Click

The referee deliberations aren't where the game has changed from when they were playing/coaching to make them useless at commentating on it. It's just the rules in general.

Apparently the BBC are happy with it, so that is all that matters.

Can you find 2 or 3 other people that are fine with the standard of analysts the BBC are currently using? No one has mentioned Shortle.

The fans aren't the ones who matter? Who are the BBC broadcasting this for exactly?

Have you actually listened to the commentary today? Kear, Noble, Davies add absolutely nothing apart from misinformation about the modern game.

A real shame Williams is missing for this - could have really made this game a close one.

Probably because they're mostly all awful?

Why do we need to even make it a penalty - just say its a knock on. He makes the error with Hiku's involvement playing no part whatsoever.

I've re-watched it a few times now, I think it was an early call by the referee to be honest.

That's poor defence to let Gildart run through your line.

Well, first I think he was probably tackled in the air by the Warrington player, and then when he goes down and the warrington players touch him there is no momentum until they then decide to drag him back, Probably 50/50 about if you can do it or not.

Ok? So it was a personal post .. Sorry for not getting the inside joke I guess.

The referee calls him held when he hits the ground - all the afters of being pulled back and dropping it happens after the held call.

And Bentley gives away another penalty

Who retires in RL all the time? I don't understand this post.