RBKnight 113 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 I've now heard Tony Rea as the summariser on two York Knights games this year on OurLeague/Sportsman - for my money he is miles ahead of his counterparts on BBC and Sky. His comments and analysis genuinely add something to the broadcasts to my ears. What do other folk think ? 12 Link to post Share on other sites
Hela Wigmen 2,994 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 I always used to quite like Tony Rea on Sky, I thought he was quite good. He was certainly better than what we’re accustomed to now. 6 Link to post Share on other sites
Blind side johnny 6,631 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 He has always been a pleasure to listen to. He has insights that seem to evade others, despite them also having played the game. Having said that I prefer to hear him as a rare treat rather than for him to become homogenised by too much exposure to the corporate broadcasters. 4 Sport, amongst other things, is a dream-world offering escape from harsh reality and the disturbing prospect of change. Link to post Share on other sites
Dave T 18,706 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 I always thought he was OK, although I don't find his voice easy on the ear. A bit too whiney and downbeat for my liking. I don't think the benchmark should be 'better than Barrie andnTez', but unfortunately it is. 5 Link to post Share on other sites
DoubleD 6,208 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 2 minutes ago, Dave T said: I always thought he was OK, although I don't find his voice easy on the ear. A bit too whiney and downbeat for my liking. I don't think the benchmark should be 'better than Barrie andnTez', but unfortunately it is. Agreed. He is knowledgeable and insightful but unfortunately his dreary tone does lead towards him sounding like he’s droning on. There are others that are better Link to post Share on other sites
Dave T 18,706 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 2 minutes ago, DoubleD said: Agreed. He is knowledgeable and insightful but unfortunately his dreary tone does lead towards him sounding like he’s droning on. There are others that are better I really prefer the BBCs approach of rotating guests and experts. Let's be honest, the ones there now don't say anything new, we can predict exactly what they are going to say. Link to post Share on other sites
RBKnight 113 Posted April 10 Author Report Share Posted April 10 4 minutes ago, DoubleD said: Agreed. He is knowledgeable and insightful but unfortunately his dreary tone does lead towards him sounding like he’s droning on. There are others that are better Genuine question - who do you rate ? Got to say that his tone doesn't bother me at all. Link to post Share on other sites
meast 1,856 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 I like him, he does waffle on a bit though ,but it's insightful and educational, interesting waffle. He does go the long way around explaining the tactical nuances of the game, which for many people is far better than some thick sounding northerner shouting " ooof" "SHOOOOTTT" "quality" etc 3 https://www.facebook.com/HuddersfieldSA Link to post Share on other sites
DoubleD 6,208 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 21 minutes ago, RBKnight said: Genuine question - who do you rate ? Got to say that his tone doesn't bother me at all. As a summariser, I would say Wilkin, Wells or Clarke. A lot don’t like Clarke, not sure why. Often less is more with summarisers, you don’t want someone wittering on (Wilkin can be prone to this at times). We’re certainly not blessed with good summarisers or commentators. I’ve always found Kevin Brown and Danny McGuire quite insightful as pundits. I wonder if Brown would consider a future career in media when he retires from playing 2 Link to post Share on other sites
RBKnight 113 Posted April 10 Author Report Share Posted April 10 1 minute ago, DoubleD said: I’ve always found Kevin Brown and Danny McGuire quite insightful as pundits. I wonder if Brown would consider a future career in media when he retires from playing Agree with you on Kevin Brown, from what I've heard from him on R5 2 Link to post Share on other sites
LittleboroRoughyed 85 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 I thought the Sportsman coverage of York last night was very good and the commentator + Tony Rea made a refreshing change 3 Link to post Share on other sites
David Dockhouse Host 73 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 I like him, he talks through a coaches perspective and talks about what the teams are aiming to do 4 Link to post Share on other sites
Oxford 5,239 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 1 hour ago, Dave T said: I don't think the benchmark should be 'better than Barrie andnTez', but unfortunately it is. The trouble is, whoever you put on regularly, fans will moan about them. I have always thought Tony Rea was great as a summariser. The Sporstman production surprised me with how good it was all round. 3 Link to post Share on other sites
Hela Wigmen 2,994 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 55 minutes ago, DoubleD said: As a summariser, I would say Wilkin, Wells or Clarke. A lot don’t like Clarke, not sure why. Often less is more with summarisers, you don’t want someone wittering on (Wilkin can be prone to this at times). We’re certainly not blessed with good summarisers or commentators. I’ve always found Kevin Brown and Danny McGuire quite insightful as pundits. I wonder if Brown would consider a future career in media when he retires from playing If all we’ve got to hope for is Clarke, Wilkin or Wells, I despair. 1 Link to post Share on other sites
RBKnight 113 Posted April 10 Author Report Share Posted April 10 33 minutes ago, David Dockhouse Host said: I like him, he talks through a coaches perspective and talks about what the teams are aiming to do Definitely still has his coaches' head on - when he was criticising the direction of York's misfiring attack against Toulouse, I was half-hoping that he'd slip a tracksuit on, appear as a water-carrier on the pitch, and have a word with our half-backs 1 2 Link to post Share on other sites
Blind side johnny 6,631 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 3 hours ago, Dave T said: I really prefer the BBCs approach of rotating guests and experts. Let's be honest, the ones there now don't say anything new, we can predict exactly what they are going to say. Do you mean like Jamie Peacock today saying that "Leeds will be looking for some good hormones"? 1 Sport, amongst other things, is a dream-world offering escape from harsh reality and the disturbing prospect of change. Link to post Share on other sites
Manfred Mann 1,258 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 (edited) 4 hours ago, RBKnight said: I've now heard Tony Rea as the summariser on two York Knights games this year on OurLeague/Sportsman - for my money he is miles ahead of his counterparts on BBC and Sky. His comments and analysis genuinely add something to the broadcasts to my ears. What do other folk think ? I agree. Tony Rea is cool, calm and masterful. He is light years ahead of Barrie McDermott, Terry O’Connor, and Phil Clarke. The only Sky commentator who comes close is the Irish law school graduate Brian Carney. Tony Rea is a breath of fresh air. Tony Rea is, of course, an Australian. Edited April 10 by Manfred Mann Link to post Share on other sites
Oxford 5,239 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 31 minutes ago, Blind side johnny said: "Leeds will be looking for some good hormones"? I think he meant pheromones! Link to post Share on other sites
fighting irish 1,914 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 34 minutes ago, Oxford said: I think he meant pheromones! It was comical. Ticked me. I was surprised none of the others referred to it. Lol. Link to post Share on other sites
Southern Reiver 153 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 I think Rea is a good summariser. Elsewhere John Kear on the BBC is one of the better ones though can lapse on occasions. Rea has a nice turn on being on the dance floor when they get into the 20m area, it conjures up a view of where the action is. Success consists of going from failure to failure without loss of enthusiasm. Link to post Share on other sites
Morris Wanchuk 77 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 I’d listen to Tony Rae everyday of the week before the names mentioned previously. 3 Link to post Share on other sites
Oxford 5,239 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 Funny, I don't mind anyone so long as they're talking about RL. 1 Link to post Share on other sites
Wellsy4HullFC 4,423 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 He's always you something good to add. I just think he lacks any sort of enthusiasm at all though. He's kinda boring. Link to post Share on other sites
Wellsy4HullFC 4,423 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 Concerning defensive formation from Hull this second half. Where were the wingers then? Link to post Share on other sites
moorside roughyed 3,244 Posted April 10 Report Share Posted April 10 I liked Tony's commentary. I also liked sportsman's production. Link to post Share on other sites
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now