Current World XIII

[JM2010 483]

Thought I might as well stick to the theme of picking a XIII based on certain criteria.

This one is based on the current best players in their position from recent form.

I need to have a think before I come up with mine.

I'll start with Taumalolo at 13

[JM2010 483]

Tedesco at fullback and Cameron Smith at 9. They're my 3 easy ones

[DavidM 10,030]

Josh Papali

[Number 16 1,502]

Munster at #6 for me. 

Nelson A-S on the bench. 

Edited September 19 by Number 16

[bobbruce 2,645]

1/ Tedesco

2/ 

3/ 

4/ 

5/ Addo Carr

6/ Pongia

7/ 

8/ Hargreaves

9/ Smith

10/ Papali

11/ Fifita (Broncos)

12/ 

13/

[DavidM 10,030]

Current form David Naufaluma . Liam Martin outstanding every week . Nathan Cleary . Fisher Harris with Papali for me. Jack Wighton getting in top form

Edited September 19 by DavidM

[bobbruce 2,645]

Kikau

[Dunbar 8,967]

1. Tesdesco

2. Addo-Carr

3. Manu

4. Crichton

5. Naufaluma

6. Keary

7. Cleary

8. Klemmer

9. Smith

10. Papalii

11. Kikau 

12. Fifita

13. Taumalolo

[DavidM 10,030]

1. Tedesco. 
2. Josh Addo - The Fox. 
3. Manu.  
4. Crichton.  
5. Naufaluma   
6. Wighton. 
7. Cleary. 
8. Fisher Harris. 
9. Koroisau   
10. Papali.  
11. Kikau.  
12. Martin
13. JT

[AB90 171]

John Bateman a shout (maybe on the bench).

Mika Sivo

 

[Davo5 4,498]

Tedesco

Addo-Carr

Morris

Manu

Sivo

Keary

Cleary

Walmsley

Grant

Papali

Kikau

Bateman

Taumalolo

[DavidM 10,030]

I forgot Bateman , I’m taking JT out and putting him in 

[Mr Frisky 885]

I think any current world team must have Alex Walmsley in it - Sl isnt that bad folks. 

[Dunbar 8,967]

32 minutes ago, DavidM said:

I forgot Bateman , I’m taking JT out and putting him in 

At 13? Bateman is great on the edge as his footwork and unpredictability is difficult to defend against. But its a big call to take out the worlds best middle forward and replace him with someone who never plays there.

[DavidM 10,030]

18 minutes ago, Dunbar said:

At 13? Bateman is great on the edge as his footwork and unpredictability is difficult to defend against. But its a big call to take out the worlds best middle forward and replace him with someone who never plays there.

In this theoretical side that’s never gonna play I’m putting him there to get him in . I think he’ll be chuffed to be selected in a world 13 to take on anything the universe has to offer 

[Man of Kent 7,025]

Tedesco

Tupou

Tom Trbojevic

Manu

Addo-Carr

Munster

Keary

Papalii

Smith

Haas

Graham

Bateman

Jake Trbojevic

[Harry Stottle 3,786]

The most honest prop running around at the moment is Reagan Campbell Graham, he would be my first choice prop.

[Davo5 4,498]

5 minutes ago, Harry Stottle said:

The most honest prop running around at the moment is Reagan Campbell Graham, he would be my first choice prop.

Think that Reagan Campbell-Gillard is better H

[Davo5 4,498]

1 hour ago, Man of Kent said:

Tedesco

Tupou

Tom Trbojevic

Manu

Addo-Carr

Munster

Keary

Papalii

Smith

Haas

Graham

Bateman

Jake Trbojevic

Given the amount of the season he's missed I'm not sure Tom Trbojevic would get into a world XIII in a position he never plays.

[yipyee 947]

Australia are not that good, this is why they have avoided playing England.

England matched Aus in the last world cup final and was edged out (albeit a few years ago)

I am amazed at the constant underestimation of the English players both NRL based and UK!

If Australia where man enough to play us we would see but whilst they continue to run and hide it perpetuates the myth

[Man of Kent 7,025]

7 minutes ago, Davo5 said:

Given the amount of the season he's missed I'm not sure Tom Trbojevic would get into a world XIII in a position he never plays.

Apart from for Australia and New South Wales

[Scubby 11,704]

There would be no England players in the World XIII at present. Sad to say that at the moment but it is true. Bateman is no where near the form he was in last year. 

[Davo5 4,498]

15 minutes ago, Man of Kent said:

Apart from for Australia and New South Wales

2 games for NSW 12 months ago hardly qualifies for  inclusion in a current world team but each to his own.

Edited September 19 by Davo5

[Dunbar 8,967]

21 minutes ago, yipyee said:

Australia are not that good, this is why they have avoided playing England.

England matched Aus in the last world cup final and was edged out (albeit a few years ago)

I am amazed at the constant underestimation of the English players both NRL based and UK!

If Australia where man enough to play us we would see but whilst they continue to run and hide it perpetuates the myth

Which English players would you include in a world 13 at the moment?

[AB90 171]

1 hour ago, Scubby said:

There would be no England players in the World XIII at present. Sad to say that at the moment but it is true. Bateman is no where near the form he was in last year. 

I think your been a bit harsh on Bateman. Thought hes been great since hes come back from injury. But yes, maybe not one of the two best, form edge back rowers in the world.

It's hard to rate the top level SL players in comparison to their nrl counterparts when the the majority of SL players would be reserve graders down under playing in either the NSW or QLD cup competitions.