Quarter Season Review

[Tommygilf]

All clubs in Super League have played either 7 or 8 league games now (plus cup) which is roughly a quarter of the season.

How would you rate each team's start? A* to F?

[Barry Badrinath]

Warrington:

joint top of the table, knocked saints out the cup, only defeated in fairly competitive games by catalans.

 

i'd give us a C

 

its definitely not our year.

[phiggins]

Leigh. Only one win, and several injuries, some of which may be related to the club's pre season departures in the backroom staff. At least two wins thrown away.

Grade E

 

[Griff]

1 minute ago, phiggins said:

Leigh. Only one win, and several injuries, some of which may be related to the club's pre season departures in the backroom staff. At least two wins thrown away.

Grade E

 

Poor old Harry.

[sam4731]

Catalans- B

Saints- C

Wigan- B

Warrington- A

Hull KR- B

Huddersfield- C

Salford- C

Leeds- D

Leigh- F

Castleford- F

Hull FC- F

London- E

 

[tiffers]

4 hours ago, sam4731 said:

Catalans- B

Saints- C

Wigan- B

Warrington- A

Hull KR- B

Huddersfield- C

Salford- C

Leeds- D

Leigh- F

Castleford- F

Hull FC- F

London- E

 

Agree with everything you've got here, except I would give Wigan an A. That win over Penrith was pretty decent and enough for an A at this stage, given their league standings.

A D might be a little on the generous side for Leeds.

[sam4731]

5 minutes ago, tiffers said:

Agree with everything you've got here, except I would give Wigan an A. That win over Penrith was pretty decent and enough for an A at this stage, given their league standings.

A D might be a little on the generous side for Leeds.

I was on the fence with Wigan but looking at it with fresh eyes I think I would revise it to an A.

I think a D for Leeds is fair though. It reflects how, even through mediocrity, they are so far ahead of the chasing pack.

[Wellsy4HullFC]

Catalans- B

Saints- B

Wigan- A

Warrington- A

Hull KR- C

Huddersfield- C

Salford- C

Leeds- D

Leigh- E

Castleford- F

Hull FC- F

London- E

[daz39]

Huddersfield - 6th place in the league, Semi final of the cup, scoring points for fun especially away from home (198 in the last 5) and with a huge confidence running through the players and coaches.

I'd give us a B, if were comparing to last year.

[Archie Gordon]

SL as a whole - C-

Failure to follow through on pre-season feel-good factor or take much advantage of every game on TV.

BBC deal just hasn't delivered.

SL+ subscriptions look low.

London feels like an albatross.

Some sensational encounters at the top of the comp.

Wigan are WC champions.

[MZH]

I don't think you can grade Hull. We've dropped out and gone to work in Burger King.

[Loiner]

A Warrington and Wigan 

B  Catalans 

C  Saints, Hull kr

D Huddersfield, Salford 

E Rhinos 

F Hull, Cas, Leigh and Broncos. 

 

 

[sam4731]

1 hour ago, Archie Gordon said:

SL as a whole - C-

Failure to follow through on pre-season feel-good factor or take much advantage of every game on TV.

BBC deal just hasn't delivered.

SL+ subscriptions look low.

London feels like an albatross.

Some sensational encounters at the top of the comp.

Wigan are WC champions.

I think a C is generous. I'd go a weak D.