Sun 1st Sept : SL : Huddersfield Giants v St Helens KO 15:00 Sky Sports+ BBC2 BBC iPlayer

[Barca Mum]

Hard game to watch neither side playing well and the woman commentator making it worse

[Old Frightful]

Ridiculous decision, hardly late.

[Futtocks]

 

[Barry Badrinath]

Virtually identical to vaughan's

[phiggins]

Poor challenge from Rogers, that’ll probably cost them the game  

[Old Frightful]

Well, how can they say no mitigation, he fell into it.

[Loiner]

Not even a yellow card that.

[JohnM]

3 minutes ago, phiggins said:

Poor challenge from Rogers, that’ll probably cost them the game  

I think so. The red card was given after a detailed look at the incident so hardly a knee- jerk reaction, but it certainly looked a harsh decision.

[Ant]

Absolutely abysmal red. 

[Ant]

Just now, JohnM said:

I think so. The red card was given after a detailed look at the incident so hardly a knee- jerk reaction, but it certainly looked a harsh decision.

Given Naqama got punched in the face by Blake and nothing more than a penalty, its am abysmal call.

[bromleybulldog]

Nonsense decision to send off the Huddersfield player there. Didn't even look like a yellow to me

[daz39]

52 minutes ago, Agbrigg said:

By the look of the crowd, it seems like the vast majority of The Huddersfield public are also not aware there is a game on. 

 

Are the vast majority of most towns and cities general public aware when their home town team is playing? 

What a silly thimg to say unless most towns have a population of under 20,000

[daz39]

Harsh red card but that's the sanitised ###### we have these days unfortunately. 

1st thing I noticed was the player was getting up and the physio seemed to push him back to the ground and told him to stay down, I will need to watch it back but I'm fairly sure that's what I saw, if it was then that sums up the game these days. 

 

[phiggins]

3 minutes ago, daz39 said:

Harsh red card but that's the sanitised ###### we have these days unfortunately. 

1st thing I noticed was the player was getting up and the physio seemed to push him back to the ground and told him to stay down, I will need to watch it back but I'm fairly sure that's what I saw, if it was then that sums up the game these days. 

 

Not sure there’s an issue of a physio is telling somebody to stay on the floor. Play has stopped and VR review started by then anyway?

[JohnM]

3 minutes ago, daz39 said:

Harsh red card but that's the sanitised ###### we have these days unfortunately. 

1st thing I noticed was the player was getting up and the physio seemed to push him back to the ground and told him to stay down, I will need to watch it back but I'm fairly sure that's what I saw, if it was then that sums up the game these days. 

 

I know. What's happened to our sport when a qualified and experienced physio puts the well-being of a player who might have sustained a neck or head injury ahead of continuing the play?

[phiggins]

I think once Saints score one this second half, a few more will quickly follow 

[Old Frightful]

"The lines gave it away" suggests the commentator regarding a forward pass.

When will professional commentators learn?

 

[Old Frightful]

2 minutes ago, phiggins said:

I think once Saints score one this second half, a few more will quickly follow 

It's looking a bit like that.

[phiggins]

1 minute ago, Old Frightful said:

It's looking a bit like that.

Horror start from Hudds with their handling (or lack of)

[JohnM]

34 minutes ago, Barca Mum said:

Hard game to watch neither side playing well and the woman commentator making it worse

That's no way to talk about Kevin Brown.

[Barry Badrinath]

Oof that was forward

[JonNgog]

Huddersfield demonstrating exactly how not to play with 12 men

[DavidM]

Video refs see something clearly then  think other angles are going to show something totally different 

[Barca Mum]

2 minutes ago, JohnM said:

That's no way to talk about Kevin Brown.

Haha didn't realise it was on BBC 2 was watching on terrible pictures on Sky+

[Just Browny]

Even at Knowsley Road the ref would have considered giving that forward.