharpish to fund their primary business however. I disagree about Toronto though - it’s owned and run by people who are now Leaguies and aren’t using this as a means to another sporting end. Sure they won’t have a bottomless pit of money but their pockets are sufficiently deep to see this through. Plus there aren’t any negative brand associations with the sport there that there appear to be elsewhere through exposure to union and its press.
  11. If you doubled the money in the sport you’d still have clubs going under - take a look at the NRL club finances despite vastly more revenue than in the UK. Clubs are historically very poor at managing finances and regardless of where any club ends up they will need to cut their cloth accordingly. The level of funding just provides a level below which teams have to be part time or a blend of part time. Clubs in League 1 without any central funding might end up as semi-amateur, and that’s not necessarily any bad thing. Generating more income at the top level is more to do with being able to attract and retain exciting talent against rival comps/codes, which makes a lot of sense however you achieve it.
  12. Northerners being chippy? Who’d have thought it?
  13. Well I’ve enjoyed the whole venture, something different and a bit of fun. Unlike the Leeds match on Friday, yesterday’s games were indeed trials so you can’t read too much into them. Wigan have done really badly in trials in the UK for a few years as their whole game depends on intensity. It was disappointing to see Souths backs run so strongly and Wigan’s lot struggle to catch the ball, but entertaining enough TV over breakfast nevertheless. I think Souths will be a strong team this year for what it’s worth. I also think Wigan might have a chance of winning SL.
  14. This has gone off on a bit of a tangent hasn’t it! Perhaps it’s all down to how we define trials and friendlies but the same old stuff gets dragged out each year. IF this were a trial then it still manages to stir up interest even amongst people who would belittle it which itself is interesting! My personal take on a friendly or trial game is one in which the result itself is not important, whereas the performance and progress of the team is what the coaches and staff are mainly looking at. Obviously I don’t know for sure but I’d wager both teams will want to win this game and will treat it very competitively. It almost certainly means more to the SL sides than the NRL sides who are also looking to use it to hone their performance for their main goal of winning their Premiership. But that still doesn’t make it a trial or friendly in my book, far from it! Onto the game itself, I fear Leed’s chances of victory have dwindled to not a lot following the parochial decision to switch from International officiating. A quite bizarre decision but entirely consistent alas. Still, Come on Leeds!
  15. I agree it’s very unlikely that Leeds will win but in a one off anything can happen. I’d probably go with a 12 point start if I were betting man which I’m not. The point I was clumsily making was actually in response to this which would be a bit harsh given last year’s result.