Sat 3rd Oct Coral RL Challenge Cup SF : Salford Red Devils v Warrington Wolves KO 17:00 BBC

[graveyard johnny 2,503]

Just now, Ullman said:

Well done Welham there.

i was talking about watkins (as you know) bone idle- not heard his name mentioned as yet- may need to turn the sound off- robinson is the annoying bloke in the pub that spoils your enjoyment of the game

[LeeF 2,197]

1 minute ago, Hughsehhh said:

Can someone explain to me why Inu's kick wasn't deemed a 40/20?

Because it went into touch outside the 20

[Old Frightful 6,355]

1 minute ago, Dave T said:

Surely that's a yellow

Good to see the RFL reads this forum.

[Cheshire Setter 1,299]

Don’t remember McCarthy being such an idiot in his early days at Warrington 

[Barry Badrinath 308]

The commentator is a bit of a pain, he sounds like he's describing a yawnion match.

 

Phases?

 

Recycling? 

[Dave T 18,647]

Just now, Old Frightful said:

Good to see the RFL reads this forum.

About time somebody listened to me.... 

[Ullman 2,013]

1 minute ago, graveyard johnny said:

i was talking about watkins (as you know) bone idle- not heard his name mentioned as yet- may need to turn the sound off- robinson is the annoying bloke in the pub that spoils your enjoyment of the game

Think you might have quoted the wrong post(er) there.

[Old Frightful 6,355]

Just now, LeeF said:

Because it went into touch outside the 20

I must have missed the camera angle that proved this.

[Barry Badrinath 308]

Just now, Old Frightful said:

Good to see the RFL reads this forum.

They didn't even consult just browny

[Old Frightful 6,355]

Just now, Cheshire Setter said:

Don’t remember McCarthy being such an idiot in his early days at Warrington 

He's been at Hull KR since then though.

[Barry Badrinath 308]

Just now, Old Frightful said:

I must have missed the camera angle that proved this.

they haven't got a camera on the ref, who decided it wasnt

[Dave T 18,647]

1 minute ago, LeeF said:

Because it went into touch outside the 20

I must admit first viewing I thought it was a 40:20, but the last replay did show it bounced a funny angle. We need to remember that the ref will have had a good angle, and Salford didn't appear to argue. 

[LeeF 2,197]

1 minute ago, Dave T said:

About time somebody listened to me.... 

There’s always a first time

[Padge 6,519]

1 minute ago, Cheshire Setter said:

Don’t remember McCarthy being such an idiot in his early days at Warrington 

Once they had taught him to be an idiot they moved him on.

[Just Browny 7,392]

Didn't enjoy that by McCarthy, a player I have always liked and admired.

[Padge 6,519]

1 minute ago, Dave T said:

About time somebody listened to me.... 

Who said that?

[graveyard johnny 2,503]

straight through watkins side for the 1st try at least he got a mention

[Ullman 2,013]

1 minute ago, Old Frightful said:

He's been at Hull KR since then though.

Good point well made.

[Old Frightful 6,355]

1 minute ago, Dave T said:

I must admit first viewing I thought it was a 40:20, but the last replay did show it bounced a funny angle. We need to remember that the ref will have had a good angle, and Salford didn't appear to argue. 

Doesn't mean that we can't though.

Up yours clever ar$e.

[bobbruce 2,862]

4 minutes ago, Old Frightful said:

That looked close to being a 40/20, why didn't they check?

Think they can only check that’s it’s been kicked from within the 40. Where it goes out can’t be checked as it’s almost impossible to tell. 

[Barry Badrinath 308]

2 minutes ago, bobbruce said:

Think they can only check that’s it’s been kicked from within the 40. Where it goes out can’t be checked as it’s almost impossible to tell. 

Yes that's true, the ref is the judge of where it goes out, he has the best angle usually

[Hughsehhh 335]

Watkins has scored, where's graveyard Johnny?

[Padge 6,519]

Watkins did that perfectly.

[Ullman 2,013]

Agree with Davies, great judgement from Watkins.

[Man of Kent 8,001]

Really enjoying Luke Robinson’s tactical insight. Much better than dumbing down as if nobody had ever seen a game of rugby before